Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • Good morning John, I don't know

  • whether I'm capable of making a decision.

  • Like on the scale of things, I'm a very good decision maker. I can crack them out like no problem.

  • What I mean is that I don't know if I or anyone is capable of doing anything that wasn't

  • predetermined from the moment of the Big Bang.

  • I've seen some fairly compelling arguments that, like, the initial starting state conditions for the universe

  • define the words that are coming out of my mouth right now.

  • Pantsuit. Golden tugboat. Larger park.

  • Larger park! That had to have come from nowhere, right? No, it came from the Big Bang.

  • At least, that's what a lot of smart people say. No matter what I do right now, I am not making a decision

  • Like, just, just AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHH

  • [playing guitar and singing]

  • ♪ ♫ Down to the beach I'm strolling, ♫ ♪

  • ♫ ♪ but the seagulls! They poke at my head, not fun, oh seagulls! ♪ ♫

  • ♪ ♫ Stop it now. ♫ ♪

  • I didn't really think about what was over there before I did that.

  • Doesn't seem possible that, like, not only me singing that song

  • but also, the lyrics to the weird seagulls, Yoda's song, and all the way to Emily Dickinson

  • and William Shakespeare, all that stuff

  • was just the inevitable consequence of particles knocking against each other

  • and seeking lower energy states.

  • [chagrined groan]

  • And if there is randomness, if it is in fact impossible to predict everything that will ever happen

  • based on the starting conditions of the Big Bang,

  • then it's not, like, human decisions that are introducing that randomness,

  • it's weird quantum fluctuations.

  • It's particles doing particle things.

  • "Me", the story that I tell myself about myself,

  • is just another...inevitable physical phenomenon.

  • I'm just a ball rolling down a hill.

  • And I've come to a place where I kind of rationally accept this.

  • In philosophy this is called "determinism": that everything that happens is part of

  • an inevitable chain of cause and effect.

  • But in my everyday life, of course I ignore this!

  • I choose, with the free will that I don't have, to ignore the fact that I don't have free will.

  • Because I know--wait for it--that if I accepted the fact that I didn't have free will,

  • I would make a bunch of different decisions that would negatively impact

  • my ability to joyfully flourish on this space ball.

  • Side note: I'm calling planets "space balls" now,

  • and if you don't like that, there's nothing I can do about it.

  • Me calling planets "space balls" is just an inevitable consequence of the starting conditions of the universe.

  • Sorry!

  • Anyway, where was I?

  • Accepting that I am not actually making decisions does not fit with my lived experience.

  • Like, I can say "Free will doesn't exist!", and then I still have to, like, decide what to make

  • my video about. I have to decide what to have for dinner. I have to decide what the next word

  • is that's gonna come out of my mouth.

  • And so--and this is the actual point of the video--

  • I live...in intentional ignorance of a reality.

  • I also kind of do this Re: the inevitable situation

  • in which there will be one human being left and then that last human will die.

  • I'm a science dude. I believe in the intrinsic goodness

  • of having a more accurate understanding of the world today than you did yesterday,

  • both as individuals and as a collective species.

  • And yet there is a very short list of things I think it's just better to ignore.

  • Because my ultimate goal isn't to have, like, the perfect understanding of the universe.

  • My ultimate goal is to find happiness,

  • and to help other people do that too.

  • I don't know that this video has served that purpose, but... I tried.

  • John, I'll see you on Tuesday.

  • If you're feeling a little rough after that one, I apologize. That's not my goal.

  • This always helps my toddler! Uh, my little boy:

  • [copious fart noises]

  • Hopefully, that's--that's better now.

Good morning John, I don't know

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級

故意無知。自由意志存在嗎? (Intentionally Ignorant: Does Free Will Exist?)

  • 5 0
    林宜悉 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日
影片單字