Name: 史上最勁爆的10個樂團！竟敢告自己團員？！😮 (Top 10 Bands Who SUED Their Own Members)
Uploaded: 2026-01-14T16:57:44.000Z
Duration: 13 min 58 s

And today we're counting down our picks for the most infamous times when at least one band member issued a lawsuit against a current or former member of the group.

今天我們要來盤點，那些至少有一位樂團成員對現任或前任團體成員提起訴訟的最惡名昭彰的時刻。

They went their own private ways, found their own friends and became less reliant on each other.

他們各自走自己的路，找到自己的朋友，彼此之間的依賴也越來越少。

Oasis I hate the term sibling rivalry, but.

Oasis 我很不喜歡「兄弟鬩牆」這個詞，但是。

I know my brother better than anybody else.

With the core of Noel and Liam Gallagher, Oasis dominated the UK and ushered in the Britpop era With Blur.

以 Noel 和 Liam Gallagher 兄弟為核心的 Oasis，和 Blur 一起稱霸英國並開創了英倫流行時代。

Yet away from the music, the brothers regularly clashed, leading to the band's split in 2009.

然而，在音樂之外，這對兄弟經常發生衝突，導致樂團在 2009 年解散。

In 2011, no claimed Oasis had to cancel their appearance at V Festival due to Liam being hungover, not for laryngitis, which was was the official statement.

2011 年，Noel 聲稱 Oasis 之所以取消 V Festival 的演出，是因為 Liam 宿醉，而不是官方說的喉炎。

This sparked the younger Gallagher to sue Noel for defamation.

這件事激怒了弟弟 Gallagher，他控告 Noel 誹謗。

In response, Noel filed a counterclaim claiming Liam had left abusive voicemails to his wife and tried to attack him with a guitar.

作為回應，Noel 提出了反訴，聲稱 Liam 對他妻子發送了辱罵語音留言，並試圖用吉他攻擊他。

However, all this family drama reportedly caused their mom Peggy, to tell her sons to stop suing each other.

然而，據說所有這些家庭劇碼讓他們的母親 Peggy 告訴兒子們停止互相訴訟。

As such, they dropped their cases in 2012.

是以，他們在 2012 年撤銷了訴訟。

In 1984, Roger Waters, who co founded the legendary English band Pink Floyd, decided to move on to pastures new.

1984 年，傳奇英國樂團 Pink Floyd 的聯合創始人 Roger Waters 決定另尋發展。

After a meeting with his remaining co founders, Nick Mason and David Gilmour, things got messy.

在與剩下的聯合創始人 Nick Mason 和 David Gilmour 會面後，情況變得一團糟。

Waters believed the band was over, while Mason and Gilmour were set to continue Pink Floyd without him.

Waters 認為樂團已經結束了，而 Mason 和 Gilmour 則準備在他缺席的情況下繼續 Pink Floyd。

He did have some very difficult times, like a few years ago, we seem to have managed to avoid the things that really get people too touchy these days.

他確實經歷過一些非常艱難的時期，就像幾年前，我們似乎設法避開了現今會讓大家太敏感的事情。

This prompted Waters to file a lawsuit to dissolve the band.

這促使 Waters 提起訴訟，要求解散樂團。

He stated that it didn't feel right for Mason and Gilmour to continue using Pink Floyd's name without him, and

他表示，Mason 和 Gilmour 在沒有他的情況下繼續使用 Pink Floyd 的名字感覺不對，

called the group a spent force creatively.

並稱這個團體在創作上已經江郎才盡。

In 1987, the two parties came to an agreement.

1987 年，雙方達成了一項協議。

In 2013, Waters spoke about his regret in issuing the lawsuit.

2013 年，Waters 談到了他對提起訴訟的後悔。

Coming to prominence in the British New Wave scene, the Police took the industry by storm with multiple hits and prestigious awards.

The Police 在英倫新浪潮中聲名鵲起，以多首熱門歌曲和享有盛譽的獎項席捲了整個產業。

Even after the band members went their separate ways, they occasionally reunited over the decades.

即使樂團成員分道揚鑣，幾十年來他們偶爾還是會重聚。

Despite years of hostility, however, the possibility of another Police get together was severely dented.

然而，儘管多年來充滿敵意，The Police 再次重聚的可能性大大降低。

In 2025, Stewart Copeland and Andy Summers issued a suit against Sting for underpaying them royalties.

2025 年，Stewart Copeland 和 Andy Summers 對 Sting 提起訴訟，指控他少付版稅。

Do they start to get resentful that you're the writer, that you're the frontman?

他們會不會開始怨恨你是創作者、你是主唱？

Yeah, I was like the cuckoo in the nest, you know, they didn't really know what they were taking on.

是啊，我就像巢裡的杜鵑鳥，你知道的，他們其實不知道自己惹上了什麼。

The duo claimed that in 1977, each member agreed to share income from the Police songs.

這兩人聲稱，1977 年時，每位成員都同意分享 The Police 歌曲的收入。

Copeland and Summers believe they lost out on around 1.5 million pounds.

Copeland 和 Summers 認為他們損失了約 150 萬英鎊。

Sting has disputed his former bandmate's assertions, instead claiming they likely owed him money from being overpaid.

Sting 則反駁了他前樂團成員的說法，反而聲稱他們很可能因為被多付錢而欠他錢。

Despite changing their main vocalist several times, breaking up and reuniting, the legacy of Journey is incredible.

儘管主唱幾經更換、樂團也曾解散又重聚，Journey 的傳奇依然令人驚嘆。

However, a major change happened in 2020.

然而，2020 年發生了一件大事。

Journey co founder Neil Schoen and Jonathan Cain announced they'd fired Steve Smith and Ross Valerie for attempting to instigate a corporate coup.

Journey 的共同創辦人 Neil Schoen 和 Jonathan Cain 宣佈，他們開除了 Steve Smith 和 Ross Valerie，因為他們試圖發動公司政變。

On top of that, they were suing the duo for $10 million in damages.

更糟的是，他們還控告這兩人損害賠償 1000 萬美元。

In response, Valerie countersued, challenging Schoen and Cayne's claim over Journey's trademark.

作為回應，Valerie 反訴，質疑 Schoen 和 Cayne 對 Journey 商標的所有權。

2021 年，這些訴訟都得到了和解。

In 2022, Schoen issued a cease and desist letter to Cayne for performing a Journey song at Donald Trump events.

2022 年，Schoen 向 Cayne 發出停止並終止信函，因為 Cayne 在 Donald Trump 的活動中演唱了 Journey 的歌曲。

This led to Cain suing Schoen for misusing the band's Tour finances in 2024.

這導致 Cain 在 2024 年控告 Schoen 濫用樂團的巡演資金。

The following year, Journey announced their farewell tour.

隔年，Journey 宣佈了告別巡演。

I think I know Steve and I think he's gonna be gracious and receive it.

我想我認識 Steve，而且我覺得他會很寬宏大量地接受。

And he was certain if he doesn't, I'll be.

而且他很確定如果他不接受，我會。

To wander aimlessly is very unswinging on hip.

When I touch you I feel happy inside I can't hide I can't hide when people discuss the most influential bands in history, the Beatles are always in contention.

當我觸碰你時，我內心感到快樂，我無法隱藏，無法隱藏。當人們討論史上最有影響力的樂團時，The Beatles 總是在競爭之列。

The success of the Liverpool group cannot be understated.

這支來自 Liverpool 的團體所取得的成功，不容小覷。

By 1970, after a spate of issues within the band, including the appointment of Alan Klein as manager, Paul McCartney wanted out.

到了 1970 年，在樂團內發生一連串問題後，包括任命 Alan Klein 為經理，Paul McCartney 想要退出。

Whatever talent they have as individuals, and

who can deny it, their capacity to earn is largely tied up in their performances and their growth.

誰能否認，他們賺錢的能力很大程度上取決於他們的演出和成長。

However, his contract and the other members wouldn't let him.

然而，他的合約和其他成員不讓他這麼做。

Unable to Sue Klein directly, McCartney issued a lawsuit against the Beatles to dissolve their partnership.

McCartney 無法直接起訴 Klein，於是對 The Beatles 提起了訴訟，要求解散他們的合作關係。

When the case went to trial in 1971, the world found out the band was in a terrible financial state.

到了 1971 年此案開庭審理時，全世界才得知這個樂團的財務狀況非常糟糕。

The Court ruled in McCartney's favor, and the band was formally dissolved.

法院判決 McCartney 勝訴，樂團正式解散。

He disputed claims he broke up the Beatles instead, insisting he was trying to save their music.

他反駁了指控他解散 The Beatles 的說法，堅稱他當時是想拯救他們的音樂。

I guess nobody ever really done me she done me she done me good Number five, Fleetwood Mac.

我猜沒人真的做過，她對我很好，她對我很好。第五名，Fleetwood Mac。

Despite decades of massive success, Fleetwood Mac aren't strangers to lawsuits between members.

儘管數十年來取得了巨大的成功，Fleetwood Mac 的成員之間並不陌生於訴訟。

One of the most shocking took place in 2018.

其中一起最令人震驚的訴訟發生在 2018 年。

Having first joined Fleetwood Mac in 1975, Lindsey Buckingham was later fired by the group.

Lindsey Buckingham 在 1975 年首次加入 Fleetwood Mac，後來被該團體開除。

This reportedly involved a disagreement about certain material being used in a tour, which Buckingham refused to sign off on.

據說這起事件源於對巡演中使用某些素材的意見分歧，Buckingham 拒絕簽署同意。

Everyone knew that this was what was being written about, and

大家都知道這就是大家在寫的東西，

everyone knew that these songs, the subject matter was what we were living.

而且大家都知道這些歌，這些主題就是我們當時的生活。

In response to his firing, he sued the group for several reasons, including breach of judiciary duty and breach of oral contract.

作為對他被開除的回應，他以多項理由起訴該團體，包括違反司法義務和違反口頭合約。

Two months later, the suit was settled out of court for undisclosed terms.

兩個月後，這場訴訟在庭外以未公開的條款達成和解。

Buckingham also claimed his firing stemmed from Stevie Nicks.

Buckingham 也聲稱他被開除是因為 Stevie Nicks。

Allegedly, a dispute led to her giving an ultimatum to the band that either he's fired or she'll walk away.

據稱，一場爭執導致她向樂團提出最後通牒，要嘛開除他，要嘛她就離開。

她只是在比賽，她只是在比賽。

After forming in 1970, Darrell hall and John Oates became one of the most famous duos in the music industry.

Darrell Hall 和 John Oates 在 1970 年組成後，成為音樂產業中最知名的二人組之一。

They continued their successful partnership for decades.

他們成功的合作關係持續了好幾十年。

However, in 2023, things got really rocky.

然而，到了 2023 年，情況變得非常棘手。

Hall was furious that Oates planned to sell their publishing rights to Primary Wave without his consent or knowledge.

Hall 對 Oates 未經他同意或知情就計畫將他們的出版權賣給 Primary Wave 感到非常憤怒。

As a result, hall issued a lawsuit which blocked the sale until the duo could agree on terms.

結果，Hall 提起訴訟，阻止了這次銷售，直到兩人能就條款達成協議。

He said that the alleged planned sale was, quote, a completely clandestine and bad faith move and called it, quote, the ultimate partnership betrayal.

他說，所謂的計畫銷售是，引述，一個完全祕密且惡意的舉動，並稱之為，引述，夥伴關係的終極背叛。

However, Oates disputed Hall's version of events, even filing his own complaint and getting a restraining order against Hall.

然而，Oates 對 Hall 的說法提出異議，甚至提起了自己的訴訟，並對 Hall 申請了禁制令。

This fallout led both musicians to declare they're unlikely to work together again in 2025.

這場風波讓兩位音樂人表示，他們不太可能在 2025 年再次合作。

The legal issues were resolved between hall and Oates during arbitration.

法律問題在仲裁過程中由 Hall 和 Oates 解決了。

Born in 1961 as a core of family members with the Wilson brothers and their cousin Mike Love, the Beach Boys unique surf and sound became the soundtrack of many people's summers.

The Beach Boys 於 1961 年誕生，以 Wilson 兄弟和他們的表親 Mike Love 為核心家庭成員，他們獨特的衝浪音樂成為許多人夏天的配樂。

Yet despite most of them being relatives, they've had many legal battles.

然而，儘管他們大多是親戚，卻經歷了許多法律訴訟。

In 1994, Love won a lawsuit against Brian Wilson for royalties.

1994 年，Love 贏了對 Brian Wilson 的訴訟，爭取版稅。

You and I are gonna rewrite these songs, put them together in a normal album and get on with it.

你和我將會重寫這些歌曲，將它們收錄在一張正常的專輯裡，然後繼續前進。