Name: 愛還是欲？羅密歐與朱麗葉第二部：英語文學速成班 #3 (Love or Lust? Romeo and Juliet Part II: Crash Course English Literature #3)
Uploaded: 2021-01-14T04:58:23.000Z
Duration: 10 min 11 s
Description: 【看影片學英語】數萬部 YouTube 影片，搭配英漢字典即點即查，輕鬆掌握單字發音與用法，長久累積看電影不必再看字幕。

Hi I’m John Green; this is Crash Course English Literature, and today we return to

Romeo and Juliet, a tale of love and woe, or else a tale of lust and woe. Anyway, it’s

程度副詞

As the play begins, Romeo is telling us that he is completely in love with a girl and will

never love anyone else. And her name is Rosaline. And a day later--A SINGLE DAY--he has married

an entirely different girl. And the whole thing is forbidden in a desperate

and exciting way. “My only love sprung from my only hate,” etc.

And that makes me wonder, does romantic love benefit from--or maybe even require--these

kind of obstacles in order to feel intense and real?

Mr. Green, Mr. Green. Yes. Truly spoken like a teenager, Me from the

Past. Because from where I’m sitting, true love is when you’re standing in line at

Chipotle and you say, “I shouldn’t get guacamole,” and the great love of your life

says, “You know what? Just get the guac,” and then you go home and you watch TV together

while eating burritos. That’s true love, Me from the Past, of a

depth and quality that you can only imagine and poor Romeo and Juliet will never know.

And not least because there were no Chipotles in medieval Verona,

(Intro.) So, it’s telling to look at the way that

Juliet describes her own feelings and the reasons for them. She calls their romance:

“too rash, too unadvised, too sudden; Too like the lightning, which doth cease to

But then in the same scene, she says: My bounty is as boundless as the sea,

My love as deep; the more I give to thee, The more I have, for both are infinite.

The lightning is over in a flash, but the sea is infinite. Juliet also famously speaks

of her “true-love passion,” which conflates two very different ideas--

As previously noted, true love is eating burritos together on the couch in your sweatpants,

whereas passion never involves burritos. What’s that? What’s Rule 34? Really? Okay. Yes.

Apparently passion occasionally involves burritos. By the way, this play is full of bawdy jokes,

usually told in prose courtesy of the Nurse or Mercutio, so it’s not like Shakespeare

wasn’t aware of sex without love. Are Romeo and Juliet making themselves believe

they’re in love to excuse their sexual desire? Would Juliet have gotten tired of Romeo? Stan,

I thought that we established that these were real. How is this? [a][b]Why is this happening?

Ah, it’s a metaphor, isn’t it, Stan? Get rid of the metaphor.

Possibly. Romeo can be a little bit intense. Like, sword fight murder intense.

And although Juliet violently rejects Paris, the man her father wants her to marry, he

seems like a pretty stand-up guy and in many ways a better match for her than Romeo.

So Romeo and Juliet’s flirtation follows the traditions of courtly love, a medieval

concept still popular in the Renaissance that advocates love at first sight and forswearing

all for love. But vitally, you aren’t supposed to sully

courtly love with sex or marriage, as Romeo and Juliet clearly do.

You’re supposed to sit around and pine and be miserable for the rest of your Edith Wharton-ing

life, like Petrarch and Dante did. All these supposedly amorous Italians but all they ever

do is write poems. Right, so you can really read the first couple

acts of Romeo and Juliet as a potential comedy. Girl falls for the wrong boy and they’ve

got to figure out what to do. So far, that’s the plot of A Midsummer’s

Night Dream. But with those characters, there was not skoodilypooping.

Romeo and Juliet do skoodilypoop, and sullying their love with sex—even post-marital sex--proves

kind of deadly. Oh, it’s time for the open letter.

An Open Letter to Literary Sex But first, let’s see what’s in the secret

compartment today. Oh, it’s Shakespeare socks. Perfect because Stan won’t let me

wear shoes because they just painted the set. Dear literary sex,

Why you gotta be so fatal? Here’s an interesting fact: until about

40 years ago, every single human who was ever born was born as a result of sex.

But to read the great novels and plays of human history, you would think that the mere

act of having sex is fatal like 65% of the time.

How did we acquire all these Montagues and Capulets if just having sex is so dangerous?

And I’ve noticed that having sex is particularly fatal to young ladies.

And that doesn’t seem very fair. After all, it does take two to fandango.

Okay but as always in Shakespeare, it’s not quite that simple, and there are indications

that Romeo and Juliet may be, at least in Shakespeare’s conception, really in love.

I mean, in their first conversation, they speak a total of 14 lines to each other. And

those 14 lines, when combined, form a perfect Shakespearean sonnet.

So this isn’t some random hook up at a party; this is literally instant poetry.

And Shakespeare bestows many of his most gorgeous lines on them--Northrop Frye calls this play,

“word magic.” Not only that, but remember, through their

death this intractable conflict between two families is ended.

And in that story of transcendental suffering and sacrifice, one can’t help but recall

the more famous story of transcendental sacrifice: that of Jesus.

Romeo and Juliet don’t actually do much together. If you think about it, they don’t

even actually die together. Only a few days separate their meeting and their deaths.

We can see the play, then, as a tragedy about time, how little there is of it, and also

about youth, how we assign passionate importance to things and people when we’re young, because

we don’t have the breadth of experience to behave more moderately--which is maybe

the tragedy of adulthood. “Old folks,” Juliet maintains, are “unwieldly,

slow, heavy, pale as lead.” But for me the play is ultimately about having

to make difficult choices with limited information. This love, which feels real and I would argue

therefore is real, has to be balanced against responsibilities to your family and to the

state, in the form of the Prince of Verona. And to the church.

In your life, are you going to seek what you want, or are you going to listen to your parents

when they tell you want to want, or to the state when it tells you what to want?

Until the very end of the play, both Romeo and Juliet are trying to find ways to please

all these masters--the self, the state, the church, the family.

And that is what kills them. Had they run away together, or hooked up without getting

marrying in an unchurchly fashion, they probably would have survived.

Their love is an ardent and over-the-top response to the violent and unjust world in which they

live and the patriarchal authority that controls that would--but they can never really abandon

or reject that authority. And this is still a challenge for teenagers,

who are often dismissed as idealistic or melodramatic, and who must balance their intensity of feeling

against the expectations of the world around them.

Don’t drop out of high school to follow your dream of being a trapeze artist; honor

thy father and mother; register for the draft; don’t pass up a full ride to Harvard to

follow your girlfriend into the Marines; etc. Let’s go to the Thought Bubble.

As Harley Granville Barker put it, Romeo and Juliet is ‘a tragedy of youth as youth sees

If you’re young or have ever been young, you know what it’s like to be pulled in

many directions while trying to discern whether feelings that are brand new to you are more

like flashes of lightning or an eternal ocean,

and you know what it’s like to want to live fully and fearlessly and maybe even a little

And the occasionally tragic thing is that you are just grown up enough for that kind