So last time we talked about the Chris Tyson situation where MrBeast's childhood friend Chris was exposed for talking to minors in very weird ways and being a PDF file.

上次我們談到了克里斯-泰森（Chris Tyson）的情況，怪獸先生（MrBeast）的童年好友克里斯（Chris）被曝以非常怪異的方式與未成年人交談，並且是一個 PDF 文件。

But it turns out Jimmy also has plenty of skeletons in his closet.

但事實證明，吉米的衣櫥裡也有很多骷髏。

A recent video by Dogpack404 has gone viral titled,

最近，一段由 Dogpack404 製作的視頻在網絡上瘋傳，視頻的標題是："你知道嗎？

I worked for MrBeast and he's a fraud, with some serious allegations made towards MrBeast.

我為野獸先生工作過，他是個金光黨，對野獸先生提出了一些嚴重的指控。

Some of them include faking his videos, promoting gambling to children, conducting illegal lotteries, rigging games and videos which involve millions of dollars in prize money, which is also a crime, not giving out the prizes that he promises, false advertising, exploitation, and a whole lot of stuff, right?

其中包括偽造視頻、向兒童宣傳賭博、進行非法彩票、操縱涉及數百萬美元獎金的遊戲和視頻（這也是一種犯罪）、不發放他承諾的獎金、虛假廣告、剝削，以及一大堆東西，對嗎？

And the thing is, this video did not even show up in the YouTube search bar for several days despite having 200k views, which is seriously suspicious and very much looks like a shadow ban.

問題是，儘管該視頻有 20 萬次觀看，但在 YouTube 的搜索欄中有好幾天都沒有顯示出來，這一點非常可疑，很像是影子禁令。

So let's get into this video, break this down, starting with the allegation that MrBeast is faking videos.

讓我們來分析一下這段視頻，首先是關於 "野獸先生 "偽造視頻的指控。

This guy is fake, this raccoon is a paid actor, this island costs more than a dollar, this city is not abandoned, these buildings are CGI, but it's not your only way out, you can literally get an Uber to the airport for $20.

這個人是假的，這隻浣熊是花錢僱來的演員，這個島的價格超過一美元，這個城市不是廢棄的，這些建築是 CGI 製作的，但這不是你唯一的出路，你真的可以花 20 美元打 Uber 到機場。

That's not a lurker, it's just a guy.

那不是潛伏者，只是一個人。

This whole room is fake, this contestant is an actor and a secret employee at MrBeast, they had him dive through this fake door twice, this line is scripted, this action is scripted, in fact, pretty much all the videos with Mac are scripted.

整個房間都是假的，這個參賽者是一個演員，也是 MrBeast 的祕密僱員，他們讓他從這個假門跳了兩次，這句臺詞是編好的，這個動作是編好的，事實上，幾乎所有 Mac 的視頻都是編好的。

What we did was scripted, holy shit, this stuff would be easy to pump out.

我們所做的都是腳本，我的天，這些東西很容易就能寫出來。

Okay, so that was a really quick montage of stuff that MrBeast has faked, and I think it's pretty obvious to most adults watching that MrBeast is faking his videos, and he clearly lies about it, because every video has those incredibly high stakes all up into the end, and obviously, MrBeast spends millions of dollars on his videos, so he's not going to pick somebody who like quits in two minutes, or he's not going to make the challenge end in two minutes, he's purposely going to manipulate the events, manipulate the contestants, so that they're not going to quit halfway, and it's going to be neck and neck all the way up till the end for that retention.

好了，這是一個非常快速的蒙太奇，怪獸先生偽造的東西，我認為這是非常明顯的，大多數成年人看怪獸先生是在偽造他的視頻，他顯然是在撒謊，因為每一個視頻都有那些令人難以置信的高風險，所有到最後，很明顯，怪獸先生花了數百萬美元在他的視頻上，所以他不會選擇一個人誰喜歡在兩分鐘內退出，或者他不會讓挑戰在兩分鐘內結束，他故意去操縱事件，操縱選手、所以他不會挑選兩分鐘內就退出的人，也不會讓挑戰在兩分鐘內結束，他會故意操縱事件，操縱參賽者，這樣他們就不會半途而廢，就會一直並駕齊驅，直到最後的留存。

Now, the most damning allegation here has to be this guy called Mac, right?

現在，最令人震驚的指控一定是這個叫麥克的傢伙，對嗎？

So Mac was made out to be this random person that is trying so hard to win these challenges, and everyone is emotionally invested in his success.

是以，麥克被塑造成了一個為了贏得這些挑戰而拼命努力的人，每個人都對他的成功投入了感情。

Well, it turns out, in reality, he's just a MrBeast employee living in a mansion, and he purposely stalls out the videos to make it intense.

原來，在現實中，他只是住在豪宅裡的一名 MrBeast 僱員，他故意拖長視頻的時間，讓視頻變得緊張刺激。

Let's talk about Mac for a second.

讓我們先談談 Mac。

We will die, you understand that?

我們會死，你明白嗎？

I found public records showing that Mac moved from California to Greenville,

我找到了公共記錄，顯示麥克從加利福尼亞搬到了格林維爾、

North Carolina, where Jimmy is located, back in August 2023, two months before he appeared as a contestant.

早在 2023 年 8 月，吉米所在的北卡羅來納州，也就是他作為參賽選手出現的兩個月前。

According to a former MrBeast employee, this is around the time when Mac started working full-time on the editing team at MrBeast.

據一位前 MrBeast 員工稱，這大約是 Mac 開始全職在 MrBeast 編輯團隊工作的時間。

Also, he didn't just move into any old house, he moved into a million-dollar mansion.

而且，他搬進的不是普通的老房子，而是價值百萬美元的豪宅。

His 6,000 square foot million-dollar mansion comes with a movie theater and seven bathrooms.

他的豪宅佔地 6000 平方英尺，價值百萬美元，配有一個電影院和七個浴室。

What are you going to spend the $800,000 on?

你打算把這 80 萬美元花在什麼地方？

I mean, my life's changed now.

我是說，我的生活已經改變了。

Yeah, I'm sure that $800,000 is really going to change your life.

是啊，我相信那 80 萬美元真的會改變你的生活。

Mac, this is a nice car.

麥克，這是輛好車。

Tell me, where are we right now?

告訴我，我們現在在哪裡？

Uh, we're in the place that, uh, we drove to a few minutes ago.

我們在幾分鐘前開車去的地方

Mac, let's, let's cut the shit here.

麥克，別廢話了

What have you been doing for like the last year?

去年你都在做什麼？

A lot of family stuff.

很多家庭瑣事

What kind of family stuff?

什麼樣的家庭瑣事？

Just like, uh, you know, playing catch with my dad, you know?

就像，呃，你知道，和我爸爸玩接球遊戲，你知道嗎？

For a year?

一年？

What are you, how do you make money?

你是什麼人，怎麼賺錢？

Okay, so this is pretty much confirmed that Mac is an employee, meaning if he wins or loses a challenge is pre-planned out by MrBeast, and MrBeast is artificially introducing these stakes in the video, and you might be saying, oh, well, he's doing it for entertainment to entertain the viewer.

好了，這基本可以確定 Mac 是一名僱員，也就是說，他在挑戰中的輸贏是由 MrBeast 事先計劃好的，MrBeast 在視頻中人為地引入了這些賭注，你可能會說，哦，好吧，他這樣做是為了娛樂觀眾。

Who actually cares?

誰會真正關心呢？

Well, then you shouldn't be saying that your videos aren't fake because you're lying to your audience.

那麼，你就不應該說你的視頻不是假的，因為你在欺騙觀眾。

And this leads to several other ethical issues because when you introduce contestants that you aren't paying, right, and you get together sort of random people or YouTubers who are not part of your bullshit pre-decided scheme, then they are actually getting tricked because they're going into these challenges thinking they can actually win a million dollars, but they can't because you're controlling everything behind the scenes and the odds are not fair and are heavily stacked in the favor of one of your friends or one of your employees and shit like that.

這還會引發其他一些道德問題，因為當你介紹參賽者時，你並沒有付錢給他們，對吧，你把那些不屬於你事先決定的狗屁計劃的隨機人或優酷用戶召集在一起，那麼他們實際上就被騙了，因為他們在參加這些挑戰時，以為自己真的能贏得一百萬美元，但他們贏不了，因為你在幕後控制著一切，而且賠率並不公平，嚴重偏向於你的某個朋友或你的某個員工，諸如此類。

And yeah, that's obviously messed up.

是的，這顯然是一團糟。

Now, Dogpack goes on to show MrBeast even fakes his own challenges, like, you know, being stranded at sea.

現在，"狗包包 "還告訴我們，"野獸先生 "甚至會偽造自己面臨的挑戰，比如，你知道的，被困在海上。

During this time-lapse on the fourth day of seven days stranded at sea, you can clearly see there's no one in the shelter.

在海上滯留七天後的第四天，您可以清楚地看到避難所裡一個人也沒有。

These are their empty beds.

這些是他們的空床。

But after a hard cut, magically five people are awake and two of the boys have bright yellow raincoats that they didn't have when it rained on day two.

但是，在狠狠地砍了一刀之後，神奇的是，五個人都醒了，其中兩個男孩還穿上了亮黃色的雨衣，而在第二天下雨的時候，他們還沒有這件雨衣。

And after standing the whole night completely soaked...

站了整整一夜，全身都溼透了...

You didn't spend the night soaked, Jimmy.

你沒有整晚都泡在水裡 吉米

You slept on the production yacht.

你睡在製作遊艇上

It's ironic because this is one of the videos where they claim that they don't fake things.

具有諷刺意味的是，這正是他們聲稱不會造假的視頻之一。

But no, we have to be the real channel that doesn't fake things.

但是不行，我們必須做一個不造假的真實頻道。

In this video, this wink was added in post.

在這段視頻中，這個眨眼是後期添加的。

In fact, 58 was actually on the far opposite side of the room from 42 and he just didn't hear him.

事實上，58 號當時就在 42 號房間的另一側，只是他沒有聽到而已。

This whole revenge storyline was added in post.

整個復仇故事情節都是後期添加的。

Multiple shots show how timers are edited in post.

多張照片展示瞭如何在後期編輯計時器。

Timers are edited in post.

定時器在帖子中編輯。

Timers are edited in post.

定時器在帖子中編輯。

They also manipulated contestants audio in post.

他們還在後期篡改了參賽者的音頻。

So we got 15 minutes.

所以我們有 15 分鐘。

In general, if anything happens last second, it's fake.

一般來說，如果最後一秒發生了什麼，那就是假的。

Or if you can hear someone's voice but can't see their mouth, the audio could easily be added in post.

或者，如果您能聽到某人的聲音，但看不到他的嘴，也可以很容易地在後期添加音頻。

I literally think I'm gonna kill...

我真的覺得我會殺了...

Okay, so this is pretty good evidence that he's found.

好吧，這就是他被發現的有力證據。

And honestly, I'm okay with the CGI and stuff.

老實說，我對 CGI 之類的東西沒意見。

I understand you need that for visuals.

我知道你需要這樣的視覺效果。

But making people say things that they didn't say, that is just completely fake.

但讓人們說一些他們沒有說過的話，那就完全是假的了。

And, you know, editing timers and stuff.

還有，你知道的，編輯計時器什麼的。

I mean, you can do that or whatever if it's a TV show and stuff.

我的意思是，如果是電視節目之類的，你可以這麼做。

But don't say it's real then.

但不要說這是真的。

And faking your own challenges is obviously just pathetic.

而偽造自己的挑戰顯然是可悲的。

Because, you know, when MrBeast would supposedly spend 24 hours or 72 hours buried underground or whatever,

因為，你知道，據說怪獸先生會花24小時或72小時埋在地下什麼的、

I had a little hope in my heart that, okay, at least those are real, right?

我心裡還抱有一絲希望，好吧，至少這些都是真的，對嗎？

And MrBeast was so insistent that they were all real.

而野獸先生卻堅持說它們都是真的。

But I remember in the back of my head, I was like, oh, MrBeast is such a busy person, such a CEO, hyper-optimizing everything, and he's gonna spend three days buried underground or some stupid shit?

但我記得在我的腦海裡，我當時想，哦，怪獸先生是個大忙人，是個首席執行官，對一切都極度優化，他要花三天時間埋在地下還是什麼蠢事？

So, obviously, I was right there and these challenges aren't real.

所以，很明顯，我就在那裡，這些挑戰並不真實。

He's probably just, you know, filming that part, instantly getting out, chilling outside or whatever.

他可能只是，你知道的，在拍那一段，然後就出去了，在外面閒逛什麼的。

But I'm surprised that everybody has gone on with it.

但我感到驚訝的是，每個人都堅持了下來。

Like, all these friends and all these employees, not one person had a peep out of them.

比如，所有這些朋友和員工，沒有一個人對他們說過一句話。

Maybe he's making them sign NDAs or whatever.

也許他讓他們簽了保密協議什麼的。

But I'm surprised it actually took this long.

但我很驚訝居然花了這麼長時間。

And I knew he'd be exposed by somebody close to him, like a former employee.

我知道他會被他身邊的人揭發，比如前僱員。

But, yeah, man, this is the downfall of MrBeast starting right now.

但是，是的，這就是野獸先生的下場，從現在開始。

I mean, it's not like he's ever rigged the results of a challenge.

我是說，他又沒有操縱過挑戰的結果。

That would be impossible because he films with hundreds of random subscribers, right?

這是不可能的，因為他的電影有成百上千的隨機用戶，對嗎？

Wrong. Let's look at this video.

錯了讓我們看看這段視頻。

Not only were the results of this video completely scripted, but the contestants are not random subscribers.

這段視頻的結果不僅完全是編排好的，而且參賽者也不是隨機訂閱的。

So many people had jobs.

很多人都有工作。

Oh, that contestant had to get out for her job?

哦，那個參賽選手是為了工作才出來的？

I guess you forgot she's your hiring manager.

我猜你忘了她是你的招聘經理。

I actually recognize a lot of people in this video, including Jimmy's own girlfriend.

事實上，我在這段視頻中認出了很多人，包括吉米自己的女朋友。

So, yeah, the random subscribers you see in challenges are actually never random.

所以，是的，你在挑戰賽中看到的隨機用戶其實從來都不是隨機的。

They're almost always local to MrBeast and oftentimes friends and family of MrBeast employees or just the employees themselves.

他們幾乎都是野獸先生的本地人，有時是野獸先生員工的親朋好友，有時只是員工本人。

And when they do pull someone from outside of North Carolina, it's usually somebody who's in the industry, who's camera trained, who has built a following.

當他們從北卡羅來納州以外的地方找人時，通常都是業內人士、受過攝像訓練的人，他們已經積累了一批粉絲。

And what's even worse is that the results of this video were completely scripted.

更糟糕的是，這段視頻的結果完全是編出來的。

According to a former MrBeast employee, it would have been a PR problem if the boys had won by a lot.

據一位前 "野獸先生 "員工說，如果男孩們贏了很多，就會造成公關問題。

And because so many of the female contestants were MrBeast employees who got out immediately, production stepped in to actually make the results of the challenge closer.

由於很多女選手都是野獸先生的員工，她們馬上就出局了，是以製作方介入，使挑戰的結果更加接近。

You can actually see some of this happen on camera, like when Jimmy pays one of the boys $10,000 to leave, which is twice as much as the actual prize money.

你其實可以在鏡頭前看到一些這樣的場景，比如吉米付給其中一個男孩 1 萬美元讓他離開，這比實際獎金高出一倍。

All right, so essentially everything is fabricated.

好吧，基本上一切都是捏造的。

See, the problem here is that this stuff is borderline illegal.

你看，問題就在於這些東西都是非法的。

Because, you know, what if I'm one of the contestants that actually wasn't bought and paid for, right?

因為，你知道，如果我是其中一個沒有被收買的參賽者呢？

I imagine at least one out of these 100 person is like an actual real person here, right?

我想這 100 個人中至少有一個是真正的真人吧？

And not just friends and family.

而且不僅僅是朋友和家人。

So what if I'm here spending three days and nights here trying to win some money and I'm taking a break from work or whatever and then I get eliminated and I'm like, oh, damn, I didn't win.

如果我在這裡花了三天三夜想贏點錢，我正在休息，然後我被淘汰了，我就會想，哦，該死，我沒贏。

But then I realized after watching this video that the other 90% of the contestants are just your friends, your girlfriend, your whatever the heck, and they were going to win anyways.

但看完這段視頻後我意識到，其他 90% 的參賽選手都是你的朋友、女朋友或其他什麼人，他們無論如何都會贏。

And you're scamming the legit people who came there to win some money.

你在欺騙那些來這裡贏錢的合法居民。

That is some really scummy behavior.

這種行為實在太卑鄙了。

And I gotta take the L here, guys.

夥計們，我得在這裡認輸。

You guys remember Rosanna Pansino?

你們還記得羅珊娜-潘西諾嗎？

She was this YouTuber who has been calling out MrBeast on Twitter for faking his hide-and-seek challenge.

她就是那個在推特上痛斥野獸先生偽造捉迷藏挑戰的 YouTuber。

And she essentially said that she was supposed to place maybe like second place in the hide-and-seek or something like that.

她基本上是說，她本應該在捉迷藏比賽中獲得第二名之類的名次。

And, you know, everyone was like, oh, you're being petty, who cares?

每個人都說，你太小氣了，誰在乎呢？

Who actually cares, right?

誰會真正在乎呢？

And I even criticized her before.

我以前甚至責備過她。

But after looking into it a little bit more, she was right.

但經過深入調查，她是對的。

If she thought she could actually, you know, win some money there or thought it was legit and MrBeast was rigging the results or whatever, somebody actually broke the rules of the challenge and stuff.

如果她認為自己真的可以，你知道的，贏得一些錢，或者認為這是合法的，而野獸先生在操縱結果或其他什麼的，有人真的違反了挑戰規則之類的東西。

And they weren't called out, but she was actually eliminated.

他們沒有被叫出來，但她真的被淘汰了。

And I've defended him a lot of times against people who would criticize his charity and stuff.

我曾多次為他辯護，反對那些責備他慈善事業的人。

But there is just overwhelming evidence now that shows Jimmy is shady as F.

但是，現在有大量證據表明，吉米和 F 一樣不光彩。

So I'm gonna apologize.

所以我要道歉

I'm sorry, Rosanna.

對不起，羅珊娜

But anyways, moving on to MrBeast's real-time video, which I knew, like, that was the instant one where I was texting people like, this is fake.

但不管怎麼說，繼續看野獸先生的實時視頻，我知道，那就是我給別人發短信說 "這是假的 "的即時視頻。

Like, there's no way.

不可能

This is a real-time video, meaning that time elapses the same in the video as it does in real life.

這是一個實時視頻，也就是說，視頻中的時間流逝與現實生活中的時間流逝相同。

Now, immediately, the intro is sped up.

現在，前奏立刻加快了。

And the timer is clearly added in post.

而計時器顯然是在後期添加的。

And he clearly touches the laser here.

他在這裡清楚地觸摸到了脈衝光。

But whatever, let's assume that it's all real-time.

但不管怎樣，讓我們假設這一切都是實時的。

When he reaches the bottom floor, he has to turn these water valves.

當他到達底層時，他必須轉動這些水閥。

Now, you can tell that these valves aren't actually connected to anything because the water flows out in an instant.

現在，你可以知道這些閥門實際上並沒有連接到任何東西上，因為水瞬間就流走了。

And it happens when he's not even touching the valve.

而且這種情況發生在他甚至沒有接觸閥門的時候。

The contestant also goes back to the first valve, unaware that anything had happened.

參賽者也回到了第一道閥門，完全不知道發生了什麼。

And he's still able to spin it.

而且他還能自圓其說。

So the valve seems to spin freely and isn't actually connected to the flow of water.

是以，閥門似乎可以自由旋轉，實際上並沒有與水流相連。

So you could assume that producers might be off-camera with remote switches to trigger the flow of water.

所以你可以假設，製作人可能在鏡頭外用遙控開關來觸發水流。

And assuming they've tested this, the producers might know how long it takes for the water to clear out of the room.

假設他們已經做過測試，製片人可能會知道水需要多長時間才能從房間裡流出來。

So they can sort of decide on the fly how many turns of the valve it takes or just when to trigger the water in general to make the results close.

是以，他們可以臨時決定閥門需要轉幾圈，或者何時觸發水流，使結果關閉。

And in traditional media, this kind of rigging is actually completely illegal.

而在傳統媒體中，這種操縱行為實際上是完全違法的。

On any kind of a game show where there is a prize, you have to have somebody that ensures that it's fair.

在任何一個有獎遊戲節目中，都必須有一個人來確保遊戲的公平性。

They are out there essentially to make sure that we don't do something that would favor one player or one tribe.

他們的存在主要是為了確保我們不會做出對某個選手或某個部落有利的事情。

I paid the one guy who knew how to solve them to leave.

我付錢讓那個知道如何解決這些問題的人離開。

They came to my area many times and I was in the smallest cupboard.

他們多次來到我所在的地區，而我卻被關在最小的櫥櫃裡。

Okay, so pretty much every video that ends at 0.001 seconds before finishing, and it's like super close, obviously it's fake and MrBeast has fabricated that for you making the video more interesting.

好吧，幾乎每段視頻都是在 0.001 秒結束前結束的，而且非常接近，很明顯這是假的，MrBeast 為你編造了這一點，讓視頻更有趣。

Because in reality, it would probably end like five minutes before and randomly.

因為在現實中，它可能會在五分鐘前隨機結束。

And that would just be lame with no tension.

這樣就太沒勁了，沒有張力。

Pretty sure this is not following the law.

這肯定是不守法的。

So MrBeast needs Saul Goodman ASAP because if any of these people decide to sue MrBeast, they are going to win.

是以，"野獸先生 "需要索爾-古德曼（Saul Goodman）儘快出面，因為如果這些人決定起訴 "野獸先生"，他們一定會贏。

They are going to win.

他們會贏的。

You can prove a lot of this stuff with the evidence this guy's used in this video.

你可以用這傢伙在視頻中使用的證據證明很多事情。

So anyways, moving on to the one bad part of this guy's video.

不管怎麼說，現在我們來看看這傢伙視頻中最糟糕的部分。

This should probably have been left out.

這一點或許應該省略。

He basically says the banner on MrBeast's channel, the subscribe for a cookie is manipulative, which it's a bit of a stretch.

他基本上是說，MrBeast 頻道上的橫幅 "訂閱餅乾 "是一種操縱，這有點牽強。

Now as adults, we can recognize that subscribe for a cookie is a joke.

現在，作為成年人，我們可以認識到，認購一塊餅乾是一個笑話。

It's not a real offer.

這不是一個真正的提議。

But again, MrBeast's audience is primarily children who may have authorities in their life that actually use sweet treats or video game detentions as forms of reinforcement.

但再說一遍，MrBeast 的閱聽人主要是兒童，他們生活中可能會有權威人士真正使用甜食或電子遊戲拘留作為強化形式。

And you aren't born understanding sarcasm.

你天生就不懂諷刺。

Okay, just going to be fair here.

好吧，為了公平起見

That is a bit of a weak point, but it doesn't invalidate all the other points in this video.

這一點有點薄弱，但並不能是以否定視頻中的其他觀點。

Like some people were saying, this guy has made a shit ton of good points in this video, right?

就像有些人說的那樣，這傢伙在這段視頻中說了一大堆好話，對吧？

I get the context he's going for because there is a lot of subtle manipulation of children going on here, especially with subscribe and you win $10,000.

我明白他要表達的意思，因為這裡有很多對兒童的微妙操縱，尤其是 "認購就能贏取 1 萬美元"。

And it's actually just buying a lottery ticket, essentially for seven-year-olds.

實際上，這就是買彩票，本質上是給 7 歲的孩子買彩票。

PewDiePie has also called this out before.

PewDiePie 也曾對此表示過不滿。

Keep in mind, he's reacting to a Dhar Mann video, but it applies to the MrBeast one as well, which is why it's edited like that.

請記住，他是在對達曼的視頻做出反應，但這也適用於野獸先生的視頻，這就是為什麼要這樣剪輯的原因。