Name: BL漫畫的問題點｜深度解析影片 (The Problem with BL Manhwas | Video Essay)
Uploaded: 2026-03-20T07:55:51.000Z
Duration: 10 min

Discord servers, TikTok communities and Twitter hashtags.

Discord 伺服器、TikTok 社群和 Twitter 標籤。

情態副詞

The BL community is basically everywhere.

Unrealistic standards, huge slippers and 20 something year old men in debt.

不切實際的標準、巨大的拖鞋，還有二十幾歲的負債男性。

Why is everyone, especially women, reading gay comics these days?

為什麼大家，特別是女性，現在都在看同性戀漫畫？

Alright, so as you might have already noticed, today we're talking about bls, especially in its manhwa form, which is basically a webtoon, but

好的，大家可能已經注意到了，今天我們要聊聊 BL，特別是漫畫形式的 BL，它基本上就是網路漫畫，但是

It's fine to be in the community, it's great, can have fun.

待在社群裡沒關係，很棒，可以玩得很開心。

But over the years I've noticed quite a few interesting things that happen in these stories and within the community that I want to be talking about today.

不過這幾年來，我觀察到這些故事和社群裡發生了好多有趣的事，這就是我今天要跟大家聊的。

A weird drawing made by a 40 year old pedophile?

一個四十歲戀童癖畫的奇怪圖畫？

No, in fact it is a perfectly legal webtoon made by likely a woman.

不，事實上，這是一部完全合法的網路漫畫，很可能是由一位女性創作者畫的。

We like to call this kind of thing a BL manhwa, which like I said, is basically like a gay comic.

我們稱這類作品為 BL 漫畫，就像我說的，基本上就是同性戀漫畫。

BL means boys love and it's basically men loving men comics.

BL 代表男孩之愛，基本上就是男性角色之間的戀愛漫畫。

Now let's see how Wikipedia defines that.

我們來看看維基百科怎麼定義它。

Boys love, also known by its abbreviation, BL is a genre of fictional media originating in Japan that depicts homoerotic relationships between male characters.

男孩之愛，也稱為 BL，是一種起源於日本的虛構媒體類型，描寫男性角色之間的同性戀情。

But I just wanted to say that most BL man was these days are actually Korean.

但我只是想說，現在大部分的 BL 漫畫其實是韓國的。

And we're only going to talk about Korean ones because I don't read any other languages.

而且我們只會討論韓國的，因為我不看其他語言的。

Well, at first glance it seems pretty normal, right?

嗯，乍看之下好像很正常，對吧？

Many people, especially, like I said, women talk about it, obsess over it, or even create it, and

很多人，特別是，就像我說的，女性，會討論它、迷戀它，甚至創作它，而且

But if we take a closer look, or not even a closer look because you could see it from a mile away, there's something weird about it.

但如果我們仔細看看，或者甚至不用仔細看，因為你一眼就能看出來，這其中有些奇怪的地方。

Maybe not even weird, maybe disgusting or morally wrong.

也許不只是奇怪，而是令人作嘔或道德敗壞。

So here's what I've observed about like 80% of the BLS that I've read or heard about, but

所以我觀察到，在我看過或聽過的 BL 漫畫裡，大概有 80% 的情況都是這樣，但是

There obviously are some exceptions, but this goes for like 80% of the BLS that I read.

當然有些例外，但這大概適用於我讀過的 80% 的 BL 漫畫。

We have one, usually the main character that's very small, skinny, usually pale as well, cute, young or very young looking, poor as fuck, and

我們有一個，通常是主角，他很嬌小、瘦弱，通常膚色也很蒼白，可愛，年輕或看起來很年輕，超級窮，而且

Not sexually experienced, gay, and oftentimes rather feminine.

沒有性經驗，是同性戀，而且常常有點女性化。

Here are a few examples of how that might look like this Guy is like 26, a physical therapist in quite a lot of debt.

這裡有幾個例子說明這可能看起來是怎樣：這個人大概 26 歲，是個物理治療師，負債累累。

For some reason, we don't even know why he lost his parents.

不知道為什麼，我們甚至不知道為什麼，他失去了父母。

Like I said, he's very poor and underweight and kind of feminine.

就像我說的，他非常瘦弱，而且有點女性化。

This guy is also debt and he's poor and he's also a student and he's very small and skinny.

這個人也有債務，他很窮，也是個學生，而且他非常嬌小瘦弱。

And even if they're not all poor, they usually are.

而且就算他們不是全部都很窮，但通常都是。

Like, this goes for like 99% of the BLS that I read.

就像，我讀的 BL 漫畫大概有 99% 都是這樣。

They're usually all very small and frail.

And this isn't about, like, my personal preferences because you could just say, like, well, if you read those kind of things, obviously you're gonna see them a lot.

而且這不是說，像是，我個人的喜好，因為你也可以說，嗯，如果你看那種東西，你當然會看到很多。

The most famous manhwas these days are what I just literally described.

現在最紅的漫畫，就是我剛剛說的那種。

And then obviously there is a love interest because it's a romance.

然後當然會有一個戀愛對象，因為這是戀愛故事。

And that love interest looks something like this.

He's big, muscular, old, or just looks older than the main character.

他高大、肌肉發達、年紀大，或者看起來比主角老。

Oftentimes he's also straight for some reason before meeting the main character.

很多時候，他在遇到主角之前，不知道為什麼是直的。

And then the main character somehow turns him gay or bi.

然後主角不知道怎麼就把他掰彎成同性戀或雙性戀。

And here are a few examples of what that might look like.

這裡有幾個例子，說明那可能會是什麼樣子。

An MMA boxer who r pes his physical therapist.

一位 MMA 拳擊手，他強暴了他的物理治療師。

And he rips a painter that he hired to paint him while having sex.

然後他把一個請來幫他畫畫的畫家給強暴了，而且還是在性行為的時候。

we're not even going to get into that because, like, you get the point.

我們甚至不用深入探討那個，因為，嗯，你懂我的意思。

And the amount of crimes that this man has committed is.

而且大多數的故事都差不多是這樣。

The two men meet for some odd reason, usually because one of them hired the other or they need the other.

這兩位男士因為一些奇怪的原因而相遇，通常是因為其中一位僱用了另一位，或是他們需要對方。

The main character acts weird and is sexually assaulted by their love interest, which is just great.

主角行為怪異，並被他們的愛慕對象性侵，這真是太棒了。

And then at some point, they end up together, happily ever after.

然後在某個時候，他們就這樣在一起了，從此過著幸福快樂的日子。

By the way, did you catch what I just said?

順帶一提，你有聽清楚我剛才說的話嗎？

Most bls actually contain R Pe like actual.

大部分的 BL 其實都包含 R Pe，就是真的。

It's kind of like a normal thing to read.

這有點像是很正常會讀到的東西。

In bls, if you've read a lot of them, you won't be confused or shocked if you see one anymore.

在 BL 裡，如果你讀了很多，你就不會再對看到某個情節感到困惑或震驚了。

It's just normalized, at least in that community.

這就是被正常化了，至少在那個社群裡是這樣。

Another thing you might have noticed at the very beginning is that some love interests are actually straight at the very beginning, or they still identify as straight for the entire thing.

還有，一開始你可能也會注意到，有些戀愛對象一開始其實是異性戀，或者他們在整個故事裡都還是認為自己是異性戀。

And then, obviously, there's the difference in size.

然後，很明顯地，還有尺寸上的差異。

It's kind of frustrating to read sometimes because of the size difference.

因為尺寸差異，有時候讀起來會有點令人沮喪。

Nobody's that big and nobody's that f cking small.

沒有人那麼大，也沒有人那麼小。