Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • The United States has a problem with income inequality.

  • People have different ideas about why this is happening.

  • CEO pay climbs every single year without exception.

  • The United States has lost 5 million manufacturing jobs since the year 2000.

  • big shifts that's happened in the economy

  • that is lead in part to a decline in union membership.

  • But one if the biggest drivers of inequality is hiding here, in these 2,000 pages.

  • It's the US tax code.

  • President Trump and Republicans in Congress have a plan to alter that code.

  • and if they get their way it'll get even better for the richest Americans.

  • First let's look at a few things that Trump and the Republicans

  • don't want to change about the tax code.

  • the charitable deduction and the mortgage interest deduction.

  • Here's how they favor the rich:

  • Let's say Dan makes $100 donation to his church. He makes about $30,000 a year.

  • Roughly, the median income for individuals in the US.

  • Which puts him in the 15% tax bracket.

  • It means he would save at most $15 on his taxes.

  • But let's say Dan's boss Steve makes the same donation to his church.

  • Steve makes $500,000 a year which puts him in the top tax bracket.

  • And the same $100 donation could save Steve $39.60 on his taxes.

  • Dan and Steve give the same amount to their church

  • but Steve saves more than twice as much.

  • Small examples like this add up.

  • People making $100,000 or more account for about 57% of all the charitable contributions in the US

  • but they get 76% of the tax benefits.

  • This deduction is also really expensive.

  • The US spends $70,000,000,000 a year on it.

  • More than eight times what it spends on Head Start the federally funded preschool program

  • and more than twice what it spends on Pell grants for low-income students to go to college.

  • Plus there's all kinds of ways to bend the rules.

  • Billionaire Mitchell Rales gets tax break for donating his collection of modern art

  • to a museum that he built right next door to his house.

  • A museum that's only open for private tours.

  • But the worst thing about about the charitable deduction?

  • There's not great evidence that it works.

  • Turns out you don't need a tax break to encourage people to be generous to others.

  • In the 1980's the top tax rate for the richest people was 70%

  • and through a series of reforms it dropped to 28%

  • and the Council on Foundations, it's kind of a trade group for charities,

  • said, 'Oh my God, you do that we're going to lose all our contributions.'

  • Guess what? No difference. People gave just as much with a much lower tax rate.

  • Austria, Finland, Ireland, Italy, Sweden, Switzerland, and New Zealand

  • have all gotten rid of their deductions for charitable contributions

  • and that hasn't had an impact on donation rates.

  • One easy way to make things more fair?

  • Replace the tax deduction with a tax credit.

  • If Dan and Steve both give $100 to their church,

  • give them each a $15 tax credit.

  • That's how they do it in Canada.

  • A tax credit reduces the amount you owe, so the same donation gets the same benefit

  • no matter how rich you are.

  • There's another tax deduction that's a boon for the wealthy.

  • The mortgage interest deduction costs about $100,000,000,000 a year to the Treasury.

  • We could use that money to treat wounded veterans, to build hospitals, to build highways

  • but instead we give it to rich homeowners.

  • Here's how it works:

  • Let's say Dan buys a house for $100,000. He doesn't pay for that all at once.

  • Each month he writes a check to the bank for $1,000.

  • Let's say $800 goes to paying for the house,

  • and the bank keeps $200. That's interest!

  • Dan writes twelve of these checks a year, so he pays $2,400 a year in interest.

  • The mortgage interest deduction let's Dan subtract that interest from his taxable income

  • which could save him as much as $362.

  • "Nice," thinks Dan, that is until he hears about Steve.

  • Steve also buys a house for $100,000.

  • He also writes a $1,000 check each month paying $200 in interest.

  • So after a year, Steve can also deduct the $2,400 from his taxable income.

  • But that same deduction can save Steve more than $960.

  • Nearly three times as much as Dan for the exact same mortgage payments.

  • It doesn't stop there. Steve can buy a second home, deduct the interest, and save even more.

  • Or he can get a mortgage for his yacht, count it as a second home, and deduct the interest.

  • Sorry Dan, your fishing boat doesn't count.

  • There are deductions everywhere.

  • The money you lose from gambling? Deduct it.

  • Fancy business dinners? Yep.

  • Money you put in a retirement account? That too.

  • You can even deduct the fees you pay an accountant to help you find more deductions.

  • And while theoretically Dan could take advantage of these same deductions

  • the fact is, people like Steve benefit a whole lot more.

  • People who make about $400,000 a year or more make up about 5% of taxpayers

  • but they get more than half the benefits from these tax deductions.

  • Now there's a third part of the tax code that Trump and the Republicans want to keep

  • and it's even better for the richest Americans than all of these deductions

  • The preferred rate for capital gains. Here's how it works:

  • According to the US tax code, there are two different kinds of income.

  • Earned income is when you go to work and somebody pays you a salary or wage a paycheck.

  • That's earned income and we have a whole set of income tax rates for that income that go up to 39.6%.

  • This is where Dan and Steve's tax rates come from.

  • Unearned income means guys who trade paper.

  • Guys who sell stock or buy commodities and then sell it.

  • Invest in real estate properties and then sell them.

  • That's capital income and we tax that at a lower rate.

  • Let's say Steve earns $500,000 a year as a surgeon

  • and Laurie earns the same amount as a hedge fund manager.

  • Even though their income is the same, Steve's tax rate is 39.6%

  • but Laurie's tax rate is nearly half that, 23.8%.

  • So Steve ends up with a much higher tax bill.

  • This is why billionaire investor Warren Buffet pays a lower tax rate than his secretary.

  • His money comes from capital gains while hers comes from a salary.

  • Debbie works just as hard as I do and she pays at twice the rate I pay.

  • Ronald Reagan thought the same thing.

  • Reagan had been a very high, high bracket taxpayer.

  • In fact, he paid at the 90% rate in the 1950s. He was a movie star.

  • His accountant kept telling him well sign these documents and that'll shift your income

  • from labor to capital income and Reagan saw that that was hokey.

  • Why should that be?

  • Reagan's landmark 1986 tax bill tax capital income and labor income at the same rate.

  • People said, "Oh my God, you can't do that. Then nobody will invest. Investments will plummet."

  • This chart shows the value of the S&P 500, a stock market metric that measures

  • how well big businesses are doing.

  • After Reagan raised the capital gains rate in 1986, businesses continued to prosper.

  • Reagan's successors, George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton also raise taxes and the on the wealthiest Americans.

  • And the 1990s saw America's longest period of consecutive economic growth ever.

  • But the changes that Donald Trump and Republicans in Congress

  • want to make to the tax code look very different.

  • While the Trump and GOP plans get rid of some deductions

  • neither gets rid of the charitable contribution or mortgage interest deductions

  • Both plans would lower taxes on capital income for people like Laurie the hedge fund manager.

  • And both plans would reduce the number of tax brackets from seven to three.

  • and cut the top tax rate. Which would mean big tax savings for someone like Steve

  • and minimal savings for working and middle-class people like Dan.

  • Rather than working to reduce the growing gap between the richest Americans and everyone else

  • these new tax plans would make that gap even wider.

The United States has a problem with income inequality.

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級 美國腔

減稅如何幫助富人 (How tax breaks help the rich)

  • 23 3
    Evangeline 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日
影片單字