Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • The United States, picks its president with the Electoral College, 538 votes distributed

  • by population (mostly) to the 50 States and DC. To become president you need to win a

  • majority of those votes. But, 538 is an even number, so what happens when the race for

  • president is tied?

  • Don't worry, there's an 18th century solution to the problem: if the Electoral College is

  • tied, the House of Representatives breaks that tie.

  • As the name implies, the House is filled with representatives from each of the states. The

  • more people in a state, the more Representatives it has and their are 435 in total -- thankfully

  • an odd number and guaranteed tie breaker... except there's a catch: each representative

  • doesn't get one vote, it's each *State* that gets one vote. So, Florida's 27 representatives

  • have to decided amongst themselves who to support before casting Florida's one vote

  • to help break the tie.

  • Meanwhile, thinly-populated Alaska's sole representative, has only to consult himself

  • before casting Alaska's vote.

  • This is an incredibly disproportionate system because just ten states, California, Texas,

  • New York, Florida, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan, Georgia, and North Carolina

  • contain more than half the population of the United States but get only 20% of the votes

  • if the race for president is tied and the other 40 states with less than half the population

  • get 80% of the votes.

  • While an exact tie is unlikely, this system is also used if they're more than two candidates

  • for president and none of them gets a majority in the Electoral College.

  • Which is exactly what happened when four candidates ran for president in 1824. Andrew Jackson

  • got the most votes from Americans and the most votes in the Electoral College, but not

  • a majority, so the race was turned over to the House of Representatives voting as states

  • who picked John Quiny Adams instead.

  • In a modern America with more states a three-way race can have horrifically disproportionate

  • results: consider a third-party candidate who the loves the small states and who the

  • small states love in return.

  • He gets the fewest Electoral College votes, but enough to ensure that neither of the two

  • more popular candidates get a majority so now the House decides the winner -- and those

  • 26 smallest states representing just 17% of the population can pick their man as president

  • even though 83% of Americans didn't vote for him.

  • It's unlikely, but it really shouldn't even be possible.

  • Anyway, all this talk of presidents has left the Vice President unmentioned: a reasonable

  • person might assume, just comes along with the President, but no.

  • When there's a tie the *Senate* independently picks the Vice President so the United States,

  • could end up with a President from one party and with a Vice President from the another,

  • which might make for some very uncomfortable meetings.

  • But even this crazy system for resolving a tie isn't guaranteed to work because are 100

  • members of the senate and in the House of Representatives they're forced to vote as

  • 50 states and many of those states have10 or 8 representatives making the whole system

  • tie-tackular with all of those even numbers.

  • So if the House can't pick the president but the Senate has picked the Vice President then

  • the Vice President becomes acting president until the House can make up its mind. But

  • if neither the House can pick the president nor the Senate can decide the Vice President

  • then the speaker of the House becomes president until either branch of congress picks *someone*.

  • So this systems is how the United States would resolve a tied race for president, though

  • it might be faster (and more fair) to just flip a coin.

  • Of course you could just get rid of the electoral college, and thus this whole crazy system,

  • and instead have a national vote, perhaps even with something fancy like preferential

  • voting, maybe that's just a crazy idea.

The United States, picks its president with the Electoral College, 538 votes distributed

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級

如果選舉團平局怎麼辦? (What If the Electoral College is Tied?)

  • 136 4
    Simon 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日
影片單字