Name: 勇敢的心｜偉大的電影，但故事的真實性如何？ (Braveheart | Great Movie But How True Was the Story?)
Uploaded: 2021-01-14T08:07:49.000Z
Duration: 4 min 48 s
Description: 【看影片學英語】數萬部 YouTube 影片，搭配英漢字典即點即查，輕鬆掌握單字發音與用法，長久累積看電影不必再看字幕。

關係子句

released Braveheart, which was nominated for 61 awards

and won 31 of those, including Oscars for Best Picture

If there had been an award for least historically

accurate movie, it would have won that as well.

The timeline is wrong, the events they got right

are depicted wrong, the look of it is laughably wrong,

they made regarding the characters that are wrong.

who would be the king after the deaths of Alexander

The thing is, all four people were actually alive and 1276.

In fact, the king wouldn't die for another 10 years.

didn't start the way the movie would have us believe.

In the film, William Wallace's father Malcolm

was among those Scots lured to a fake Scottish summit only

Malcolm's death was the first spark of young William's hatred

That inciting incident in the life of the protagonist

did they show the battle without including the titular bridge?

The real life bridge created a bottleneck

that was essential to the Scots' strategy.

Also in 1297, Wallace's men raided several cities

in Northumberland, which is in the northeast of England.

In 1298, the Battle of Falkirk took place.

so they abandoned their post with the British

The real battle didn't include any Irish.

Those didn't come into fashion until around the 1600s.

The men would have been dressed in tunics and hosen,

And if they had, they certainly wouldn't have spruced it up

a warrior sporting such paint, or more likely,

indigenous to the British Isles over 1,000 years

before the events of Braveheart took place.

In the mid-1700s, bagpipes were banned as an instrument of war.

about bagpipes being illegal some 400 years before the ban.

At least the errors found on the Scottish soldiers

What also didn't exist at the time was a pagan British king.

Let's look at the film's depiction of Edward II

It's unclear whether he had sexual relationships with men,

and we don't know if his father knew or cared about it.

He and his wife had tension, but that didn't stem

Other than Isabella, the person most associated with Edward

being thrown out of the window to his death

William Wallace never seduced Edward's wife Isabella.

She never met him and was only 13 when he died.

Isabella and Edward didn't marry until several years after that.

And for the biggest fact bending of all--

William Wallace wasn't referred to as "Braveheart."

In 1329, that honor was bestowed upon Robert the Bruce, whom

the movie erroneously suggested was involved in Wallace's

He was called Braveheart because, as per his wishes,

so it can be taken on a crusade before being

What else did they get wrong about William Wallace?

His dad was probably Alex Wallace, not Malcolm Wallace.

Regardless, neither died when William was young,

and they were both minor nobility rather than commoners,

字幕列表影片播放

勇敢的心｜偉大的電影，但故事的真實性如何？ (Braveheart | Great Movie But How True Was the Story?)

struggle

version

exist

instrument