Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • Since Russia invaded Ukraine, maps of the conflict are everywhere.

  • In most cases, shaded areas, like this red

  • are meant to symbolize territory occupied by Russian forces

  • or at least, territory Russia and Ukraine are fighting over.

  • In general, this red is referring to ground troops, like these.

  • The more the Russian ground troops advance, the more of the map turns red.

  • But what maps like these don't show is another battle

  • that's taking place high above Ukraine.

  • Where a small Ukrainian air force is fighting a powerful Russian one

  • for control of the skies.

  • What happens here could determine not just the course of the war

  • but whether it escalates and spreads beyond Ukraine.

  • It's why Ukraine's allies are scrambling to send it weapons.

  • And some are asking to go a step further:

  • "No-fly zone."

  • "No-fly zone."

  • "A no-fly zone."

  • [chanting] "No-fly zone!"

  • "A humanitarian no-fly zone."

  • "No-fly zone seems to make sense."

  • "Well, I think you that all know what I'm going to say."

  • "We need the no-fly zone over Ukraine."

  • So, why are the stakes of this air war so high?

  • And what would a no-fly zone change?

  • On February 24, 2022, the Russian invasion of Ukraine began.

  • And in terms of military strategy, it followed a common script.

  • First, Russian missiles targeted Ukraine's radar system.

  • Then its airfields and some missile launchers.

  • To military experts, this appeared to be preparation for a crucial step.

  • Send a lot of planes to destroy the Ukrainian air force

  • and achieve what's calledAir Superiority."

  • So when we say a military has air superiority

  • what we're essentially saying is a military more or less controls the skies.

  • With air superiority, Russia could freely attack Ukrainian ground troops

  • and protect its own ground troops

  • who could move faster without fear of being attacked from the skies.

  • If Russia were able to establish virtually unchallenged air superiority

  • it would be a disaster for Ukraine.

  • Doesn't mean you're guaranteed a victory

  • but it makes that victory a heck of a lot more likely.

  • That's why since World War II

  • winning air superiority has been the first step in most invasions.

  • But in this case, the big attack never came.

  • And experts don't really agree on why.

  • My best informed guess is that

  • Russians thought that they would be welcome when they got there.

  • And so when they saw men, women, and children

  • blocking their tanks from entering Ukrainian villages

  • that surprised them.

  • When you make war plans, including plans related to air superiority

  • if your assumptions are wrong, then your plan is messed up.

  • Whatever happened, it means that, more than two weeks into the invasion

  • Russia did not have total air superiority.

  • It allowed the Ukrainian air force to defend themselves

  • against some Russian fighter jets and ground forces

  • helping bog down the Russian invasion.

  • This was celebrated as part of Ukraine's remarkable resistance early on in the war.

  • It's a function of both Ukrainian success and also some surprising

  • shortcomings in Russian military capability.

  • But it might not last much longer.

  • When you compare the Russian military and the Ukrainian military there is no comparison.

  • In every major metric of power, the Russian military is far more powerful

  • including when it comes to aviation.

  • Russia has more than ten times the number of fighter aircraft as Ukraine.

  • And so far, they haven't really used them.

  • It's possible over the coming days and weeks that Putin and his military leaders decide

  • to make greater use of Russian aircraft.

  • And I think that's already happening.

  • They're entering a new phase where, in my view, they're systematically

  • using air power in part

  • to systematically attack civilians and civilian infrastructure.

  • That means the Russians still could win air superiority

  • which would help speed up their invasion, and likely cause significant civilian casualties.

  • So, Ukraine's allies are frantically trying to keep that from happening.

  • Many countries are sending weapons

  • that Ukrainian ground troops can use to shoot down Russian aircraft.

  • And there have been talks about sending Ukraine planes.

  • But there's also been talk of another kind of help: a no-fly zone.

  • Ukrainian president Volodmyrr Zelenskyy has asked NATO, the western military alliance,

  • to declare a no-fly zone.

  • A number of US foreign policy experts have called for a limited no-fly zone

  • and a recent poll shows 74% of Americans think the US should declare one.

  • So, what is a No-Fly Zone?

  • Basically it's a geographic area, where certain plains are prohibited from flying.

  • The point of NATO declaring a No-Fly Zone over Ukraine

  • would be to prevent Russia from winning air superiority

  • thereby protecting Ukraine's military and civilians.

  • But what makes a no-fly zone complicated is how NATO would have to enforce it.

  • To propose the no-fly zone in Ukraine

  • if you're going to be serious about it, you have to consider that to enforce it

  • to make it a real thing

  • you would actually have to shoot down Russian aircraft.

  • This means NATO would be directly participating in the conflict

  • escalating the war to involve the US and most of Europe.

  • The establishment of a no-fly zone sooner or later

  • puts us in a high risk of direct combat.

  • And don't for a minute think that you can control how that escalates.

  • Once one aircraft gets shot down, whether it's ours or theirs

  • all bets are off on what happens next.

  • Russia is a nuclear armed power and Putin's been making a lot of threats to suggest that

  • he thinks nuclear weapons might be an option.

  • All this would also be true of a "limited no-fly zone"

  • which would only cover certain areas, but would be enforced in the same way.

  • Putin has vowed to treat anyone imposing a no-fly zone as a “participant in the conflict”.

  • And, so far, president Biden and NATO leaders have ruled it out.

  • So for now, even while its allies send weapons

  • Ukraine will have to do the fighting themselves.

  • Every bone in my body wants to help Ukrainians.

  • They're fighting for all of us, and I weep when I see some of these images.

  • But I think we should do all that we can to help Ukraine

  • while also doing everything we can to avoid direct conflict with Russia.

Since Russia invaded Ukraine, maps of the conflict are everywhere.

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級 美國腔

How a no-fly zone would change the war in Ukraine

  • 11 0
    林宜悉 發佈於 2023 年 04 月 10 日
影片單字