Name: 巴基斯坦和印度達成停火協議，哪個國家損失更大？印度損失 830 億美元 (Pakistan & India Agree to a Ceasefire I which Country Suffered more losses? India lost $83 billion)
Uploaded: 2025-05-12T00:31:10.000Z
Duration: 8 min 17 s

程度副詞

出現了一個非常積極的事態發展。

A ceasefire has been agreed upon between Pakistan and India.

巴基斯坦和印度已經達成停火協議。

情態副詞

US President Donald Trump announced on social media that both nuclear-armed nations have immediately agreed to a ceasefire, which is indeed great news.

美國總統唐納德-特朗普在社交媒體上宣佈，兩個有核國家已立即同意停火，這確實是個好消息。

Now let's examine which country suffered more losses, what each side gained, how much false propaganda was spread, and what lessons can be learned from this situation.

現在，讓我們來看看哪個國家遭受了更大的損失，雙方都獲得了什麼，虛假宣傳傳播了多少，以及從這種情況中可以吸取什麼教訓。

India conducted missile strikes on nine targets in Pakistan on May 7, 2025, under Operation Sindor.

2025 年 5 月 7 日，印度在 "辛多爾行動 "中對巴基斯坦境內的九個目標實施了飛彈襲擊。

These strikes were in response to a terrorist attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir on April 22, 2025, which resulted in the deaths of 31 civilians.

這些襲擊是對 2025 年 4 月 22 日查謨和克什米爾帕哈勒甘發生的恐怖襲擊的迴應，襲擊造成 31 名平民死亡。

India described the strikes as focused, measured, and non-escalatory, emphasizing that the targets were terrorist infrastructure, not Pakistani military bases.

印度稱這些打擊是有重點、有分寸和非升級性的，並強調打擊目標是恐怖分子的基礎設施，而不是巴基斯坦的軍事基地。

However, one of the most controversial claims is that India attacked mosques in Pakistan, alleging that Jaish-e-Mohammed terrorists were being trained there.

然而，最有爭議的說法之一是，印度襲擊了巴基斯坦的清真寺，聲稱 "聖戰者 "組織恐怖分子正在那裡接受訓練。

But no credible evidence has been presented to support this claim.

但沒有任何可信的證據支持這一說法。

The sudden attacks, carried out at 1am across nine different points, caused widespread panic and fear throughout Pakistan.

凌晨 1 點在 9 個不同地點發動的突然襲擊在巴基斯坦全國造成了廣泛的恐慌和恐懼。

As a result, the initial losses were primarily on Pakistan's side.

是以，最初的損失主要在巴基斯坦一方。

During these strikes, India reportedly used Rafale jets armed with Scalp cruise missiles and Hammer air-to-ground precision-guided bombs.

據報道，在這些襲擊中，印度使用了裝備有 "頭皮 "巡航導彈和 "錘 "式空對地精確制導炸彈的陣風戰鬥機。

At the same time, Pakistan scrambled its air force to respond swiftly.

與此同時，巴基斯坦空軍也迅速做出反應。

It is reported that this became the largest air battle in modern South Asian military history, with over 80 Indian Air Force fighter jets involved and approximately 40 Pakistani Air Force jets deployed in response.

據報道，這成為現代南亞軍事史上規模最大的空戰，印度空軍有 80 多架戰鬥機參戰，巴基斯坦空軍也出動了約 40 架戰鬥機進行反擊。

While India was carrying out strikes on these nine targets, the Pakistan Air Force and air defense systems were actively trying to intercept and repel the attacks.

在印度對這九個目標實施打擊的同時，巴基斯坦空軍和防空系統正積極試圖攔截和擊退這些襲擊。

However, India ultimately managed to hit all nine intended targets.

然而，印度最終還是成功地擊中了所有九個預定目標。

During this confrontation, both air forces remained within their own airspace and did not cross each other's borders.

在這次對峙中，雙方空軍都留在自己的領空內，沒有越過對方的邊界。

Amid the conflict, a major development occurred.

在衝突中，出現了一項重大進展。

Pakistan claims to have shot down five Indian fighter jets, including three Rafales, one Su-30, and one MiG-29.

巴基斯坦聲稱擊落了五架印度戰鬥機，包括三架陣風、一架蘇-30 和一架米格-29。

However, based on the evidence and sources I have gathered, it appears that four aircraft were confirmed to be downed, three in Jammu and Kashmir and one in Batinda, Indian Punjab.

不過，根據我收集到的證據和消息來源，似乎已確認有四架飛機被擊落，其中三架在查謨和克什米爾，一架在印度旁遮普省的巴廷達。

This has been independently confirmed, and there is solid evidence supporting these claims.

這一點已得到獨立證實，並且有確鑿證據支持這些說法。

Moreover, the shooting down of Rafale jets was acknowledged by France, and U.S. officials have also confirmed that the Indian Air Force suffered losses.

此外，法國承認擊落了陣風戰鬥機，美國官員也證實印度空軍遭受了損失。

According to the New York Times, India faced significant damage to its air assets.

據《紐約時報》報道，印度的航空資產面臨重大損失。

However, there is still no official update on the fate of the pilots from the four or five downed Indian jets.

然而，關於四、五架被擊落的印度戰機飛行員的命運，官方仍未給出最新消息。

In terms of human loss, Pakistan suffered more, with 31 civilians killed.

就人員損失而言，巴基斯坦遭受的損失更大，有 31 名平民喪生。

However, in terms of military equipment, India took a heavier hit, losing four to five fighter jets that were reportedly shot down by Pakistan.

然而，在軍事裝備方面，印度受到的打擊更大，據說損失了四到五架被巴基斯坦擊落的戰鬥機。

Following the airstrikes, some skirmishes were reported along the line of control, with reports of Indian civilian and military casualties.

空襲之後，據報控制線沿線發生了一些小規模衝突，並有印度平民和軍人傷亡的報道。

These were the main confirmed developments during the conflict.

這些都是衝突期間得到證實的主要事態發展。

Pakistan maintained that its response so far was only defensive.

巴基斯坦堅稱其迄今為止的反應只是防禦性的。

It shot down Indian fighter jets in self-defense.

它出於自衛擊落了印度戰鬥機。

But the Pakistani military stated that its actual retaliatory strike against Operation Sindor was still pending.

但巴基斯坦軍方表示，其對 "辛多行動 "的實際報復性打擊仍有待進行。

Now coming to fake news and propaganda, there was a significant amount from both sides.

現在來談談假新聞和宣傳，雙方都有大量的假新聞和宣傳。

On May 8, India launched a wave of drones, mostly Israeli Harop-loitering munitions, approximately 70 in total.

5 月 8 日，印度發射了一波無人機，其中大部分是以色列 Harop 發射的彈藥，共約 70 架。

Most of them were reportedly intercepted by Pakistani defenses, though one drone injured two Pakistani military personnel.

據報道，大部分無人機被巴基斯坦防禦系統攔截，但有一架無人機炸傷了兩名巴基斯坦軍人。

Initially, India denied the attack, but later claimed that it destroyed a Pakistani HQ-9B air defense system using these drones.

起初，印度否認了這次襲擊，但後來又聲稱它使用這些無人機摧毀了巴基斯坦的 HQ-9B 防空系統。

However, no evidence has emerged to support this claim, no images, no verified videos.

然而，沒有任何證據支持這一說法，沒有圖片，也沒有經過核實的視頻。

It's important to note that Harop drones are equipped with high-resolution cameras, and any successful strike would typically be recorded and widely circulated as proof.

值得注意的是，Harop 無人機配備了高分辨率攝像頭，任何成功的襲擊通常都會被記錄下來，並作為證據廣泛傳播。

Since no such footage has appeared, it strongly suggests that this claim was false and likely propaganda.

由於沒有出現這樣的錄像，這強烈表明這一說法是錯誤的，很可能是宣傳。

Another fake news story emerged, claiming that India had shot down a Pakistani F-16 and captured the pilot.

又出現了一則假新聞，聲稱印度擊落了一架巴基斯坦 F-16 戰鬥機，並俘虜了飛行員。

But ask yourself, has anyone seen an image or video of the supposed Pakistani pilot?

但捫心自問，有人看到過所謂巴基斯坦飛行員的影像或視頻嗎？

Because under Pakistan's agreement with the United States, F-16s cannot be operated outside the country without permission.

因為根據巴基斯坦與美國的協議，F-16 戰鬥機未經許可不得在境外運行。

Following that, even more exaggerated and fake reports surfaced.

隨後，更多誇大和虛假的報道浮出水面。

At one point, it seemed as if Pakistan had completely taken over India.

巴基斯坦一度似乎完全佔領了印度。

While on the other hand, Indian media was showing footage claiming that INS Vikrant had attacked Karachi, and the city had been destroyed.

而另一方面，印度媒體卻播放錄像，聲稱 "維克蘭特 "號驅逐艦襲擊了卡拉奇，城市被摧毀。

But remember, both sides were spreading propaganda, and these stories were entirely false.

但請記住，雙方都在進行宣傳，這些故事完全是虛假的。

Then, on May 10th at 5.15am, Pakistan launched its retaliatory strike, Operation Bunyanun Marsus.

隨後，巴基斯坦於 5 月 10 日凌晨 5 時 15 分發動了報復性打擊，即 "布尼亞農-馬蘇斯行動"。

During this operation, Pakistan used the Fatah-1 MLRS to strike limited Indian military infrastructure, though most of the attacks were intercepted by Indian defenses.

在這次行動中，巴基斯坦使用法塔赫-1 多管火箭炮襲擊了印度有限的軍事基礎設施，儘管大多數襲擊都被印度防禦系統攔截。

Amid this, a new claim surfaced that Pakistan had destroyed an BrahMos missile storage facility, and that a JF-17 Thunder had destroyed India's state-of-the-art S-400 air defense system using air-launched hypersonic missiles.

在此情況下，又出現了一種新的說法，稱巴基斯坦摧毀了一個布拉莫斯飛彈儲存設施，一架JF-17 "雷霆 "戰鬥機使用空射高超音速飛彈摧毀了印度最先進的S-400防空系統。

However, no images or visual proof of this destruction was released, so this too was likely another fake or exaggerated claim.

然而，並沒有公佈這一破壞的圖片或直觀證據，是以這也很可能是另一個虛假或誇大的說法。

When I watched Indian media, it felt like Pakistan had been completely destroyed.

當我看印度媒體時，感覺巴基斯坦已經被徹底摧毀了。

When I looked at Pakistani social media, it looked like India had been wiped out.

我在巴基斯坦的社交媒體上看到，印度好像被消滅了。

但實際上，這一切都沒有發生。

For a moment, it really felt like the conflict might escalate into a full-fledged war.

有那麼一瞬間，人們真的覺得衝突可能會升級為一場全面戰爭。

But as always, the United States stepped in and brokered peace, and the drama ended with a ceasefire.

但美國一如既往地介入並促成了和平，這場鬧劇最終以停火告終。

In reality, it might seem like this war was only between India and Pakistan, but in truth, it was more of a battle between Western and Chinese technology.

實際上，這場戰爭似乎只是印度和巴基斯坦之間的戰爭，但事實上，它更像是西方和中國技術之間的較量。

The main equipment used on both sides included French-made Rafale fighter jets, and on the other side, Chinese-made J-10C fighter jets.

雙方使用的主要裝備包括法國製造的陣風戰鬥機和中國製造的殲-10C 戰鬥機。

On paper, it was always claimed that the Rafale, a twin-engine jet equipped with advanced spectra electronic warfare systems, was vastly superior.

從紙面上看，"陣風 "一直被認為是一種配備了先進光譜電子戰系統的雙引擎噴氣式飛機，具有巨大的優勢。

In contrast, the J-10C, a single-engine jet, was considered less advanced because it was Chinese-made.

相比之下，單發噴氣式飛機殲-10C 因為是中國製造而被認為不夠先進。

However, in the wake of these India-Pakistan clashes, the J-10C has significant recognition.

然而，在這些印巴衝突之後，J-10C 得到了極大的認可。

The world is now more likely to shift interest towards Chinese weapons systems.

現在，世界更有可能將興趣轉向中國的武器系統。

Even U.S. officials have acknowledged that Chinese technology is beginning to surpass Western technology in certain aspects.

就連美國官員也承認，中國技術在某些方面已經開始超越西方技術。

As a result of these developments, the stock value of Dassault Aviation, the company that manufactures Rafale, reportedly dropped by 8 percent, while Chengdu Aircraft Corporation, the maker of the J-10C, saw a 19 percent increase in its share value.

據報道，由於這些事態發展，生產陣風戰鬥機的達索航空公司的股票價值下跌了 8%，而生產殲-10C 戰鬥機的成都飛機工業集團公司的股票價值則上漲了 19%。

So, in this conflict, India, Pakistan, and France suffered losses, while China gained in terms of influence and recognition.

是以，在這場衝突中，印度、巴基斯坦和法國蒙受了損失，而中國則獲得了影響力和認可度。

Everything else you may have heard was mostly fake news and propaganda.

你可能聽到的其他消息大多是假新聞和宣傳。

Civilians from both Pakistan and India died in this conflict, and that is truly tragic.

巴基斯坦和印度的平民都在這場衝突中喪生，這確實是一個悲劇。

In the end, I want to share a few timeless lessons from the art of war by Sun Tzu.

最後，我想從孫子兵法中分享一些永恆的經驗。

Wisdom that still holds true even in today's high-tech world.

即使在當今的高科技世界，這些智慧依然適用。

Build your opponent a golden bridge to retreat across.

為你的對手建造一座金橋，讓他們從橋上撤退。

This reminds us that giving the enemy a dignified way out can prevent unnecessary destruction.

這提醒我們，給敵人一條體面的出路，可以避免不必要的破壞。

The greatest victory is that which requires no battle.

無需戰鬥的勝利才是最大的勝利。

Avoiding war while still achieving your objectives is the most honorable and intelligent path.

既要避免戰爭，又要實現目標，這才是最光榮、最明智的道路。

The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting.

戰爭的最高藝術就是不戰而屈人之兵。

True strength lies not in violence, but in strategy, diplomacy, and restraint.

真正的力量不在於暴力，而在於戰略、外交和剋制。