Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • Harry Potter scribe JK Rowling has created a wizarding world that has sparked the imaginations

  • of millions across the globe.

  • And while her accomplishments have made her a very rich and powerful person, that doesn't

  • mean she lives entirely without regret.

  • To many fans, the decision to pair Ron Weasley with Hermione Granger was a strange one.

  • Ron, the goofy sidekick, had almost nothing in common with Hermione, whereas Harry always

  • recognized her status as the secret MVP of the story’s central trio.

  • Sure, Ron had a few moments of bravery, and there was that tenuous connection with her

  • being a muggle and his dad having a fascination with the non-wizarding world, but please.

  • Even Rowling knows that Hermione and Harry were the real endgame of the series.

  • In an interview with The Sunday Times, Rowling admitted:

  • "I wrote the Hermione/Ron relationship as a form of wish fulfillment.

  • That's how it was conceived, really.

  • For reasons that have very little to do with literature and far more to do with me clinging

  • to the plot as I first imagined it, Hermione ended up with Ron.

  • [...] It was a choice I made for very personal reasons, not for reasons of credibility."

  • Of course, it’s possible that the personal reason she's alluding to here is the fact

  • that Ron Weasley was based on a close childhood friend of hers, while Hermione was based in

  • part upon herself.

  • Mental, that one.

  • I’m telling you.”

  • In 2007, J.K.

  • Rowling revealed that Albus Dumbledore was meant to be a gay character, even if it wasn't

  • completely spelled out in her books.

  • During a reading of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, she answered a fan question as to

  • whether Dumbledore had ever fallen in love, saying:

  • "Dumbledore is gay, actually."

  • While the news was received warmly by the crowd, she expressed some regret that she

  • hadn't been more clear about that before, saying:

  • "I would have told you earlier if I knew it would make you so happy."

  • The matter would become a point of contention later on, however, when Dumbledore's sexuality

  • was again left ambiguous in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald.

  • LGBTQ advocates were dismayed when director David Yates revealed that the film would "not

  • explicitly" address his homosexuality.

  • Although Rowling still openly defended her decision to make Dumbledore gay, she chose

  • to ignore those who criticized the film's lack of attention to that detail.

  • For the third instalment in the franchise, Yates has maintained that they will make Dumbledore's

  • romantic history with Grindelwald a little more obvious.

  • Rowling fielded more public disappointment over the fact that the cast for the first

  • Fantastic Beasts was predominantly white.

  • Producer David Heyman defended the film's casting by explaining that the story's timeline

  • had a lot to do with the cast's whiteness, pointing out to Entertainment Weekly that

  • 1920s era New York was racially segregated.

  • He said:

  • The wizarding world is a much more open and tolerant society where people of color

  • and different ethnic backgrounds exist harmoniously together."

  • Heyman also promised that the series would have "people of color filling this world in

  • an organic way."

  • Rowling, meanwhile, simply denied that the cast was all-white on Twitter and challenged

  • a fan to wait to see the movie before judging, adding:

  • "It is a trilogy and all the characters have not been revealed or cast yet."

  • The author faced further Fantastic Beasts backlash when the character of Nagini, Voldemort’s

  • pet snake from the original series, was introduced in The Crimes of Grindelwald as a maledictus,

  • played by South Korean actress Claudia Kim.

  • Rowling was accused of fabricating diversity with the decision, which she fought back against

  • by pointing out that the wordNaginicomes from Indonesian mythology, and that

  • Indonesia has a significant Chinese population.

  • Still, as many suspected, the character came through as something of a token inclusion

  • in the movie.

  • All of this comes on top of other long-running Potter franchise controversies, such as the

  • issue of Jewish representation and varying interpretations of Hermione's race.

  • It’s not hard to imagine that, given the chance, she would have approached the diversity

  • of her characters a little differently.

  • Plenty of characters died in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, but one of the offings

  • that hurt the most was Fred Weasley, who was killed in an explosion at the Battle of Hogwarts.

  • Fred had become a fan favorite, alongside his twin brother George, thanks to his signature

  • cheery demeanor.

  • She would later apologize to fans for claiming the fictional life of a character who was

  • so beloved by readers.

  • In 2015, she tweeted:

  • "Today I would just like to say: I'm really sorry about Fred."

  • In 2016, Rowling returned to her tradition of apologizing for a character's authorial

  • execution.

  • This time, she shone the spotlight on Remus Lupin, the Hogwart’s Defense Against the

  • Dark Arts professor who also turned out to be a werewolf.

  • It wasn't just Remus' death that hit so hard, though.

  • He died shortly after his wife Tonks was also killed, which meant that their newborn son

  • Teddy lost both his parents before he had a chance to know them - just like Harry Potter

  • had so many years before.

  • Rowling issued a series of tweets apologizing and explaining the need for Lupin's death,

  • writing:

  • "In the interests of total honesty I'd also like to confess that I didn't decide to kill

  • Lupin until I wrote Order of the Phoenix.

  • Arthur lived, so Lupin had to die.

  • I'm sorry.

  • I didn't enjoy doing it.

  • The only time my editor ever saw me cry was over the fate of Teddy."

  • To orphan one little wizard baby?

  • Cruel.

  • Two of them?

  • That’s just diabolical.

  • Whether or not Professor Severus Snape actually redeemed himself at the end of Deathly Hallows

  • is up for debate.

  • Sure, he was working for the good guys all along and only killed Dumbledore so that Draco

  • Malfoy wouldn't have to.

  • But he was pretty terrible to Harry from the very start of his tenure at Hogwarts.

  • Making the generous assumption that he was trying to teach Potter to toughen up in preparation

  • for his fateful confrontation with Lord Voldemort, you can’t help but imagine some of that

  • was him projecting his pure acrimony for James Potter onto the Boy Who Lived.

  • The fandom’s split opinion on Snape meant that a good chunk of them would have been

  • happy if Rowling never apologized for his death - which is why her 2017 commemoration

  • of the Battle of Hogwarts ended up a little more timid than usual.

  • She tweeted:

  • "OK, here it is.

  • Please don't start flame wars over it, but this year I'd like to apologise for killing

  • (whispers)…

  • Snape."

  • After all this time?”

  • Always.”

  • It's almost like she was apologizing for apologizing.

  • One character that Rowling managed to completely redeem by the time the series ended was Dobby

  • the house elf.

  • When we first met him, he was a completely irritating pest whose sole purpose was to

  • get Harry in trouble with the Dursleys.

  • By the end of the road, he was a sweet little scamp who just wanted to be free so that he

  • could define his own loyalties.

  • While trying to rescue Harry and Griphook from the Death Eaters, however, Dobby was

  • stabbed by Bellatrix Lestrange.

  • To make his death even more devastating, Harry dug his grave by hand and inscribed it with

  • the words: "Here lies Dobby, a free elf."

  • Rowling memorialized him in her 2018 tribute, despite the fact that he wasn't a part of

  • the legendary final battle, writing:

  • "It's that anniversary again.

  • This year, I apologise for killing someone who didn't die during the #BattleofHogwarts,

  • but who laid down his life to save the people who'd win it.

  • I refer, of course, to Dobby the house elf."

  • Another lamentation J.K.

  • Rowling has made about the Harry Potter series is how certain characters' names are so commonly

  • mispronounced.

  • With Hermione Granger, for example, Rowling had to pretty much spell it out in the text

  • once she discovered that fans were saying her name incorrectly.

  • Rowling has since admitted that the scene from Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire in

  • which Hermione tells Viktor Krum to say "her-my-oh-nee" instead of "hermy-own" was also meant to be

  • instructional for readers, since the films hadn't come out yet.

  • One name pronunciation that she never did quite correct, however, was Lord Voldemort,

  • whose moniker most fans think is "vawl-duh-MORT."

  • Even the films adapted that bit of elocution.

  • Voldemort.”

  • Voldemort?”

  • Shh.”

  • However, if Rowling had her way, fans would never say the "T" in his name at all.

  • In 2015, she confirmed this fun fact about the series, conceding:

  • "I'm pretty sure I'm the only person who pronounces it that way."

  • One specific regret J.K.

  • Rowling has copped to is the type of dog bred by the third book’s nasty Aunt Marge.

  • In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Harry was introduced to Uncle Vernon's sister,

  • who often used canine-related theories and phrases to analyze people.

  • It’s all to do with the mother.

  • You see it all the time with dogs.

  • If there’s something wrong with the b----, then there’s something wrong with the pup.”

  • Clearly, her relationship with her dogs was significant to her character development.

  • However, Rowling later said she should not have chosen bulldogs as her breed after all.

  • She wrote on Pottermore:

  • "I regret making Aunt Marge a breeder of bulldogs, as I now know them to be a non-aggressive

  • breed.

  • My sister owns one and he's the most lovable, affectionate dog you could hope to meet.

  • On the other hand, they do look grumpy, and on appearance alone seemed to suit Aunt Marge."

  • There are some Harry Potter fan theories that Rowling has shown some major support and respect

  • for - while others have been kindly dispelled by the author as illegitimate.

  • Usually, Rowling is polite enough about putting an idea to rest, like when she denied that

  • Ron is a younger time-travelling Dumbledore and shut down the theory that Draco Malfoy

  • became a werewolf after being bitten by Fenrir Greyback.

  • One theory that seems to get Rowling into a tizzy, though, is the one that suggests

  • Dumbledore may have turned his phoenix Fawkes into his own horcrux.

  • Admittedly, the supporting evidence for the concept is pretty thin.

  • Basically, the idea is that if Voldemort could store a piece of his existence in a snake,

  • a bird wouldn't be off the table either, and Dumbledore may not have always been the benevolent

  • soul that we know him to be.

  • However, Rowling not only put the kibosh on the idea, but also expressed personal offense

  • to it, writing:

  • "The idea that anybody believes this is strangely upsetting to me."

  • By the end of the Harry Potter series, J.K.

  • Rowling had written a whopping 4,224 pages about her magical realm - but there was still

  • one scene she couldn't quite squeeze into the story.

  • In 2007, the author revealed that she wanted to include a Hogwarts graduation scene in

  • Deathly Hallows to confirm that Hermione went back to school and finished, while Harry,

  • Ron, Neville, and some others went straight to work to clean up Voldemort’s mess in

  • the wizarding world.

  • She told fans on Pottercast:

  • "I felt a huge sadness that I wouldn't write a graduation scene.

  • I felt sad that the book wasn't gonna end with that feast scene, the graduation scene.

  • [...] A lot of people felt the epilogue was too sentimental, I think to have a graduation

  • scene on top of what just happened would've been an absurd bit of anti-climax."

  • Had the scene been included, fans would've seen the trio ride the thestrals away from

  • Hogwarts to signify a fresh new start for them as they passed over the water.

  • Check out one of our newest videos right here!

  • Plus, even more Looper videos about your favorite movies are coming soon.

  • Subscribe to our YouTube channel and hit the bell so you don't miss a single one.

Harry Potter scribe JK Rowling has created a wizarding world that has sparked the imaginations

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級

J.K.羅琳對《哈利波特》最大的遺憾。 (J.K. Rowling's Biggest Regrets About Harry Potter)

  • 33 1
    林宜悉 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日
影片單字