Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • I'm Dan Mitchell of the Cato Institute,

  • here to narrate another Center for Freedom and Prosperity video.

  • Today's topic is why tax havens are good for the global economy.

  • We're talking about this issue because politicians,

  • especially those from high tax nations such as France and Germany,

  • are persecuting low-tax jurisdictions.

  • They don't like the fact that jobs and capital are shifting to places with better tax laws.

  • Working through international bureaucracies, such as the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development,

  • the European Commission,

  • and the United Nations,

  • these politicians from high-tax nations are trying to shut down the havens

  • in hopes of propping up their uncompetitive fiscal systems

  • The OECD even put together a tax haven blacklist,

  • and threatened these jurisdictions with financial protectionism

  • if they didn't agree to become vassal tax collectors for bigger nations.

  • Some off-the-wall advocates of big government

  • have even urged military attacks against tax savings, if you can believe that.

  • In a previous video, we talked about the issue of tax competition,

  • which occurs when politicians feel pressure to improve tax policy

  • so the geese that laid the golden eggs won't fly away.

  • Ever since the Reagan and Thatcher tax-rate reductions began the process of tax competition,

  • nations have been racing the lower tax rates,

  • in hopes of attracting or retaining jobs and investment.

  • Top personal income tax rates in the developed world

  • have dropped by more than twenty five percentage points.

  • Corporate tax rates, meanwhile,

  • have plunged by twenty percentage points,

  • and there are now twenty five flat tax nations - an amazing development

  • No wonder the global economy is so much stronger today

  • than it was in the nineteen seventies.

  • Tax havens are good because they promote this tax competition.

  • But before getting into details

  • let's define what it means to be a haven.

  • According to stereotypes, tax havens are little islands in the Caribbean,

  • and indeed, some of the world's premier offshore centers are Caribbean Islands.

  • But to be more accurate,

  • a tax haven is any jurisdiction that satisfies two criteria.

  • First, it has tax laws that are attractive to global investors and entrepreneurs.

  • Second, it protects its fiscal sovereignty by choosing,

  • in at least some cases, not to enforce the bad tax laws of other nations.

  • So who are the havens?

  • The answer is gonna surprise you.

  • One of the world's leading experts on offshore issues, Marshall Langer,

  • wrote in Tax Notes International that the most important tax haven in the world is Manhattan

  • The second most important haven in the world is... London

  • the United States and United Kingdom are havens

  • because of attractive laws that enable foreigners to invest money

  • and then not have to report that income to their tax police.

  • That's good for the US and UK economies,

  • and it's good, of course, for the foreign taxpayers.

  • By some counts there are more than seventy tax havens in the world,

  • ranging from big nations like the United States

  • to obscure tiny jurisdictions such as Melilla,

  • which is an autonomous part of Spain on the coast of Morocco,

  • and Sark, a tiny British controlled island off the coast of France.

  • In some cases, such as America,

  • the tax haven policies are designed to attract global capital

  • and are only available to foreigners.

  • In other cases, such as the Bahamas,

  • the beneficial tax rules are open to everyone,

  • both residents and non-residents.

  • Let's run through quickly four reasons why tax havens are good for the global economy.

  • First and most important, they promote good policy around the world

  • by pressuring politicians and high-tax nations to lower tax rates.

  • We already saw how tax rates have been reduced and how a flat tax revolution is sweeping the globe.

  • These pro-growth changes are happening mostly because of tax competition,

  • and tax havens are very valuable in this regard

  • because politicians are less likely to be greedy

  • when they know taxpayers have escape options.

  • Remarkably, even OECD economists understand that tax competition

  • is a pro-growth force in the world economy.

  • They have admitted that “...the ability to choose the location of economic activity

  • offsets shortcoming in government budgeting processes,

  • limiting a tendency to spend and tax excessively.”

  • Another OECD study acknowledged that

  • “...decentralization can make governments more accountable...

  • It may also introduce competition across jurisdictions and thus raise public sector efficiency.”

  • These are astounding confessions,

  • since the OECD is the bureaucracy that is leading the attack against low-tax jurisdictions.

  • Tax havens have been especially helpful

  • in convincing politicians to reduce the double taxation of saving and investment.

  • Many nations have lowered or eliminated death taxes and wealth taxes,

  • because the politicians have finally figured out

  • that oppressive tax laws simply lead taxpayers to move their money to havens,

  • such as Luxembourg or Panama.

  • Likewise, nations have reduced the double taxation of dividends, interest, and capital gains.

  • The politicians figure it's better to have a low rate and collect some money,

  • rather than have a high rate

  • and drive investment somewhere such us Switzerland or Singapore.

  • As a German economist noted,

  • the level of total taxation would indeed be higher

  • in a world without tax competition...

  • Financial assets such as bank accounts, bonds, or equity

  • are highly mobile and easy to relocate. ...

  • Tax competition has largely prevented [politicians] from tapping into this revenue source. ...

  • tax rates were cut practically everywhere.

  • From an economic perspective, these lower tax rates are critical

  • because they've reduced the tax bias against saving and investment.

  • This encourages people to set aside more of today's income to finance tomorrow's growth.

  • And even socialists agree that capital formation is the key long-run prosperity

  • and rising living standards.

  • Second, tax havens generate high living standards.

  • According to World Bank data,

  • nine of the world's thirteen richest jurisdictions are tax havens.

  • Academic researchers, not surprisingly,

  • have confirmed that tax havens grow faster and create more prosperity for people.

  • This is especially important in the developing world,

  • where poor nations that become tax havens

  • enjoy big increases and prosperity

  • and big reductions in poverty.

  • Third, tax havens promote better governance.

  • One of the problems plaguing poor nations

  • is the lack of sound institutions.

  • Property rights, the rule of law, and sound money

  • are the indispensable building blocks for wealth creation and economic growth.

  • Well, two academics found that the desire to become a tax haven

  • leads nations to improve their institutions, for the simple reason

  • that global investors don't want to place their money in poorly governed jurisdictions.

  • This is something that should be applauded, not persecuted.

  • Fourth, and this is especially interesting,

  • leading economists found that tax havens help high-tax nations enjoy more prosperity.

  • This seems like an odd finding, but it actually makes a lot of sense.

  • Most countries, even high-tax nations,

  • generally have more favorable tax rules for inbound investment.

  • This is because politicians figure their own citizens are captive customers and can be overtaxed,

  • but they understand that they have to compete for global investment,

  • so there are better rules for foreigners.

  • What happens, then, is that citizens from high-tax nations often

  • move their money to a neighboring tax haven;

  • They then pretend that they're foreigners and they use the haven as a platform

  • to invest back in their own country.

  • This additional investment in the high-tax country,

  • which otherwise would not have taken place,

  • increases its prosperity,

  • which is exactly what the professor's found in their study.

  • Let's close with a quote that captures the essence of the issue.

  • John Mcginnis, of Northwestern University Law School,

  • wrote that, “Jurisdictional competition among sovereign nations

  • is a primary mechanism

  • for empowering the encompassing interest of a nation

  • and reducing the ability of interest groups

  • the take resources from the government.

  • ...Leaders are therefore restrained from rewarding themselves,

  • their supporters, or influential special interest groups.

  • I'm going to sign off now with my usual request.

  • Help the Center for Freedom and Prosperity by sharing this video with your friends and colleagues.

  • I'm Dan Mitchell, thank you for your time.

I'm Dan Mitchell of the Cato Institute,

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級

避稅地的經濟理由 (The Economic Case for Tax Havens)

  • 265 18
    SophyYeh 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日
影片單字