字幕列表 影片播放 列印所有字幕 列印翻譯字幕 列印英文字幕 “Only a few stones actually hit me. 「 只有幾顆石頭擊中了我 And obviously they don’t hurt. 並不太疼 This coat has been through a war, possibly two. 這件外套已經經歷過戰爭(意指文中的主角經歷過戰爭) Pebbles are nothing. 這些小石頭算不了什麼 It’s built for grenades.” 這件外套可以承受手榴彈(意指主角可以承受更多) So Meeder says, “Not only do I detect fact and a bit of humor in here, but I was wondering Meeder 接著說,「在這邊我不止發現到一些幽默幹和事實, whether this is a metaphor for being a feminist. 我也在想這會不會是用來比喻一個女權主義者 The small obstacles are something we blow away; we’ve got bigger fish to fry.” 我們將會排除萬難;我們還有更偉大的事要完成」 So that’s a quote from How to Be a Woman, and it’s the opening chapter where I’m 這是從 How to Be a Woman 中第一個章節節錄的一個句子 describing the worst birthday anyone’s ever had. 在這個章節我描述了你可以想像最糟糕的生日 It was my 13th birthday, and I was walking across some wastelands. 那是我13歲的生日,我路過一個荒地 And some boys started shouting at me, and then they started throwing stones at me. 有幾個男孩看到我後開始對我叫嚷,然後他們開始用石頭丟我 And I felt like turning round to them and saying, you know, I’m already oppressed 當時我恨不得轉過頭對他們說,我已經感到很壓迫很委屈了 enough, simply by being a woman! 僅僅身為一個女人 You don’t need to throw stones at me as well! 你們沒必要拿石頭丟我! Society is throwing enough stones at me as it is. 這個社會對我的壓迫已經夠多了 So yes, I know, it is very much a metaphor. 是的,我知道它是一種比喻 But you know, but within that metaphor there, cunningly, and I’m making this up as I go 但隱藏在這個比喻裡的是 along because I hadn’t thought about it, feminism is the coat that you’re wearing. 我之前沒有認真想過的事 - 女權主義就是你在穿的這件外套 In that thing, I was wearing a huge army coat of my dad’s that had been through several wars 我穿著這件我爸經歷過數次戰役的巨大軍衣 And that’s what feminism is, it’s the coat that will protect you. 這件軍隊外套和女權主義一樣,會保護你 It has been through several wars. 它已經歷經好幾次的戰役了 However many problems there may be being a woman or a girl now, compared to the problems 儘管如此,裡面提及的問題大部分是身為現代女性的問題 that we had 100 years ago, 150 years ago, you know we are definitely—there’s no 現代女性面對的難題和100、150年前顯然不一樣 better time in history to be a woman than now. 我們也應當感到慶幸,現在正是歷史上身為女人最好的時間點了 We’re not getting burnt at the stake anymore. 女性不會再被奇怪的理由苛責和處罰 Hair products have improved immeasurably, so frizzy hair need not be a problem. 護髮產品越來越好用,捲髮不再是問題 You know, we have Benedict Cumberbatch’s face. 像 Benedict Cumberbatch 俊俏的臉 You know, things are definitely getting better. 凡事會越來越好 Things are improving, for sure. 凡事都在進步,這是一定的 No, I think that’s so true. 我覺得這是一定的 I think feminism and the feminist movement and finding a community of women through feminism 我覺得女權主義本身、女權運動、通過女權主義找到合適的團體 and all of these things have sort of like—it feels like have been creating this force field 這些事彷彿在我身邊創造了一個力場 around me, which has been sort of insulating me from all sorts of cold weather—sexism, 這個力場有某些特別的能力,可以將我我從各種惡劣的氛圍隔離,像是 - 性別歧視 patriarchy, so. 父權等等,所以 I totally relate. 我完全可以理解和想像 I totally relate. 我完全可以理解和想像 Well it’s that saying, isn’t it? 有一個名言是說 Kind of like standing on the shoulders of giants. 站在巨人的肩膀上 And I say I’m standing on the shoulders of aunts. 我覺得應該說是站在阿姨的肩膀上 Because that’s who they are, all these women that came before that have done these things. 因為這就是她們,這些女性身為過來人完成了很多事 All the little laws that they brought in, all the marches that they went on have incrementally 她們的付出、帶來的改變是逐漸增量的 made my life better. 讓我現在可以過上更好的生活 You would not be sitting there, and I would not be sitting here, if it wasn’t for probably 你我都不會坐在這裡 20 women who went out there and changed things. 如果不是因為這20個女性當時做了改變的決定 But that’s the beautiful thing—one person can change things for millions of people. 不過這也是讓人著迷的地方 - 即使是一個人也有可能為無數人做出一些改變 One person can alter the future, and everything that I write, the idea of writing Moranifesto, 一個人就可以改變未來,我所寫的任何事,寫 Moranifesto 這本書的理念 was everyone, I genuinely believe everyone has one idea, however tiny, that could change 是有關於任何一個個體,我由衷地相信任何一個人,只要他有一個想法,哪怕是很微小的 the world. 這個想法也是有能力改變世界的 And we need all those little ideas. 我們非常需要這些微小但有潛力的想法 That’s the only way the world changes, is by everybody who has that idea, having, making 這是唯一讓這個世界不斷進步的方法,我們確保這些有想法的人 sure that we have a society that is structured so that if you have a great idea, it can be 可以在一個結構完善的社會,當你有好的想法的時候 heard by the right people and can be put into action. 你的想法可以被有利於幫助你實現想法的人聽見 That’s the idea of democracy. 這就是民主的觀念 I love the letter that you wrote to your daughter at the end of Moranifesto. 我非常喜歡在 Moranifesto 的最後,你寫給你女兒的信 And it actually reminded me of—I’m currently, I’m re-reading 1984 at the moment because 這封信讓我想起一些事 - 我現在正在重讀1984 I did a film called The Circle, which has a lot of the same themes. 因為我正參與一部 The Circle 這部電影,1984和這部電影有很多議題很類似 And it talks about, in this book, how for the first time in human history, we could—we 在這本書提到在人類歷史上,我們可以 - actually have the potential, we have the technology, we have the scientific advances, we have the 我們確實有這個潛力、我們有技術、科技日新月異 knowledge, for the first time, to feed the world, to possibly create peace, to actually 我們有知識,我們可以餵飽人口、為世界帶來和平 achieve all of these things. 去達成以上所說的事 But for the first time in human history, we don’t believe that it’s possible, that 但同時這也是人類史上第一次,我們不相信這些是有可能辦到的 humanity will allow us to do that. 我們不相信人性可以讓我們辦到這些 We don’t believe in the innate goodness of humans to achieve this anymore. 我們不再相信人性本善將足以幫助我們達成這些 There’s this kind of disillusionment which has followed the Enlightenment, there’s 人們在啟蒙運動結束後感到悲觀、幻滅 this lack of hope that we can actually get this done anymore, and it’s so ironic and 人們缺乏希望,人們不再相信其實這些都是可以辦到的 tragic that it really would be the first moment we would actually be able to do it. 這其實非常諷刺和悲慘,因為這次是我們第一次離大同世界最接近的一次 And there’s been all these times in history when we were writing books about utopias and 以往我們都是寫了許多有關烏托邦的書 we were imagining all of these wonderful societies, and whatever else. 我們都在想像這些美好的人事物 And now all we do is we make movies about dystopias and about the world ending and apocalypse 而現在我們卻大量生產這些提倡反烏托邦、世界毀滅的電影 and everything just crumbling around us. 在提倡一切都快完蛋瓦解的世界 I thought that was really interesting, and I just—I loved that your—I loved that Moranifesto 我覺得這點非常有趣,我非常喜歡 Moranifesto was just full of hope, and just the idea that this is absolutely possible. 我覺得它給人帶來希望,我喜歡它所提倡的大同世界是有可能達成的這個想法 You don’t need to watch the news every night. 我們不需要每晚都看新聞 You know, you can actually—you can have a diet of hope and belief and faith in human beings 對人性本善、保持正向這件事抱有信心和希望就可以讓我們充滿力量 Well, totally. 是的,完全沒錯 Well the future is a propaganda war. 未來的世界是被宣傳和口號牽引的 You know, kind of like, we are choosing whether we’re going to be pessimistic or optimistic 對於未來,我們可以選擇要往悲觀或樂觀的方向 about the future. 對於未來,我們可以選擇要往悲觀或樂觀的方向 And the way that the news media is set up at the moment, and the tone that social media 現在的新聞媒體的操作方式,以及社群網路所製造的討論氛圍 has, these two incredibly powerful places where we have all our conversations, and where 這兩個現代人接收以及探討事情的主要平台 we go—what’s the world like today? 我們的方向在哪裡? I’ll look at the news and I’ll go on social media. 我會先看新聞,然後我就會到社群網站去 That’s what the world is now. 現代人對訊息以及媒體的交流就是這樣 And the tone of both those places is incredibly pessimistic. 而我們可以發現,不管是主流媒體或社群網站,氛圍都相當悲觀 It’s only showing us problems. 媒體讓我們看到的都是問題 It’s only showing us things when they’ve tipped over and it seems like they can’t 媒體只讓我們看到失敗的事情 be solved anymore. 讓我們覺得這些事都沒有解決的方法 And people’s reaction to that is necessarily one of being completely overwhelmed, and just 人們對這些訊息的反應必須是招架不住的 going well we’re pumped then, this is it. 唯有如此,當結果反而是好的時候,人們就會感到振奮 And but that’s where you realize that like on a day to day basis one of the greatest 不過這也是讓我們發現在生活中 things that you can do to the continuation of our species and making the world a better 可以讓我們的下一代過得更好的方式就是 place is to be optimistic, is to not believe in that. 要付諸行動讓這個世界充滿希望,而不是單純相信而已 Because, you know, if we all thought that everything was going to get better, then things 只有當我們相信一切都會變好的時候 would get better. 事情才會變好 But you know, if at the point where you just become, oh no, it’s just too exhausting, 如果不幸的在某個時間點我們覺得筋疲力盡沒辦法繼續下去 I can’t do anything about it– It’s not going to make a difference. 覺得自己沒辦法完成任何事,覺得沒辦法帶來改變 —that is where we lose the war. 這時候,我們就會敗下陣來 So, there’s a brilliant lyrics by the band The Divine Comedy, “Fate doesn’t hang 樂團 The Divine Comedy 有一句歌詞寫得非常好 on a wrong or right choice. 「 命運不會被對或錯的決定左右 Fate just depends on the tone of your voice.” 你的心態將決定你的命運」。 And that is so key, because you know, if you make mistakes in your life, you know, decisions 這很關鍵,假設你在你的人生犯錯 that you make won’t ruin your life. 你做的抉擇不會把你的人生毀了 But if your tone all the way through is one of unhappiness or anger or if you’re an 但如果你一直都維持一貫的不開心、憤怒 unpleasant person, that will dictate your life. 或是不友善,這一點將會決定你的人生 And it’s the same with our species. 決定了人生,就會決定我們人類這個物種 We can make all these mistakes, but if our general tone is one of we’re together in 犯錯是被允許的,但如果大家的心態是團結的 this, we’re going to make things better, then that 大家的心態是可以一起把事情變得更好的話 is what will happen. 事情就真的可以變得更好 But this is why culture’s so key, and the thing that I enjoyed most about my writing 這也是為什麼文化是非常關鍵的,它讓我的寫作生涯感到滿足和享受 and why I think it’s amazing you’re doing what you’re doing, and it’s because for 它讓我感受到活在當下 too long these kinds of conversations have only happened in politics or in academia, 這是因為有很長一段時間,這些對話只發生在政治和學院上 and you know, not many people will pay attention to those things. 只有少數人會對這些事表示關心 You only come to those things late: you only come to academia when you’re in your teens 當我們接觸這些時已經相對晚了:我們只有在青春期或二十幾歲才會開始接觸學術 or in your twenties. 當我們接觸這些時已經相對晚了:我們只有在青春期或二十幾歲才會開始接觸學術 You probably won’t start to get into politics until that time as well. 我們恐怕最早也要到二十歲才會開始接觸政治 But as a child, when you’re growing up, what you think the world is and what your 不過身為小朋友,當我們在長大的時候,全世界和我們可能接觸的事對我們來說 possibilities are, is stories. 是各種故事 It’s the films you watch, it’s the TV you watch, it’s the things you see in magazines. 是我們看的電影、電視、雜誌 And that’s why making sure that you have as many different stories as possible and 這也是確保我們在故事以及內容可以盡量有更多的選擇 as many different people represented in these things are key. 這也是確保我們在故事以及內容可以盡量有更多的選擇 One of the big examples that I give in the books is, when I was growing up one of the 其中一個我在書裡提到的例子是,在我小時候 worst things you could say to a boy in the playground was “you’re a gaylord” you 人們在操場對小男孩說的最糟糕的話是「你是同性戀」 know, “you’re a queer.” 人們在操場對小男孩說的最糟糕的話是「你是同性戀」 Like they were destroyed, you know, to say that someone was gay, that was the end of their life 小男孩聽到這句話,對他們的傷害是非常大的,就想世界末日一樣 Then you fast forward 20 years into the future, and the writer Russell T. Davies writes, first 接著讓我們快轉二十年,編劇 Russell T.Davies 寫了 of all, Queer as Folk, and then takes over Doctor Who, and writes into Doctor Who this 同志亦凡人、異世奇人這兩部電視劇 brilliant, swashbuckling bisexual superhero Captain Jack Harkness, who, in one episode, 他創造了Captain Jack Harkness 這個聰穎、英勇並且是雙性戀的角色 kisses the Doctor on Prime Time TV. 這個角色在其中一集播出的黃金時段親吻了主角 the Doctor And not only are there no letters of complaint to the BBC about this, but when I go to my 當時 BBC 不僅沒收到任何投訴信 daughter’s school on Monday morning, there are boys in the playground fighting to play 當我禮拜一早晨到我女兒的學校時,操場上的男生都爭先恐後想要扮演這個雙性戀的角色 this bisexual character. 當我禮拜一早晨到我女兒的學校時,操場上的男生都爭先恐後想要扮演這個雙性戀的角色 Because we’ve now got a story, we’ve now got a character. 因為現在我們有了一個故事,我們有了一個角色 Instead of it just being the word “gay” we’ve got this hero that everybody wants 這個角色不僅僅是一般的「 同性戀」這個字,而是一個大家都想要成為的角色 to be. 這個角色不僅僅是一般的「 同性戀」這個字,而是一個大家都想要成為的角色 And I can draw a direct line between that show and that character, and then passing 我可以把那個電視節目和那個角色所產生的效果 the equal marriage act in this country. 歸功於讓這個國家順利通過同性婚姻法 Because when you’ve got children in a playground who are fine with bisexuality and see all 因為當我們的小孩對雙性戀感到沒什麼不妥的時候 love as equal, their fathers and grandfathers who’re in Parliament can’t go, Well we 當他們視所有的愛都是平等的,但他們在立法院的祖父爸爸卻沒辦法認同這些 don’t believe in this. 我們不會相信這個的 Your children have shamed you. 如果真的發生這種事,我們的孩子會把我們比下去 Culture is there to show you possible futures. 所以,一個地方、族群的文化將會為我們預測未來的前景 And again, that’s why it’s so important to make sure that you’ve got all these different 這也是我一再強調 voices, and particularly if you possibly can, to tell an optimistic story. 我們必須容納這些不同的聲音,而當能力許可的時候,去弘揚正面的故事 Show us a better future. 為大家示範、指出一個更好的未來 Show us—show me amazing people doing amazing things. 為大家示範 - 了不起的人們可以做了不起的事 Because that’s what children are watching, and going, “Yeah, that’s gonna be my future! 因為這將會是小孩看到的,他們會說「 沒錯,這將會是我的未來! I believe in that!” 我對此深信不疑!」 It’s really interesting, since doing my work with UN Women, and since becoming more 這非常有趣,自從我和聯合國婦女開始合作共事 involved in this movement generally, people have said, Well, are you going to give up, 自從我更多的參與這類的活動,人們都會問我說,你什麼時候要放棄 now? 現在嗎? Do you not want to act anymore? 你不要演戲了嗎? Are you not going to be an actress? 你不想繼續當一個演員了嗎? And if anything, it’s actually reinstilled my passion for what I do, and made it more important 如果我參與這些互動對我有任何的意義和改變,我覺得是對於我想做的事,重新讓我找到熱忱,也讓這些事變得更重要 Well, the other key thing about culture is, again, if you want to change the world, you 另一個有關文化的關鍵點是,如果你想要改變世界 can argue all day that something’s right or wrong. 我們也許可以一直對一些事的對錯爭論不休 You can say women should be equal to men, we should see women in films equally to men, 我們也許可以說女性應該是和男性平等的,電影的女性的出場次數不應該比男性少 living incredible stories and solving their problems. 女性應該也要過著精彩的生活、可以自己解決問題 You can argue that forever, but that argument can go on forever, and there’s no real way 我們可以永遠地去爭辯這點 of resolving it. 但這不是真正的解決之道 Or! 或是! You can make the right thing cool, and you can just simply show me an amazing woman. 我們可以做出對的事,女性可以直接活出精彩的人生 And that’s what culture does time and time again, it doesn’t argue. 這就是從古至今文化可以辦到的,文化從不單純爭辯 David Bowie could have spent all of his life writing academic treatises and lobbying Parliament David Bowie 可以花他一生的時間專注於撰寫學術論文和說服立法院 going, you know, bisexuality and gay men who are pretending to be aliens should be accepted 來達到讓這個社會有辦法接受被貼上外來者的雙性戀和同性戀 into society. 來達到讓這個社會有辦法接受被貼上外來者的雙性戀和同性戀 It wouldn’t have gone very far. 如果他採取的是這種方式,恐怕效果不會太好 Instead, he dresses like a gay alien and writes Life on Mars and suddenly everyone’s like, 他反而直接打扮成看似外星人的同性戀打扮、寫了 Life on Mars 這首歌 I wanna be a gay alien! 突然間大家都能接受同性戀,都想要變成外星人同性戀了! It’s a great idea, this is genius! 這真是一個很棒的想法,簡直天才! Culture wins! 文化戰勝一切! It’s faster, and it’s more fun. 這樣會比較有效率,也比較好玩 Because this—the whole thing about change and the revolution and feminism, you know, 因為我們在說的這些有關於改變、革命、女權主義 all these things we’re talking about, anti-racism and equality and the trans movement and stuff. 反種族歧視、平等、跨性別權利運動 It doesn’t need to be worthy and like, eating your fiber and your bran bread, you know and 我們其實沒有必要把它看得太嚴肅 eating your vitamins. 或是一切都要照著死板板的規則去做 The future should be fun, a more inclusive future where people are free to love and are 未來應該是活潑好玩的,一個可以包容的未來是由一群可以自由戀愛 not scared. 和不會被壓迫、恐嚇的人們組成的 It should be amazing, that should be a party you want to join! 他應該是精彩的,應該是一個我們願意加入的派對 We shouldn’t be having to go, “This is the right thing to do,” we should just be 我們不應該覺得「做這件事是因為我覺得他是對的,是必需的」 going, “This is where you wanna be, man.” 我們應該覺得「做這件事是因為我想要這樣做」 So, Jenny wants to know: in chapter 7, I Encounter Some Sexism, you make a point about the possible Jenny 想要知道:在第七章,I Encounter Some Sexism reasons why women didn’t have a great role in human history. 你為女性為何在人類史上較少扮演重要的角色給予一些解釋和看法 How did you come to these conclusions? 請問你是怎麼得到這些結論的? What enlightened you? 有什麼事特別啟發了你嗎? When you’re taught history at school, and you look at the history of women as it’s 當我們在學校學習歷史的時候,通過觀察女性隨著時間軸的歷史 depicted time and time—you know, our accepted story of humanity is generally the story of men 不難發現,現代人所理解的人性大部分是圍繞於男性的 We tend to only hear about what men did. 我們通常只能聽說男性做了什麼 I’ve learnt a bit more since I wrote that book, because that was 5 years ago. 在完成那本書到現在已經過了五年,在這段時間我又學了更多 I had just presumed that women weren’t doing anything, and that was primarily because we 我當時只是假定女性沒在做什麼事 were giving birth or having raging cystitis that we were gonna have to wait 400 years 會這麼假定是因為我當時覺得女性都在懷孕生子、和膀胱炎奮鬥 before they invented antibiotics to cure, and the combination of those two things was 大概也要等個四百年,男性才有辦法發明適合的抗生素來治療女性 why we didn’t discover America; that, and the very uncomfortable skirts and underwear 這就是為什麼發現新大陸的不會是女性;女性所謂的一些天職 that we were wearing. 和我們身上穿的這些極不舒服的裙子和內衣褲 But since then, I’ve learnt a lot more about female history, and I particularly watched—and 不過自從完成那本書以後,我對女性的歷史有了更多的認識 I know that you’ve seen it as well—that show, The Ascent of Woman, by Dr. Amanda Foreman, 我尤其看了那個節目,我知道很多人也有再在看 - Dr Amanda Foreman 的 The Ascent of Woman who is— Such a major babe! 她真是一個可敬的人 Yes. 是的 And she did the brilliant thing. 她做了了不起的事 It was an answer to, so the biggest BBC documentary previously about the history of humankind 她對於之前 BBC 製作的一部有關於人類史的紀錄片做出了回應 was the history of mankind, and it was Civilization by Dr. Alan Clark*, and that was just the 這部名為 Civilization 的紀錄片是由 Dr Alan Clark 所製作 history of men. 這是一部有關於被男性主導的人類史 And so what Dr. Amanda Foreman has done is gone, Ok, let’s have a look at the history Dr Amanda Foreman 所做的一切都沒被看見。好的,讓我們看看 of women. 女性的歷史 And it was one of the most mindblowing premises I’ve ever seen, because she’s done all 這是我看過最令人印象深刻以及打動人心的聲明之一 of her history and all of her research, and she tells an extraordinary story, which tells Dr Amanda Foreman 做了很多功課和研究,她述說了一個超凡的故事 us that at one point, men and women probably were equal. 她告訴我們,曾經有一個時候,男性和女性很有可能是平等的 It’s in pre-history, so we don’t know, but we have to presume there was more equality 那時候可能是前歷史,所以我們無法確認,但我們必須假定曾經有一段時間女生是更加能夠和男生平起平坐的 because we can start to see from 10,000 BC onwards laws coming in that are against women. 接著我們可以發現,從公元前10,000年開始,各種針對女性的規定和法律陸續出現 And the only reason they’d be having to write down these new laws is presumably because 這些新規則和新法律在一開始並不存在,這也是之後它們需要被記錄下來的原因 they didn’t exist before. 因為它們一開始是不存在的 So you can see sexism being constructed. 我們可以發現,性別歧視是被人類創造出來的 You can see gradually women’s rights being taken away from them, being prescribed what 女性的權利漸漸被剝削、掠奪 women should do. 女性被告知她們應該怎麼做 The shut down of women in society, them being hedged out of activity and being shut down. 女性在現代社會的角色慢慢被隔離、減少、甚至失去功能 And to watch that, I just genuinely believe it should be on the curriculum, I think every 我覺得這部紀錄片應該被收錄在學校課剛課綱 man and woman should watch it, because so many of these things that we experience as 每個男性和女性都應該看這部紀錄片,當我們看了這部紀錄片 emotions, like “women can’t do these things, women can’t rule a city, we are inferior, 許多我們可以感受到的情緒,像是「女性什麼事都辦不好、女性無法管理一個城市、女性是低下的 we haven’t done anything…” 女性一無所成...」 Once you watch that show, it’s like, no, we were trying all the time, because the other 當我們看了這部紀錄片,我們會頓時覺得,其實女性一直都在努力 great thing she does, even though she’s showing you all the ways that women were shut 因為她(Dr Foreman)做了很多了不起的事,即使她告訴我們女性一直以來都被打壓 down, she’s showing you time and time again these women that flourished. 她也告訴我們,還是有很多女性不時會有不錯的表現 These women that did educate themselves, these women that did rule, these women that did 這些自學、自治的女性 try and change things, these women who did try and connect with each other. 這些嘗試改變現況、嘗試踏出舒適圈和世界接軌的女性 And it’s—it’s simultaneously incredibly depressing and incredibly uplifting, but at 這真是即沮喪同時又振奮人心 the end of it you just feel—you feel woke, you feel informed as to what it is to be a 不過看到最後,我們會覺得豁然開朗 woman and what has gone before us. 我們會對身為女性這個身份的認識和女性的歷史有更深入的了解 Yeah, totally. 是的,完全認同 And again, it’s that thing about needing to see something before you can even know 很多時候人在相信自己內在的潛力之前需要得到一些啟發 somewhere inside yourself that it’s possible, and I think knowing as a civilization we have 我相信在現代的文明 found a way to do this, to live in harmony and in equality, and knowing that that’s 我們已經發現解決之道、因此我們可以和睦共處、維持性別平等 something that has existed and that we could potentially get back to is pretty cool. 了解這些是可能發生的讓我感受良好 Yeah, it’s an amazing show. 是的,這是一部傑出的紀錄片 I think it’s on Netflix now—and so it is available, and I would genuinely—everyone 現在可以在 Netflix 收看這部紀錄片,我衷心推薦給全部人 that I have made watch it, and I have made everybody I know watch it, has just come round 任何被我說服而去看這部紀錄片的人 the next week and just gone, it blows your mind! 看完之後都對我說,這部片徹底改變他們對女權的看法 You genuinely feel a new part of your mind forming. 看了之後可以為我們的思想注入新思維 I tried to harass the BBC to put it back on my player, but didn’t succeed with that, 我曾經騷擾 BBC 的人把它放在我的專屬網路播放器,不過沒成功 but Netlfix has covered it now, so… 可喜的是 Netflix 已經把它放上去了 Well done Netflix. 幹得好,Netflix Netflix for the chicks! Netflix 萬歲! Celeste wants to know, I thought her argument that many religions were created in a time Celeste 想問的是,你(Caitlin)對於許多宗教是在 where women were considered second-class citizens was very important, and wonder what a religion 女性被認為是二等公民的時代所創教的這點 made by a woman would look like in her mind? 對於女性的影響有什麼看法? Well, this is the great thing like kind of one of the things that I’m working on now 這是一個我目前正在努力搞懂的事情 is, for one of the next books I’m going to write, is imagining that. 也是我下一本書的題材 Because this is a three-parter, isn’t it? 因為這是三部曲,對嗎? No? 不是嗎? Well, there probably—you know what, I’m never going to stop writing. 也許吧,反正我不會停止寫作 Okay, amazing! OK,太精彩了! Definitely, which will be fun. 當然,而且會很好玩 And you know, and so some people, you’re always worried you’re going to anger people, 我們必須知道,有些人會過於擔心自己的言行會激怒別人 but you do have to remind people that religions were invented by people. 但我們必須記得宗教是被人創造的 Some people haven’t thought of that, but these things were invented, all these things 有些人可能沒想過這點,但它們的確是被創造的 that are religious rights, you know, things that—when you talk about FGM, and people 這些因宗教名義而被合法化的事 - 像是女性割禮 are going, “It’s a custom.” 都被人們認為是一種合法的習俗 So, it was invented by someone. 既然它們是被人類創造的 So it can be un-invented by someone. 那它們也可以被人們推翻 You have to remember that these are things that we have invented. 我們必須知道這些不合理的事都是我們創造的 And when you look at so much of what’s in religion, you know it’s almost like a little 當我們看看宗教想要傳達什麼給我們的時候 kind of “how to survive” guidebook. 不難發現,它就像一本「如何生存」的指南書 You know, it’s things like “don’t eat pork and shellfish.” 比如說,「不要吃豬肉和貝類」 That’s cause they lived in a hot place and those were the things that went off quickest, 因為當時的人們住在炎熱的地方,豬肉和貝類非常容易變質 and you know, that would kill you. 吃了這些可能會要你的命 You’d get food poisoning. 可能會食物中毒 And so again, that when they’re writing about women, you have to remember that, you 所以,當宗教提到有關女性的時候,我們必須記得 know, this was just what people thought at the time. 這都是那個年代的人的想法 And so the idea of, if we invented a religion from scratch now, what would it be, that fascinates me 假設我們現在要創造一個宗教,我們會創造出什麼樣的宗教呢?這點讓我很感興趣 If I was a teacher, I’d be in schools, I’d make—you know, and if I was a religious 如果我是一個宗教老師 teacher, I’d go, okay, we’re going to invent a religion today, and it’s gonna 我會和同學說,好的,我們今天要創造一個宗教 be, let’s see what would happen. 讓我們看看會有什麼火花吧 What would you kids invent today if you invented a religion, and, you know, you made sure that 今天小朋友要創造宗教的話,我們會確認 it was female friendly, that it was about equality? 它是對女性友善的,確定這個宗教是性別平等的 To see what kids would invent, -Fascinating!- would thrill and fascinate me. 看看現在的小朋友會創造出什麼的這個想法非常吸引我 - 真的! It would be amazing. 這真是太好了 Charlie wants to know, why do you think so many parts of the world including our own Charlie 想要問,你對全世界,包括我們的國家 are so scared of making long-lasting decisions regarding gender equality? 在有關於性別平等方面沒辦法果斷的、勇敢的做出一些持久的決定有什麼看法? What are they afraid of? 他們是有什麼特別的顧慮嗎? Well, I mean that’s down to the political system, isn’t it? 這就要歸咎於政治了,不是嗎? Which is just a bit unfortunate, because people are only, you know, you only have government 不幸的是,一個任期也只有 terms for four years. 四年 And you do get a lot of people who are… don’t really feel politics in their blood, 現在很多人都缺乏在政治上的遠見,也缺乏對於政治的熱忱 but they’re just kind of like, well that’s a career that I could do for 10 years, I could 他們會覺得,反正我也只能幹十年 have done anything. 那我想幹嘛就可以幹嘛 I’ll go into politics for 10 years and then go on to work for other companies or other 我就進入政壇混個十年,之後再到其他公司 consultancies. 當個顧問 So they’re not really interested in long term plans. 他們不太會對長期經營一個國家有很好的計劃 And also, long term plans are hard! 還有,長期計劃是非常困難的! You know? 你知道嗎? It’s the difference between being on a diet for 1 day and eating healthfully for the rest 這就像節食一天和一輩子實行健康飲食的差別 of your life. 這就像節食一天和一輩子實行健康飲食的差別 Anybody can just starve for 1 day, but eating healthfully for the rest of your life is an 任何人都可以不吃不喝一天,但一輩子控制飲食、一輩子吃得健康 entirely different thing. 這又是完全不一樣的事了 But, being on a diet for one day and starving is completely useless. 可惜的是,節食甚至不吃不喝一天是沒有好處的 Eating healthfully for the rest of your life is a key to what you need to have. 一輩子實行健康和均衡飲食才是關鍵 So we need to look at the way the political system works, and build in incentives for 所以我們必須觀察政治如何運作 making long-term improvements in to our society. 並對系統改造,建立一些激勵機制,來鼓勵這些政治人物為我們的社會做出長期的貢獻和進步 And we’ll only do that if people, who aren’t career politicians, want to get involved in 要辦到這些,唯有讓那些非政客的人們願意 politics again. 重新投入政治 The kind of people who will be MPs for 40 or 50 years representing their local area, 那些願意在他們的地區當個四五十年的民意代表 because then they have accountability. 因為這些人才有能力擔當,對他們做的事負責 If they’re not there putting in plans that benefit everybody long term, then the people 如果他們沒辦法履行承諾,沒辦法讓大家因他們的長期計劃受益 that they’re representing back in their home town will not elect them anymore. 選民就會拋棄他們,他們也不會連任 So it’s that reconnecting of politics. 這就是在政治裡面應該看到的良性循環,而不是政客一面倒地支配選民 Just getting those ideas from the people up to Parliament again. 民意代表應該讓地方選民的想法和心聲可以傳達到國會 And one of the reasons that I wanted to write Moranifesto was to make politics a good profession 而我寫 Moranifesto 的其中一個原因就是希望讓政治重新變成一個 to go into again. 優良的專業 Because I think these days politics is so devalued. 因為我覺得現在的政治的價值已經大不如前 People are so disillusioned by politicians. 人們都對政客感到失望 We hate politicians. 我們討厭政客 The rise of Donald Trump in America is people just going, well he’s not a politician. Donald Trump 在美國政壇的崛起正是因為,他不是一般的政客類型 So we’ll vote for him. 所以才會有人想投票給他 Yeah, he’s like, he’s talking real talk. 他給人的感覺就像,對啊,他說的很對 Because they think he lives outside of that system. 因為大家覺得他不屬於大家所熟悉的、所厭惡的政治體系 Exactly, well of course he’s hugely part of that—he is the system. 沒錯,不過其實事情不是這樣,他本身就是這個體系 He inherited billions of dollars. 他繼承了數十億美金的財產 You know, he is the system. 他就是這個體系 There’s no one more the system than Donald Trump. 世上沒有其他的體系是更加的 Donald Trump 了 But people think he’s non-political, he’s not a professional politician, and so they’re 但一般人覺得他沒有政治色彩、不是一般的政客 voting for him. 所以大家決定投票給他 And people don’t trust politicians anymore, to the point where, if your child came downstairs 人們不再相信政客的地步已經達到,當小孩和家長說 and said, Mum, I’ve decided I want to be a politician, you would probably treat them 媽媽,我決定以後要當一個政治人物的時候 as if they had just said, Mum, I’ve decided to be a massive pervert. 人們會以為小朋友說他想要當一個色情變態狂一樣 You know, good people don’t want to go into politics anymore, and that was, you know, 好人都不再願意投入政治工作了 we need to change that conversation, and you know, and look to the MPs that do address 我們必須改變這點,給予那些願意正視這些問題的民意代表支持 these things. 我們必須改變這點,給予那些願意正視這些問題的民意代表支持 You know, I love Stella Creasy, who’s a brilliant, obviously female, MP who’s there. 我非常喜愛 Stella Creasy,她是一個聰明的女性民意代表 She works brilliantly on the local level, she works on the national level. 不管是區域或是全國性的場合,她都可以做的非常好 You know, she was there for the tampon tax, she talks about payday loans. 她為棉塞稅和發薪日貸款發聲 You know, just things that change people’s long term. 這些是會為人們帶來長期改變的事 Rather than being one of those politicians who just comes in, kind of shakes some hands, 她並不是那些沒實際作為、只有動動嘴巴的政客 go, “I’m deeply concerned about this,” and then does nothing about it. 就說說「我為此感到非常擔憂」,然後什麼都不幹 I mean there are plenty of them. 這些政客真的很多 No, it’s true. 真的,你說的沒錯 I think, god, wouldn’t it be awesome if kids were excited to say, I’m going to be 我會想,天啊,如果有一天小朋友會說,將來有一天我要 a politician one day. 成為一個政治家而非政客 It would be amazing! 那真是太好了 So excited. 非常振奮人心 We have devalued politics, and it’s to our—you know, it’s the people who get screwed over 我們把政治的價值貶低了,而遭殃的是人民 by that. 我們把政治的價值貶低了,而遭殃的是人民 Aspirational. 非常具有抱負 You know, the demos in democracy means the people. 民主還是要回歸人民 And we are losing the people in democracy, and we need to make it an honorable job again. 人民在現代的民主已經慢慢失去扮演的角色了,我們必須讓人民重返榮耀 So, for feminists, the area of everything from porn to stripping to prostitution is 對於大部分的女權主義者,凡是有關於色情、脫衣舞、性工作的領域 often sort of lumped into one category or perceived in the same way as one big problem. 都被歸納成一個分類,或是被用一個單一的方式看成是一個大問題 And I’m really interested that you have very different views on each individual topic. 你對這些各別的議題都有不同的看法,我對這點很感興趣 So you have a very different view on stripping from what you do on porn, from what you do 你對脫衣舞、色情、性工作有不同的看法 on sex work, from what you do—and, I found that really interesting and really specific, 我真的覺得非常有趣、而且非常特定和具體 and I just wondered if you could talk about how you see all of those things, and why you 你可否說說看你是如何看待這些事的 see them so distinctly and separately. 你為何要把它們分類得這麼細緻和清楚、分明 Well you’re so right that the big problem is that they do all get lumped together. 我非常認同你說的,當他們把這些各別的問題都歸類在一起時候,本身就是一個很嚴重的問題 That’s, again, because we’re not used to talking about women, and also we freak 這是因為我們不常討論女性的種種問題,我們不習慣這麼做 out about female sexuality, and that is rooted in, again, history. 所以只要提到有關女性在性方面的話題,我們就感到很奇怪彆扭,而這再次顯現出這個根深蒂固的問題 Like, kind of, you know, up until we invented contraception and antibiotics, for a woman 怎麼說彆扭呢?在避孕法成熟以及抗生素問世以前 to be and to have sexual desire and be sexually active, meant that A: she was at risk of disease, 女性只要表達出性慾或是在性生活比較活躍的時候,這就表示 A:她得到性病的風險會提高 and B: risk of pregnancy. B:她懷孕的風險也會提高 And you know, those are things you generally wanted to avoid, because you had a 1 in 4 這些其實都是當時的人不希望發生的,因為當時的醫療不太進步 chance of dying in childbirth, you know, and diseases were completely incurable. 懷孕死亡的機率是四分之一,而性病是沒辦法被治癒的 So, it was in a woman’s interest to not be sexual, you know, a chaste woman would 所以,當時的人們認為,為了女性的健康著想,女性不應該有活躍的性生活 be a safe woman. 維持貞潔的女性能避免疾病的危害 She had a better chance of living. 她們可以活得更久 And yeah, from a male point of view, you would want a chaste woman because you wouldn’t 同時,從男性的角度出發,男性會希望迎娶保有貞潔的女性 want to catch a disease from her. 因為男性不希望從女性身上染上性病 These are the simple, you know, awful facts of history. 這些就是簡單但可怕的歷史 Obviously everything’s changed now. 當然,現在已經不一樣了 Women can have sex without getting pregnant. 女性在享受性愛的同時可以避免懷孕 You know, we can cure these diseases. 性病也可以被治愈 So, if we look at all these things now, something like sex work, if we invented sex work now 所以,假設我們現在重新審視這些議題,比如說和性工作有關的,假設我們現在創造這些性工作機會 we would not have the attitudes to it that we have, because ours are rooted in a time 我們沒辦法用應有的態度來看待,因為我們的觀念是在以往那個充滿恐懼和疾病的時代培養的 of fear and disease, and a time when a sexual woman was seen as a bad woman; you’re either 那是一個性活躍的女性被視為壞女人的時代 a whore or a virgin. 那是一個除了婊子就是處女的時代 You know, my view, and you know I’m still flexible on this, I’m still learning about 在我的看法,我對這個議題的討論空間是很大的,我還在摸索學習 it, but my view on sex work is that we have all these intimate things that we’re happy 不過我對性工作有一個看法,生活其實不乏這種利用金錢來交換一些和我們非常親密的事 to exchange money for. 我們也很樂意這麼做 You know, we will pay people to look after our dying people. 我們會付錢給人幫忙照顧垂死、接受安寧照護的人 We will pay people to look after our newborn babies. 我們付錢讓保姆照顧新生兒 You can pay someone to bleach your bumhole from brown to pink if you so desire. 我們甚至可以付錢保養肛門,讓它變成粉紅色 We are unashamed of all of these things, and yet this one thing, sex work, we sort of go, 對於這些事,我們都不會覺得害羞,卻對性工作這件事有很多意見 No, that has to be completely special. 不對 We just need to make those women safe now. 我們現在只需要確保這些女性性工作者的安全 We can talk later and untangle this huge thing of centuries of us being screwed up about 關於性工作這個議題實在是太複雜了,我們可以之後再慢慢討論 sex, but as things are at the moment, we leave women who do sex work to be in dangerous places. 目前的現況是我們對這些女性性工作者的安全置之不理 We put them on the edges of towns like sacrificial victims that are left on the edges of towns. 我們就像把她們晾在城市的邊邊等著受害 They’re the bad girls that are allowed to be killed. 彷彿她們都是罪該萬死的壞女孩 So we need to make sure those women are safe, that’s the first thing we do. 我們應該要確保這些女人的安全的,這是當務之急 We make sure that they can work in brothels, that they are known to the police so if they 我們必須確認她們可以在妓院安全的工作,讓警方知道她們的存在 have any problem they can go to the police. 讓當她們有困難的時候,她們可以尋求警方的協助 If they’ve been trafficked, they can say I’ve been brought into this country illegally, 如果不幸遭遇人口販賣這類犯罪活動,她們可以告訴警方她們是被不法人士帶進這個國家的 you know, I’m telling you now I need to be helped. 告訴警方她們迫切需要協助 And later on we can talk about what sex is, but right now, we can’t let another girl 等這些問題被解決之後,我們再來討論性工作合不合理 be murdered, be raped, be attacked, be scared, feel that she can’t go to the authorities 但目前我們不能再讓任何一個女性被謀殺、性侵犯、攻擊、恐嚇、讓她們感到無助且不敢求助於當局 because what she’s doing is stigmatized and not legal. 因為她認為她在做的事不合法,社會會給予異樣的眼光以及對待 But you feel very differently about porn and you feel differently about stripping. 雖然我對性工作的看法是如此,我對色情行業和脫衣舞俱樂部的感覺又是很不同的 Well how do you see those as different? 如何不一樣呢? Well, with pornography, you know, there’s a big thing that like kind of porn is bad 色情片的話,就是讓人覺得它對女性是不好的 for women. 色情片的話,就是讓人覺得它對女性是不好的 And if you look, you know if you’re a feminist you shouldn’t be into pornography. 如果我們認真想一下,女權主義者是不會支持色情片的 But pornography of itself is just watching some people have sex. 也許有人會說,色情片本身就是看一些人在進行性行為而已啊 And we see that in classical paintings, we see it on the side of vases, we see it in 我們在古典繪畫、花瓶甚至是三千年的卷軸 scrolls from 3,000 years ago. 都可以看到這些畫面 If you walk down the street and som\eone’s forgotten to draw their curtains, you can 當我們在街上行走的時候,如果有人忘記把窗簾拉上 see it through someone’s window, and I can tell you the people at Number 87, they have 我們就可以透過窗戶看到 87 號的人正在 got it going on right now! %%%%%%% And that’s not damaging to me to see that, that’s not damaging to a woman or a feminist 而以上說的這些對我來說都不會造成傷害,讓一個女性或女權主義者 to see some people having, you know, some consensual sex. 觀看一些人在進行性行為其實沒什麼大不了 What we’re talking about in pornography is the pornography industry and the ideas 重點是,我們現在討論的色情是一個龐大的色情工業 and aesthetic that it has. 這個行業、工業所代表的思維、美感 You know, if all you’re seeing, and there’s a kind of monoculture of pornography at the 而我們看到的這個色情行業所呈現的文化是非常單調的 moment, like 90% of the sex that you will see in pornography on the internet will be, 網路上大概 90% 的性愛都是同樣的 a man will come in, a woman will be sitting there, he’ll like go jigga-jigga-jigga on 首先是一個男的走進來,一個女的坐在那邊 her tits for 30 seconds, 男的開始搓揉女生的胸部,大概三十秒 and then—ok, jigga-jigga-jigga on the tits, then you’ll probably go squeak-squeak-squeak 接著,好的,jigga-jigga-jigga 胸部後 like 3 times in the general vagina area, and you’re feeling like kind of, you know what, 男的接下來在女生的會陰部 squeak-squeak-squeak,大概三次 if you found my clitoris, if it’s there, I’ll give you the money myself. 我和你打賭,如果你這樣就找到我的陰蒂,我直接把我的錢交給你 You are 3 and a half inches out, there’s no pleasure going on there, that’s not even happening 你大概還差了 3.5 寸吧,然後我完全沒有愉悅感 Then he’ll get on top of her and do her on top, then he’ll turn her over and do 接著男的就會開始男上女下的體位,結束後他就會把她轉過來 her from behind, then he’ll do some anal sex, and then he’ll spaff on her face. 開始從後面的體位,然後呢就會進行肛交,最後以顏射來結束這個章節 And job’s done in like 4 and a half minutes, which is the totally average time of a wank, 這些大概在四分鐘半就完成了,和男性自慰打手槍所耗費的時間差不多 a male wank. 就是和打手槍一樣 And you’re like, well, if that’s all I’m seeing, and that’s where children are getting 如果色情片就是這些,如果這些是我們的小孩的性教育來源 their sex education, that’s not sex. 這不是性愛、不是性教育 That’s pornography. 這就只是單純的色情片 And one very specific vision of what sex should be, one very specific—that doesn’t address 而且是一個非常特定、非常單一的對性的解讀 the multitudes of all the different things that we’d want to do. 它並沒有嘗試從不同的角度去剖析我們在性裡面想要多了解和嘗試的 And the key thing is, that if I’m watching some pornography, that’s just some sex. 關鍵在於,如果我現在看的只是一些色情片,它就只是單純的性愛而已 There’s no great scripts, we’re not going to see some incredible CGI, there’s no amazing 沒有豐富的劇情、沒有華麗的電腦畫面 monologues. 沒有精彩的獨白 It’s just some sex. 就只是性愛而已 And that’s two people having sex, and if one of them palpably isn’t enjoying it, 如果這兩個正在做愛的人,其中有一樣沒辦法好好享受 then that’s not great sex. 那更糟,這不是一個好的性愛 We’ve screwed up sex at that point. 我們居然把性愛搞砸到這種地步 I don’t see women having pleasure. 我完全看不到女性在這中間有任何的愉悅感 I sit there, going looking for women, you know, I’ve got a little list of times when 我在看這些片子的時候,我會收集一些女演員 I’ve seen women having a good time. 當我覺得她們做愛時樂在其中 It’s a very small list, they’re all saved in a special folder. 我就會把她們的名字做成一個名單,並收藏在一個特別的文件夾 What you see instead, because you want to see an emotional response from a woman, is 當我們嘗試在女演員的臉上找尋享受的表情 pain instead. 我們只能發現疼痛的表情 You know, slapping–I don’t know when slapping became a huge part of sex, but if I was a 我實在無法理解拍打女性的臀部在什麼時候變成性愛裡面的一個重點 13-year-old now, I would absolutely presume that in some way the sexual mechanics of either 如果我現在是十三歲,我一定會誤以為一些特定的生理性愛機制 lubrication or erection involved at some point having to slap someone repeatedly on the ass. 不論是潤滑或勃起,是可以通過不斷拍打一個人的臀部而產生的 You know, I come from an older age before we invented bum slapping, that just wasn’t a thing 我年紀比較大,我的年代不流行拍打臀部,可是這個舉動不應該成立 We all managed to have sex without repeatedly slapping each other. 我們那個年代的人都可以很順利的做愛,即使沒有重複拍打臀部 This is a fashion for sex, it’s a fashion in pornography. 這是一個在性愛的流行,是色情片所造成的流行 So, you know, I love people like Cindy Gallop, who does Make Love Not Porn, where you just 我喜歡想 Cindy Gallop 這類人,她拍了 Make Love Not Porn 這部電影 see consensual couples having sex. 在這部電影我們看的也是兩情相悅的人在做愛 It’s pornography, but it’s pornography that’s about pleasure, and about two people 它是色情片沒錯,不過它的性愛是愉悅的、是歡樂的 having sex, rather than a man coming to have sex on top of a woman, which is what we see 是兩個人一起享受性愛,而不是一個男的走進來對一個女的進行性愛 time and time again. 它不像是我們一直重複看到的所謂的色情片 I don’t see any women’s ideas in that, you know, she’s not going, Hang on, I’ve 在這種色情片,我沒辦法看到女性有任何想法,有任何生命,她不會說,等一等 got a good idea! 我有一個好主意! We could do it like this! 我們可以嘗試這樣做! She’s just lying there having sex on top of her. 她只是躺在那邊,讓別人對她進行性愛而已 And that’s not what sex is. 而這很顯然的並不是性愛的原貌 I’m 41 years old. 我現在已經四十一歲了 I’ve had sex 4 or 5 times now, and I can tell you generally not that bad. 我有過四到五次的性經驗,我可以告訴你,我覺得這幾次的經驗都不錯 4 or 5, huh? 四或五次,蛤? I know! 我就知道你會有這種反應! Wow. Wow I can tell you about it later. 我晚點再和你解釋這點 Big, big news. 真是一個天大的消息 Ha, ha, yeah! 哈哈,沒錯! I’m a big pumper. 這個我真的不會,和sex有關的? Okay, Jenny wants to know, what do you think is the biggest challenge facing the feminist 好的,Jenny 想要問你,你覺得在2016年女權主義者面臨最大的挑戰是? movement in 2016? 好的,Jenny 想要問你,你覺得在2016年女權主義者面臨最大的挑戰是? For people who really want to do something, book clubbers, beyond reading, what are some 對於那些真正想要做些什麼的人士、讀書會會員,除了閱讀以外 of the concrete things you think they can do, direct action that can be taken to fight 你覺得他們可以做些什麼比較實際的事、行動 for change. 去達到想要改變的目的 I think the biggest challenge is, again, it comes back down to tone. 我覺得最大的挑戰是,回到我們之前一再強調的,態度 Feminism has become such a big, hot potato, it's a hot newsworthy subject now in America and in the UK and in parts of Europe in a way that it wasn't 10 years ago. 女權主義已經變成一個夯、熱門的議題,不管是在美國英國或是歐洲的部分國家,女權運動的知名度和十年前完全無法相比。 You could not get arrested if you wanted to talk about feminism. 現在公開討論女權主義並不會讓你被銬上手銬 I went and pitched an idea of writing a column about funny feminism to a leading women’s 我曾經想要在一個知名的女性雜誌上用幽默的方式撰寫一個有關女權主義的專欄 magazine, and they went, We couldn’t write about feminism in a women’s magazine, which 我卻被拒絕了,他們告訴我,不能在女性雜誌上提倡女權主義 is why I went away and wrote How to Be a Woman. 這也是我決定寫 How to Be a Woman 這本書 Now, they are commissioning stuff every week, it’s a huge clickbait thing. 現在可不一樣了,這些雜誌每個禮拜都推出關於女權主義的內容,因為這些都可以刺激銷售量和廣告 People want to read about feminism. 現在的人想要了解女權主義 But many people have been put off feminism in the last couple of years because the tone 不過在前幾年,許多人因為女權主義這個話題被炒得有過頭,而對它產生反感 gets so heated. 不過在前幾年,許多人因為女權主義這個話題被炒得有過頭,而對它產生反感 You know, we’ve had feminism wars. 我們為女權主義開戰 First of all, people will argue and fight all the time, that’s absolutely fine. 一開始,人們都會互相吵來吵去,這是很正常的 We can’t go, Oh, two women have disagreed with each other, it’s a cat fight, that 我們不能說,哦你看這兩個女人不認同對方,看起來白痴一樣成何體統 proves women shouldn’t be able to speak in public, feminism is dead. 如果人們保持這種想法,導致女性無法在公共場合發言,女權主義就真的名存實亡了 It’s like, allow women the weakness to be able to argue and fight like men would. 我們應該像我們對待男性的不完美一樣去對待女性 True equality is not being perfect immediately, and being some superhero who has an amazing 真正的性別平等不是立刻變得完美,不是變成有完美職業、秀發、骨盆底、腰圍和兩個小孩的女英雄 job and incredible hair and a pelvic floor and a tiny little stomach and two children 真正的性別平等不是立刻變得完美,不是變成有完美職業、秀發、骨盆底、腰圍和兩個小孩的女英雄 who are perfectly well turned out. 甚至打扮的很好看 You know, that’s exhausting. 這太費力耗神了 True equality is being as dim, fat, deluded, nuts, smelly, scruffy, hopeful, joyful, and 真正的性別平等是一般般、胖、誤導的、發瘋的、有異味的、襤褸的、抱有希望的、開心的 idiotic as men. 愚蠢的,就像男性一樣 You know, it’s not being perfect, it’s just being treated as a human being. 重點是不是變成一個完人,重點是要像一個人一樣被對待 So, you know, we need to allow that women will have arguments. 所以,我們必須讓女性為她們的權利爭辯 But the key thing we need to do is just calm everything down a little bit. 不過關鍵在於,我們同時必須讓這些爭辯稍微緩和 It’s so important when these big debates that are about the future of half the population, 當這些有關於女性的未來的辯論開始在社群網站展開時,維持一個理性的討論是非常重要的 of womankind, start breaking out on social media, to just be calm. 當這些有關於女性的未來的辯論開始在社群網站展開時,維持一個理性的討論是非常重要的 You know, to just bring a bit of a certain sense of humor to it. 可以的話,同時也可以帶一些幽默感進去 To listen to it, you don’t need to make your mind up straight away, you don’t need 我們只需要聆聽內容就好,沒有必要馬上做任何決定 to have a hot take. 不需要那麼急 And very often, you know, I think the problem is that the medium is often the message. 很多時候,我覺得社群網站的媒介本身就會影響和代表所要傳達的訊息,而這是一個需要注意的問題 If you’re doing this stuff on Twitter, which is where the worst stuff happens, Twitter 我覺得 Twitter 是眾多社群網站中最容易引發不好的事的地方 works in such a way that every time someone writes something that you’re following, Twitter 的運作方式就是,當我們追踪的人傳達一些訊息的時候,這些訊息會直接出現在 you can’t not see it. 我們的眼前 It’s short, and it goes like a bullet into your brain, and it provokes a flight or fight response 雖然這些尋思都很短,但我們沒辦法忽略它,它就像子彈一樣穿入腦袋,引起驚慌失措、恐慌 If someone’s written something you disagree with, you flood with adrenaline, you’re 如果有人寫了讓我們無法認同的事,我們的腎上腺素立馬飆升 panicky, you’re angry, and you respond in fear and anger, and suddenly an argument’s 我們感到驚慌、憤怒、對此我們同時給予驚恐和憤怒的回應 happening with people who should be on the same side. 突然間原本應該站在同一條船的人就突然吵起來了 I’ve seen arguments break out between feminists who have the same life experiences, who want 我看過一些經歷過相同人生歷練的女權主義者之前爆發的口角 the same things to happen in society, who are disagreeing on the most tiny thing, and 她們對社會其實都有同樣的期待,只是對一些芝麻蒜皮的小事有意見而已 I would say Twitter is making them do that; social media is making them do that. 我覺得這是 Twitter 和社群網站把她們非理性的一面曝露出來 If they could just sit down in the pub, have a couple of Bacardis and put some Guns n’ 如果她們可以靜靜的坐在酒吧,來一點百加得酒 Roses on the jukebox, this would all be sorted in 5 minutes flat. 聽一聽搶與玫瑰的音樂,這些爭吵在五分鐘就可以好好地解決 So I mean, you know, but that’s another reason we need to get more women in tech. 不過這也是另一個我們必須讓女性多參與科技發展的原因 Because I think if women were inventing social media platforms, they would be completely different 假設今天是女性在發明這種社群網站平台,她們所發明的將會很不一樣 It would be much easier to break out and have relaxed conversations and talk about things 女性發明的應該能讓我們更容易敞開心扉、好好地、放鬆地談一談 at length. 女性發明的應該能讓我們更容易敞開心扉、好好地、放鬆地談一談 And you know, be able to inject some humor into it and let people know what emotions 女性可以為這些網站多注入一些幽默感,讓人們可以了解到 you’re having rather than these shouting statements. 除了這些在 Twitter 上看到的類似喊叫聲的字眼,社群網站可以有其他的情緒 It’s everyone waving a placard at the same time. 現在的社群網站就像每個人同時揮舞著手上的大字版 That’s not a conversation. 根本沒有溝通、會談可言 So we’ve seen all the placards, we know what all the issues are now. 我們現在看到這些大字版了,我們知道問題所在了 Now we need to move it somewhere where we have these conversations. 現在我們必須拿掉這些大字版,坐下來好好的談一談 So in terms of, that’s the bad stuff. 這是我們提到需要改進的地方 The good news is that there are places where you can have these conversations. 好消息是,現在確實有不錯的平台讓我們去進行這些會談 One of the most hopeful things that’s happened in this country in the last couple of years 其中近幾年最讓人感到欣慰的是 is the formation of the Women’s Equality Party. 婦女平等黨的成立 Because they have said, Okay! 當時她們說,好的! Let’s form a party that is just about women’s issues, and we’re gonna open source policy. 讓我們來組成一個針對探討女性議題的黨,而且我們會利用開源政策 So they don’t have an idea for what this party should be, other than, Let’s find 她們並不知道這個黨的功能與目的 out what women want. 她們純粹想要問問女性的想法、訴求 And they are now just consulting all up and down the country. 她們現在還在全國奔波、詢問女性同胞的意見 You can go now, and be a member of the Women’s Equality Party, attend these meetings, and 你現在就可以成為婦女平等黨的黨員,參加這些會議 talk about the problems in your life and the things that you think would solve it. 告訴大家你生活上的困境、和你想要解決的問題 And I don’t see any other political party doing that, and going, Women, come and tell 目前沒有其他的政黨在做這些事 us, let’s do this. 鼓勵女性表達意見的事 A party is being build from the ground up now that is inclusive of everybody, that has 現在這個黨是有社會各階層人士所組成的 stated it wants every kind of woman involved in that, whatever your class, whatever your 她們希望各種各樣的女性都可以參與,不管你的階級 age, whatever your ability, whatever your ethnicity, whatever your religion or your 年齡、能力、種族、宗教信仰 sexuality, go there and talk about being a woman and come up with some ideas. 或是性取向,只要你願意對於女性的議題發表意見,都隨時歡迎大家 I love a bit of direct action. 我超愛這種想幹嘛就幹嘛的衝勁 Yeah, no, direct action is super cool. 沒錯,這種衝勁真的是太酷了 If you do think that one of the things you want to do on earth is make the world a better place 如果你覺得你這一生想要做的其中一件事是要讓這個世界變得更美好 which is what being a feminist is, what being a decent person is, then you have 這剛好是一個女權主義者和一個好人會做的事 to make sure that you are aware of what you are subconsciously thinking about anybody 你就必須確保對於任何表達個人意見的人,你有辦法知道你的潛意識對他們所產生的想法和判斷 who speaks up. 你就必須確保對於任何表達個人意見的人,你有辦法知道你的潛意識對他們所產生的想法和判斷 Because I think we have this subconscious belief that someone can only speak up if they 因為我覺得人們會有一種潛意識的信念,我們會覺得說當一個人願意表達意見時 are perfect and have the answers to everything. 他的想法一定是正確的,而且可以解釋任何事 We are basically waiting for a Feminist Jesus to come along who’s going to write The Feminist 我們感覺就好像等待一個抱持女權主義的耶穌,等他寫一本女權聖經來打救大家 Bible that has everything in it, or who has written the Feminist TV Show that has everything 或者是一個可以製作出女權主義的電視節目的耶穌,這個節目可以解釋任何事 and everyone in it, or makes The Film that tells the story of everyone, and that is, 或是拍出一部 The Film 來告訴宇宙萬物真相 of course, impossible. 當然,這些都是不可能的 Because, again, you just say to yourself, are the men doing this? 因為,我們又會再次問自己,男性有在做這些事嗎? Are we expecting a man to come along and write a book that would provide the answers and 我們有去期待說一個男人出現了,然後他要寫一本書來解釋任何的問題 speak for 3.3 billion men? 並且為這世上三十三億的男性發聲嗎? And what we have to understand is that feminism, there’s never going to be a Feminist Jesus. 對於女權主義,我們必須了解的是,不可能會有一個女權主義耶穌 No one’s ever going to come along with all the answers. 沒有人會帶著全部的答案,告訴我們到底要怎麼做才是對的 If we’re waiting, if we’re not going to get behind someone until that comes along, 如果我們只是等待,如果我們不嘗試 then we will never do anything. 我們就沒辦法完成任何事 We have to understand that feminism is, instead, a patchwork quilt. 我們必須了解,女權主義就像拼布被子一樣 And what we all do, is we go, we all sew the little squares that we think we can sew with 我們能做的,就是利用這些小小的小方布 our abilities and our stories and our solutions, and then we join them all together. 利用我們的能力、我們的故事、處理問題的方式、把它們縫合起來 So you know, I will speak about my experiences and the things that I’ve observed and things 我會告訴你我的經驗、我觀察到的事 that I know, these are my squares here, and then you will talk about your things and your 和我知道的事,這些都是我的小方布,接下來你可以告訴我你的故事 powers and your skills, and we sew that next to there, and then you know, then you get 你的強項、你的能力,我們再把這些小方布都繡在一起,接著你可以發現大家的交流變多變廣了 someone who’s like, from the transgender movement, talking about their experiences, 跨性別運動的人開始分享他們的經驗 and they sew their thing, and you make sure it’s sewn to yours, you make sure you’re 他們在完成他們的目標的同時,我們也在確定可以吸收他們的經驗 all working together, you make sure that everybody’s squares are equal, but you make sure that 確保大家可以互相合作,確保每個小方布都是一樣的(大家都有貢獻) we’re working this together. 確保我們大家都在一起讓這個活動變好 Feminism is a collaborative effort, it’s not waiting for one Feminist Jesus to come along. 女權主義需要團隊合作,我們沒辦法等待耶穌的降臨 Yeah 沒錯 You talk about this in your book, how in Moranifesto specifically, how you know, Germaine Greer 你在你的書提到,尤其是 Moranifesto,Germaine Greer 這位作家為何是啟發你最大的 was one of your big inspirations, one of the first pieces of text that you read, and whatever 作家之一,為何是你早期一開始的閱讀對象 else, and that while you disagree with some of the comments that she made later on, you 雖然在她後期的一些評論讓你無法苟同 still appreciate the contributions that she’s made even though she can’t speak for you 你還是非常珍惜她的貢獻,儘管她沒辦法在每個議題幫你發聲、認同你 on every single specific topic. 你還是非常珍惜她的貢獻,儘管她沒辦法在每個議題幫你發聲、認同你 I absolutely, fundamentally disagree with Germaine Greer’s viewpoint on trans issues, 在 Germaine Greer 對於跨性別的議題的看法,我是完完全全無法認同的 and her belief of what a woman is. 我也不認同她對於女性為何物的看法 I come from the point of view that you are what you say you are, whether you’re saying 我覺得性別認同最直接的方式就是說出來 you’re a man or a woman or a gay space alien, because I was brought up on David Bowie. 不管你說你是男的、女的、同性戀,因為我是聽 David Bowie 長大的 I just believe what people tell me they feel they are. 事實上,我就會相信人們對他們自己的看法和感覺 But, to trash everything that Germaine Greer did, first of all misunderstands what you’re 可是,在我們完全推翻 Germaine Greer 所做的一切前,我們必須意識到也許我們忽略了什麼 standing on, as a woman, to have the power to be able—and the public platform, and 身為現代女性,我們變得更強大,我們有許多平台 the vocabulary, to speak out against Germaine Greer and call her a bad feminist, is to misunderstand 可以大聲說出對 Germaine Greer 的看法,說她是一個失敗的女權主義者 that she has given you half those words and that platform and that ability to do that. 是因為我們沒辦法體悟到,正是因為她的努力,才讓我們現在有這個機會和平台自由地表達意見 You know, we are all standing on the shoulders of our aunts. 其實我們都是站在之前的女權鬥士們的肩膀上 And, particularly, it happens in sort of every political movement and movement for sexual change 這類有點忘恩負義的現象其實屢見不鮮,尤其是涉及到政治或是性別運動 but it’s particularly noticeable these days because so much of our talk about 但現在我們特別容易發現這點,因為大家都利用社群網站來討論 these things happens on social media, that we don’t bring our elders with us. 我們不會提及前輩們的貢獻 We’re not taking into account what other previous generations did, because they’re 我們不會理會上一輩的人在我們之前做了什麼 not on social media. 因為他們不活躍於社群網站 They’re not part of the conversation. 他們不在我們的會談、對話中 We’d like to think, well we’ve moved on from that, we just, you know, these people 我們會覺得,我們已經向前邁進很多步了 are outdated, we do things a different way now. 我們做事的方式和這些過時的老傢伙不一樣 And you need to have your tribal elders. 其實我們需要這些前輩 You need to have the old people sitting around, because we’re going to have to fight a lot 我們需要他們,所謂家有一老 of battles in order to change things. 如有一寶 And these people have fought these battles before. 他們也打過類似的戰爭 They know the right language to use, they know how you can change legislation, they 他們知道恰當的措辭、他們在立法上比較有經驗 know the kind of alliances that you need to make, they’ve gone through these different tatics before 他們知道哪些人是我們的夥伴,他們也都是用過各種各樣的戰術、手段 You need people who’ve been in wars. 我們需要有實戰經驗的人幫助我們打這場仗 And yeah, some of the stuff they say will be highly objectionable, but to lose this 當然,他們說的話也不是全對 massive well of wisdom and resource means that we are never going to progress past a certain point 但失去他們我們將無法向前邁進 We make ourselves weak. 這讓我們變得脆弱 You know, have the strength to be able to say, yeah, my heroes are flawed 我們必須要勇於承認,我們尊敬的人也是會犯錯的 in the same way that I am flawed, in the same way that all of us are flawed. 就像我們會承認自己不是完美的,大家都不是完美的一樣 Again, if we’re waiting for a perfect Feminist Jesus to come along, who’s never made a 如果我們還是在等待一個完美的女性主權耶穌的降臨 single mistake, we will have no one. 我們會等不到這個人 We will continue to be disadvantaged. 我們會繼續處於劣勢 While the men, who are like, I’m not perfect at all! 與此同時,男性則會直接承認自己不是完美的 I’m Jeremy Clarkson! 我是 Jeremy Clarkson! I’m simply going to carry on making racist comments and driving my car where I want, 我會繼續為所欲為 and because I’ve said I don’t want to make the world a better place, I’m just 因為我本來就沒有要讓這個世界變得更好、沒有什麼雄心壯志 allowed to get away with it! 我只是想要這樣過日子 Whereas if you are a person who says I’m trying to be a good person, and you make one mistake 但如果你勵志想要當好人,當你犯了一點小錯 then that seems unforgiveable. 就會顯得你罪該萬死 You know, some days I wish I was Jeremy Clarkson. 有時候我會希望我就只是 Jeremy Clarkson I would just get up, say 10 absolutely untenable, horrendous things before breakfast, and because 我每天起床後,可以說十個毫無根據、糟糕的事,再吃早餐 he’s essentially saying, [...] no returns, you know, nothing happens. 因為到最後他可以隨便說一些事來敷衍過去
B1 中級 中文 英國腔 女性 女權 主義 色情片 政治 男性 艾瑪華森的女權讀書小組 (Emma Watson & Caitlin Moran - In Conversation for Our Shared Shelf) 6679 464 smilehumanbeing 發佈於 2016 年 08 月 30 日 更多分享 分享 收藏 回報 影片單字