Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • The race is on to use neuroscience and technology...

  • ...to plug the learning gap between poor and rich children

  • Recent research shows children’s life chances may depend less...

  • ...on showering them with knowledge and words...

  • Kite, key, koala

  • ...and more on opportunities to interact with adults

  • That specific type of communication is what is going to...

  • ...really benefit the child long-term

  • But is this enough?

  • Could a controversial focus on genetics...

  • ...be what’s needed to break the class ceiling?

  • We are at a tipping point in terms of...

  • ...how genetics is going to shape our lives

  • Let’s put your shoes on OK?

  • It might look like Shadarra and her son Kevin...

  • ...are getting ready for a trip to the playground

  • But this is no ordinary day

  • Oh my goodness let’s play, what do you want to play first?

  • Every word they say is being recorded...

  • ...on a tiny device known as a “talk pedometer

  • But instead of tracking steps, it counts words

  • The microphone is in the front and you don’t want to obstruct it

  • You don’t want anything to block the sound

  • The device picks up how many adult words he’s hearing...

  • ...how much electronic noise is in the background...

  • ...and how many turns he’s taking in talking to me...

  • ...when I communicate with him

  • It’s hoped this tech could transform how children learn language...

  • ...and help kids from lower-income families to get ahead

  • It makes me more mindful

  • So now I’m always considering when I’m getting him ready

  • I’m like, am I talking to him enough?

  • So let’s go play with our toys

  • One influential study found that in the first three years of a child’s life...

  • ...those from wealthy families will have heard around 30m more...

  • ...words than those from poorer backgrounds

  • And this word gap can set them back for years to come

  • Kids in poverty hear fewer adult words...

  • ...and it’s not because their parents are bad parents

  • It’s because mom or dad is working two jobs

  • The pedometers are part of a scheme...

  • ...to try to change things by using data

  • Every week Shadarra gets a breakdown of exactly how much...

  • ...she’s spoken to her son while he was wearing the device

  • What I love about this side is because it’s really measurable

  • Weve had several teachers in our district go through the programme...

  • ...and when I’ve talked to them after they get their first or second report...

  • ...almost all of their comments are, I thought I was talking with my kid...

  • ...way more than this report actually shows

  • One study found this use of technology and data analysis...

  • ...led to a 32% increase in the number of words a child hears per hour

  • Everybody, listen to me, what?

  • But it’s not just about increasing the number of words children hear

  • The scheme’s organisers are looking out...

  • ...for the number of so-called conversational turns

  • I tried to tell you last night papa

  • The area that we really encourage and try to promote...

  • ...the most growth in is that back-and-forth conversation...

  • ...between an adult and a child

  • There’s tonnes of research that shows that...

  • ...that specific type of communication

  • ...is what is going to really benefit the child long-term

  • Neuroscience has shown the benefits of conversational turns

  • As they appear to get round...

  • ...some of the disadvantages of growing up poor

  • It is well established that if a child grows up in poverty...

  • ...this affects their growing brain

  • Low socioeconomic status or other types of disadvantage...

  • ...or adversity affect the developing brain

  • Parts of the brain that respond to...

  • ...threatening environments, tend to accelerate...

  • ...so that children can be more resilient

  • Then there are other parts of the brain, showing slower growth...

  • ...when exposed to adversity

  • Here we go in one, two, three

  • But when children are engaged...

  • ...in high numbers of conversational turns...

  • ...these differences in brain development...

  • ...caused by their background don’t seem to matter

  • And regions of the brain associated with language development expand

  • Conversational turns is something directly...

  • ...in the child’s everyday environment that seems to have an effect over...

  • ...and above socioeconomic status

  • Yet despite these insights from neuroscience and new tech...

  • ...the gap in achievement between rich and poor kids...

  • ...hasn’t changed for decades

  • By the time they are ten, in fourth grade...

  • ...lower-income students will have a reading score...

  • ...around 28 points below their richer classmates

  • And this gap hasn’t really changed in the past 20 years

  • Were surprisingly ineffective at that, at closing the differences...

  • ...that we see between low-income and high-income children

  • In some cases, those gaps have actually gotten worse...

  • ...in the US in the last 25 years

  • So what else could help level the playing field?

  • Professor Kathryn Paige Harden is a psychologist and geneticist...

  • ...who argues a new approach is needed

  • She believes understanding children’s genetics could be key

  • From a genetic perspective, we can see that...

  • ...people who happen to inherit certain genetic variants...

  • ...are more likely to graduate from college

  • I think were really used to thinking about the role...

  • ...that a child’s family background plays in...

  • ...equality and inequality over the course of their life

  • And what were seeing with the research now...

  • ...is that genetics plays just a bigger role in shaping these types...

  • ...of inequalities in life outcomes

  • Professor Harden argues genetics could be used...

  • ...to identify the children least likely to do well at school

  • And that this offers the potential for better...

  • ...and more effective interventions to help them

  • You can have children spit into a tube...

  • ...and for less than 75 American dollars...

  • ...you can get a read out of their DNA...

  • ...which can be used to see, OK we know for some reason...

  • ...these kids with these genetic variants are less likely...

  • ...in 30 years to have graduated from college, or have gotten a PhD

  • Is this so exciting?

  • She says that some existing interventions, which don’t take account...

  • ...of genetics, could be improved

  • Is that intervention working disproportionately for people...

  • ...who are most likely to succeed in school or least likely?

  • Or is it working about the same for everyone?

  • So far those questions are really unknown...

  • ...because interventioners haven’t really incorporated...

  • ...genetic tools into their research designs

  • There’s nothing the state of North Carolina can do...

  • ...to justify what they did to me

  • The idea of using genetic information...

  • ...to shape social policy provokes strong reactions

  • It has a very dark and uncomfortable past

  • In the 20th century genetic traits...

  • ...were used to promote the idea of racial superiority...

  • ...sometimes in disturbing propaganda

  • I think many people worry because they say...

  • ...that’s a way of dismissing a large chunk of the population

  • They talk about genetic determinism being right-wing

  • But Professor Harden believes it doesn’t have to be like this

  • We see these real fears that genetic information...

  • ...will be used to naturalise hierarchy

  • At the same time, we see an increasing embrace...

  • ...of thinking about our biology, in relation to sexual orientation...

  • ...in relation to weight, how does my genotype affect...

  • ...my difficulty in keeping off weight?

  • So what I’d like to see is for that trend to continue...

  • ...but around things related to academic achievement...

  • ...or educational attainment

  • Using genetic information like this is still a long way off

  • Its advocates will have to show that it can be done...

  • ...in a safe and ethical way

  • And that it will improve social mobility...

  • ...rather than increasing existing inequalities

  • Parents and children see that the DNA revolution is here

  • They want to know how it’s affecting them

  • I expect it to be a really scientifically interesting...

  • ...and productive area of research moving forward

  • Hi, I’m Adrian Wooldridge, political editor here at The Economist

  • If you'd like to read more about social mobility...

  • ...then click on the link opposite

  • And if you’d like to watch more in our Now & Next series...

  • ...click on the other link

  • Thanks for watching

  • And don't forget to subscribe

The race is on to use neuroscience and technology...

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

A1 初級 美國腔

經濟學人(Can science help poor kids earn more? | The Economist)

  • 34 6
    Taiyi Lin 發佈於 2021 年 11 月 19 日
影片單字