Name: 亞歷克斯·普雷蒂的死刑讓我心碎！💔 (The Execution of Alex Pretti Broke Me)
Uploaded: 2026-01-27T16:23:36.000Z
Duration: 12 min 38 s

情態副詞

I know all of us have seen the videos of what is basically the execution of Alex Preddy.

我知道我們都看過 Alex Preddy 被處決的影片。

I've seen it from more angles and more times than I care to repeat.

我看過的角度和次數，多到不想再說了。

I'm not going to give an in depth, frame by frame analysis.

我不會做深入的 frame by frame 分析。

You don't need a lawyer to tell you what you can see with your own eyes, which is that it was an inexcusable state sanctioned murder.

你不需要律師告訴你眼睛看到的，那就是一個無法辯解的 state sanctioned murder。

And it is the latest in what is probably a long line.

這只是漫長隊伍中的最新一個。

This one happens to have been videotaped, thankfully, by many brave bystanders.

幸好，這次被許多勇敢的 bystanders videotaped 了。

你可以看得出來，我不在我的 studio。

It's 0 degrees, which is still 10 degrees warmer than it is in Minneapolis right now.

現在是零度，比明尼阿波利斯現在的溫度還暖和十度。

I analyze the videos that are out there and think about things from a legal perspective.

我會分析現有的影片，從法律觀點去思考。

But, you know, with any video taken from across the street, there's some ambiguity.

但是，你知道的，任何從街對面拍的影片，都會有些模糊性。

In the second video, you can hear that Alex Preddy's last words were, are you okay?

在第二支影片裡，你可以聽到 Alex Preddy 最後一句話是「妳還好嗎？」

That was next to him who had been pushed down by the ICE or CPP officer who was acting unhinged, where Alex Preddy just has his phone out and his left arm is free.

那位被 ICE 或 CPP officer 推倒的女士聽的，那位 officer 表現得很 unhinged，而 Alex Preddy 只是拿出手機，左手是自由的。

I think those were his last acts, was trying to help the woman that was pushed down by the man in the.

我想那是他最後的舉動，就是試圖去幫助那位被那個穿。

In the green sweatshirt, who I think eventually was the first.

穿綠色帽 T 的男人推倒的女士，我想他最後就是。

to my eyes, you know, the last thing that Alex Brady did was to help others.

And look, my legal analysis doesn't change when the victim is, you know, a bank robber or a saint.

而且你看，我的法律分析不會因為受害者是銀行搶匪或聖人而改變。

每個人都應該享有相同的權利。

And it doesn't justify or justify less the actions of what happened, but

這並不能合理化或減輕所發生的事情，但

it does heighten the loss of what happened and the people whose rights are being taken away and their lives are being taken away.

它確實加劇了所發生的事情的損失，以及那些權利被剝奪、生命被剝奪的人們的損失。

So, look, I'm going to try and gather some thoughts, which I'm only going to do because I think a lot of people are thinking the same thing, whether you're a lawyer or a layperson.

所以，你看，我會試著整理一些想法，我之所以這麼做，是因為我覺得很多人都有同樣的想法，無論你是律師還是普通人。

I think we're all absolutely enraged, not only by the loss of Alex Preddy, but

我覺得我們都非常憤怒，不僅僅是因為 Alex Preddy 的離世，

Renee Goode and everyone else who has been pushed aside and has been Caught in this web of what is clearly illegal action from our federal government.

還有 Renee Goode 和其他所有被排擠、被捲入我們聯邦政府明顯非法行為的網羅中的人。

It doesn't change the legal analysis, but

it does say something that Alex Preddy and Renee Goode before him seem to be the best, the best of us.

這確實說明瞭一點，Alex Preddy 和他之前的 Renee Goode 似乎是我們之中最好的人。

And there's a reason why they were gunned down.

It's because they put themselves out there.

We need to continue to stand up because they did too.

我們需要繼續站出來，因為他們也是這麼做的。

And look, you don't need to be a lawyer to know that their shootings were not justified.

看看，你不需要是律師也能知道，他們被槍殺是不對的。

But I think we need to take a step back too, to recognize that, you know, ICE and CBP shouldn't have been there in the first place.

但我覺得我們也需要退一步，認識到，你知道，ICE 和 CBP 一開始就不應該出現在那裡。

They have no right and no duty to do crowd control, to be on the front lines using weapons against protesters.

他們沒有權利也沒有義務去控制人群，去站在第一線對抗議者使用武器。

But they are not enforcing criminal law even when they are enforcing immigration laws, which they are not.

但他們即使在執行移民法時，也沒有執行刑法，而他們根本就沒有在執行移民法。

Right now it is state sponsored protest control of people exercising their First Amendment rights.

現在這是在國家贊助下，控制行使第一修正案權利的人民。

best, they are enforcing regulatory and civil laws.

最多，他們是在執行監管和民事法律。

And there's no reason they should have firearms in the first place.

而且他們根本就不應該配備槍枝。

They, I don't even think should have less lethals like pepper balls.

我甚至覺得他們連胡椒球這種低致命性武器都不該有。

And they shouldn't be using tear gas and pepper spray and bear spray on protesters.

而且他們不應該對抗議者使用催淚瓦斯、胡椒噴霧和熊噴霧。

It would be as if we gave every postal worker and every person who delivers the mail, you know, an AR15.

這就像是我們給每個郵務人員和每個送信的人，你知道，一把 AR15。

They don't need it to complete their duties.

他們不需要它來完成他們的職責。

And it's insane that they have been armed and are wearing flak jackets and are obviously wearing masks to.

而且他們竟然配備了武器，穿著防彈背心，還戴著口罩，這實在太瘋狂了。

For no other reason than to obscure their identity and prevent accountability.

只是為了掩蓋他們的身份，防止追究責任。

Obviously the shootings are unjustified, but

the entire situation that recently Alex Preddy unfortunately found himself in and the woman next to him, they should not have been pushed aside by these putative federal officers for exercising their first amendment rights.

Alex Preddy 和他旁邊的女士最近不幸遇到的整個情況，他們不應該被這些所謂的聯邦官員因為行使他們的憲法第一修正案權利而被推開。

They should not have been pepper sprayed while they were restrained.

他們被制服時不應該被噴灑胡椒噴霧。

And of course they should not have been shot and murdered while they were prone and restrained.

他們當然不應該在趴著並被制服時被槍殺和謀殺。

The entire situation should not have happened.

3000 ICE and CBP officers should not have been deployed to Minneapolis in the first place.

根本就不應該部署 3000 名 ICE 和 CBP 官員到明尼阿波利斯。

I will echo what some legal commentators have said.

我會呼應一些法律評論員的說法。

這基本上就是隨機的恐怖主義。

If you send 3,000 untrained psychopaths with guns into a place where people are angry, where they are not effectuating the law, you don't know who's going to die, but

如果你派了 3000 名未經訓練、精神失常的持槍者到一個人們憤怒、他們又不執行法律的地方，你不知道誰會死，但是

And I think that President Trump and I think that Stephen Miller have blood on their hands because this is what they wanted.

我認為川普總統和史蒂芬·米勒手上都有血債，因為這正是他們想要的。

It's honestly incredible that the people of Minneapolis and Minnesota have shown as much restraint as they have and that they have not taken the bait and they have not responded to violence with violence.

說實話，明尼阿波利斯和明尼蘇達州的人們表現出如此大的剋制，沒有上鉤，也沒有以暴制暴，這真是令人難以置信。

And it deserves commendation, not the least of which because they're not going to be the last.

這值得稱讚，尤其因為他們不會是最後一個。

It's going to come to other cities, predominantly blue and majority Democratic cities, because what ICE and CBP are doing is a terror campaign.

這會來到其他城市，主要是藍營和多數民主黨的城市，因為 ICE 和 CBP 正在進行一場恐怖活動。

It is a pretext that they are effectuating anything related to immigration at this point.

事實上，他們現在根本不是在處理任何與移民有關的事情。

And also I will point out that there are a lot of people doing a lot of good.

而且我也要指出，有很多人在做很多好事。

There are a lot of lawyers working overtime right after this happened.

這件事發生後，有很多律師都在加班。

Lawyers who had already received a temporary restraining order saying that ICE could not employ unconstitutional methods to restrain and punish all of the protesters filed an emergency motion with the Court of Appeals to lift an administrative stay that was put in place, which is a thing that often happens.

這些律師已經拿到了一份臨時禁制令，說 ICE 不能用違憲的方式來限制和懲罰所有抗議者，他們向法院提出緊急動議，要求撤銷一個行政暫緩令，這種情況很常見。

And it's insane that they would need a TRO in the first place to restrain these people en masse from conducting unconstitutional raids and unconstitutional methods.

而且，他們一開始就需要臨時禁制令來阻止這些人進行違憲搜查和使用違憲手段，這真是太瘋狂了。

But the declarations from people who were on the scene and saw Alex Preddy shot with their own eyes, it's crazy that lawyers would respond within a few hours and get that in front of a judge.

但是，現場目擊者親眼看到 Alex Preddy 被槍殺的證詞，律師們能在幾小時內就將這些提交給法官，這真的很不可思議。

It's also there was some parallel litigation from the Minnesota bureau in charge of the investigation that was stymied by ice, which is another thing for another day.

還有，負責調查的 Minnesota 局也進行了一些平行訴訟，但被 ICE 阻礙了，這又是另一回事了。

Within a few hours, they had a motion in front of a judge seeking a temporary restraining order to prevent ICE from destroying evidence because they already mucked up the crime scene.

幾小時內，他們就向法官提交了一份動議，尋求臨時禁制令，以防止 ICE 銷毀證據，因為他們已經弄亂了犯罪現場。

The declarations and affidavits from people in support of that are also incredible.

支持這項動議的聲明和宣誓書也令人難以置信。

And another incredible thing that is within two hours, a Trump appointed judge granted the tro.

另一件令人難以置信的事是，在兩小時內，一位川普任命的法官就準許了臨時禁制令。

And, you know, these are not perfect mechanisms.

It's something that in the past has helped to prevent ICE from destroying evidence, which I think they did in the case of Jonathan Ross when they took all of the stuff out of his house and put it God knows where.

過去，這曾幫助阻止 ICE 銷毀證據，我認為在 Jonathan Ross 的案件中，他們就把他家裡所有的東西都拿走了，然後不知道放哪裡去了。

It probably goes without saying, but it's unfortunate.

這大概不用說了，但這真的很不幸。

而且我們竟然不能信任，這也太瘋狂了。

We cannot trust federal officers in the first place, but we also cannot trust them to investigate.

我們一開始就不能信任聯邦官員，但我們也不能信任他們去調查。

There are also things that Congress can and should do immediately.

國會也有一些可以而且應該立即做的事情。

Obviously, they should not fund ICE in the future, but that's the table stakes.

顯然，他們未來不應該資助 ICE，但這是基本要求。

We need to have serious curtailment of the immunity that exists.

我們需要嚴格限制現有的豁免權。

Federal Officers do not have absolute immunity, but they do have strong immunity.

聯邦官員沒有絕對豁免權，但他們確實有很強的豁免權。

And it is incredibly difficult to sue the federal government when you have had your constitutional rights deprived.

當你的憲法權利被剝奪時，要起訴聯邦政府是極其困難的。

Obviously, there's qualified immunity on a state level.

When state actors do that, it would be unbelievably easy for Congress to amend the current laws to provide a right of action for people to be able to sue, to remove qualified immunity unnecessarily, and

當州級官員這樣做時，國會要修改現有法律，為人們提供訴訟權，不必要地取消合格豁免權，這將會變得非常容易，

字幕列表影片播放

亞歷克斯·普雷蒂的死刑讓我心碎！💔 (The Execution of Alex Pretti Broke Me)

sort

entire

absolutely

incredible