Name: 我是生化人嗎？ (Am I A Cyborg?)
Uploaded: 2021-01-14T07:28:04.000Z
Duration: 9 min 32 s

基礎被動語態

This video is brought to you by audible go to audible.com/domics

or click on the link in the description to get your free audiobook and a 30-day trial.

到 audible.com/domics
或是由影片資訊的連結來享有 30 天的免費有聲書試用

Dom: Whoa! Hey! I'm not alone in this video. Why don't you guys introduce yourselves, huh?

Dom：喔~嘿！這次的影片終於不是我一個人了，
你們要不要自我介紹一下啊~

Ehlboy: Uh... Animator. Sometimes helps Dom with his videos.

Ehlboy: 痾...我是動畫師，有時候也會幫 Dom 做影片

Jomm: I'm Jomm, sometimes known as "Dom" without the D. Uh...

Jomm: 我是 Jomm，就是那個名子裡沒有 "D" 的 Dom...痾...

00:00:34,460 --> 00:00:37,040
Kressh: 怎麼能把你自白沒有____的片段剪掉呢？

Kressh: How can we cut it? If you don't have a "D"?

Dom: Next, we have, uh, "Kreesh" (Kressh)

Kressh: 每個人都這樣叫我名子，根本沒人正確的叫我 "Kressh"

Kressh: See everyone's gonna take that seriously, and no one's gonna call me Kressh.

00:00:45,340 --> 00:00:50,020
Dom: 然後我們有一堆古怪的假想題，
痾...要不要舉例一下我們之前有講過那些題目？

Dom: So, we have a lot of hypotheticals. Uh... talking about a lot of stuff. What's what's an example of what we've thought of before?

Ehlboy : 這是我們最一開始討論的假想題

Ehlboy: That was an original hypothetical--

Dom : 我們當初到底怎麼想到要討論這個啊？

Dom : 一開始是...
" 如果地球上的所有空氣都變成木頭會怎麼樣？ "

Dom: I don't even know where that came from.

Kressh : 所以...在這個假想題裡，人類應該要靠呼吸木頭來維生了嗎？

Dom: First one was, "what if all the air in the world (as in like the planet Earth) was just replaced with wood?"

Dom : 這個嘛...你確定你還會呼吸嗎?
你不是應該直接死翹翹了嗎？

So, in this hypothetical, do we now as humans breathe in wood? Is that what we need to survive?

Kressh : 所以...所有人應該會感覺突然被某種東西壓扁，或是因為缺氧而死？

Well, are you breathing because don't you just die instantly?

Dom : 還有人有辦法意識到
到底發生了甚麼事情嗎？

So, everyone just like either get like squished by something or just dies cuz they wouldn't have oxygen

But would anyone be conscious to understand what-- what just happened??

Kressh: 好吧...所以這個議題好像就結束了，有人還記得當初的討論是怎麼結束的嗎？

Dom : 這種問題都沒有解答的，
就是故意做這種沒有正確答案的假想題，
我們就是單純...單純的...

Okay wait, so what was the end-- what was the end of the conversation?

Dom : 這才是其中美妙的地方啊，
我想在這其中沒有正確或錯誤的答案，
只有正確跟錯誤的理論。

There is no solution to this. These hypothetical there's no solution. We just... it's just...

Dom : 好喔，然後這是今天的問題..恩亨！

that's the beauty man. There's no right or wrong answers. Just... there's right and wrong reasoning, I guess.

Dom : 好！你要被改造到甚麼程度 -

Okay, so here's the question for-- for this episode *clears throat*

Do you become a cyborg? Let's say for example I-- I have

And I held it in my hand, and now I just don't let go for the rest of my life. Am I a cyborg?

- 到死都不放開
我這樣算是賽博格嗎？

Kressh : 好喔，不過我們是不是應該先定義...

Yeah, I think you need a define cyborg first.

Jomm : 對啊，我想你應該先定義
" 賽博格 "

Dom : 對對~幫我先定義一下甚麼是賽博格

"A fictional or hypothetical pers-- * hypothetical* person whose phys--
whose physical abilities are extended beyond normal human

" 一個虛構、或是假想... "
呵呵...假想...

limitations by mechanical elements built into the body."

" 一個虛構、或是假想的人物，
經由裝備機械 - "

" - 而擁有了超越常人力量的肉體 "

In the television broadcast that I saw, okay,

So they basically claim like even something as simple as a contact you wear for your eyes counts as being like a cyborg.

- 就像我之前在電視節目上有看過類似的討論

Okay, let's say let's say I hold the gun, and I tape my hands, so that I can't open it and release it.

他們宣稱，
基本上就算你只是裝了像是隱形眼鏡之類的物品，
你就算是個賽博格了

I'm thinking like, uh, like the exoskeletons people wear?

Dom : 這樣說好了，我握著那把搶，
然後用膠帶捆起來，這樣我就拔不下來了

Or like when someone like breaks their shin,

Khlboy : 我想這就像是...痾...
像是穿在身上的鎧甲一樣嗎？

And then you get like surgically stick a bar inside or something

Dom : 或像是如果有人小腿骨折 -

- 然後你必須在裡面安裝鐵條之類的東西

Jomm : 所以成龍也可以說是賽博格囉？

He's got metal all throughout his body. Oh from like the --

Kressh : 那不是...
Dom : 他有這樣嗎？

Dom : 喔~因為他...
Jomm : 因為他每次只要骨折就必須動手術

00:02:56,980 --> 00:02:59,240
Jomm : 喔對！我想這的確會讓他更強壯

So you're saying in the case of the hearing aid, it is a cyborg?

Kjlboy : 所以你是說只要做過類似的治療，都算是賽博格嗎？

But in the case of the gun sticking into your hand

Khlboy : 但是在這個把手槍綁在手上的假設 -

That is not a normal thing you can do, so it's not a cyborg now?

- 因為不是正常會做的事情，
所以就不算是賽博格了嗎？

I would say that doesn't bring you beyond normal limitation because you lose a function of a whole hand.

Jomm : 我會說這樣做你並沒有讓你 "超越常人" -

- 因為你等於放棄了整條手的能力

That's still less than like normal humans.

Dom : 對！但我還有另一隻手啊！

You're like adding a whole new structure to your body.

Khlboy : 你這比較像在身上加上了新的部位...
Dom : 但是...我...

00:03:24,040 --> 00:03:26,640
Jomm : 但這樣你並沒有變的更好啊！

I didn't say it's better. It's just like enhanced in a-- in that category, you know?

Dom : 我沒有說這樣比較好啊，
就好像我把天賦點在不同的地方一樣，
你懂嗎？

Jomm : 好吧，我不贊成，
我的想法是這樣的 -

- 當你身體功能都還正常的情況下 -

normally, but in a situation where you can't do something, you can do something now because you have that implant.

- 但是在某些正常無法做到一些事情的情況下，
卻因為這些裝備可以做到了

Kressh : 天哪...這一談又是另一支新影片了！

Wait. Isn't a cyborg still a human, basically?

Khlboy : 等等...賽博格基本上還算是人類吧

Time to look at the definition of android...

Okay well, let's put it in reverse. What--
 at what point?

Dom : 我是說，像是七龍珠 Z 那樣...

Do you have to take an android and add human elements before it stops being called cyborg?

Wait, when you take an android and start adding elements?

- 你要把人造人的多少部分的部件換成人體，
他才會開始算是賽博格？

Adding and so you know take an Android. Right? You have a yeah robotic skeleton, and you throw in--

Dom : 等等...你是說你在人造人身上裝人體？

So like, you know when Krillin uh, wished android 18 to be human?

Jomm : 對，假設現在有一個機器人身體的人造人，
然後開始把...

Dom : 所以你是指像是克林向龍珠許願讓 18 號變成人類那樣？

Okay, so you have a robot, and you slowly throw in human pieces like a brain, a liver, lungs, skin,

whatever. At what point does that stop becoming a cyborg?

And I think that's when we would get our definition for-- at what point does something become...

Jomm : 回歸正題，假設你有一個機器人，
然後你一步一步地把他的零件用人體換掉，
像是大腦、肝、肺、皮膚...

那要換掉多少東西，
他才不算是賽博格？

Yeah, like how many human bits do you have to throw in before it's not considered a cyborg anymore?

我想這能讓我們更了解
" 要到甚麼程度才算是... " 的想法

Uh... I'm gonna say brain. Brain, yeah because--

So you're saying if it's a fully robotic body with a human brain, it's not a cyborg?

Okay, if you're working like from the ground up with like organs first, and then the last thing replaces the brain

Jomm : 對！所以你要替換掉多少部件才不算是賽博格？

Domm : 痾...我會說大腦，
Kressh : 對！因為...

Jomm : 所以你是說，
如果有一個完全機器人的身體裝著人類的腦袋，
這樣也不算是賽博格嗎？

Dom : 好...如果你從頭開始替換，
一件一件器官慢慢換，
但把大腦留到最後 -

Like what ratio of cyborgs and human bits does it have to be before it's not a cyborg anymore?

字幕列表影片播放

我是生化人嗎？ (Am I A Cyborg?)

episode

stick

permanent

description