Name: 瑞克·比託為何如此厭惡 AI？真正原因大揭密！ (The Real Reason Rick Beato Is Upset About AI )
Uploaded: 2026-02-24T21:42:54.000Z
Duration: 10 min 19 s

程度副詞

Rick Beato Coming in Hot with another Video on all things AI the Music Industry how music and music platforms are completely changing because of AI.

Rick Beato 又來啦！這次的影片要講所有關於 AI、音樂產業，以及音樂和音樂平臺因為 AI 而徹底改變的一切。

Now Rick seems a little pissed with his video title.

看來 Rick 對他的影片標題有點火大。

We also were so pissed off by these companies, which are now multibillion dollar companies that stole independent artists music to build their platforms, got zero licenses the first two years that they were in business.

我們也對這些公司感到非常火大，這些公司現在是數十億美元的公司，他們偷了獨立音樂人的音樂來建立他們的平臺，在經營的前兩年完全沒有取得授權。

So my law firm has filed class action lawsuits against Suno and Udio.

所以我的律師事務所已經對 Suno 和 Udio 提出了集體訴訟。

But with that being said, let's take a look at what Rick Beato is pissed off about today.

不過話雖如此，我們還是來看看 Rick Beato 今天到底在氣什麼。

So a friend of mine sent me this LA Times article that I'm chuckling about now that I just read and it goes like this.

我一位朋友傳了這篇洛杉磯時報的文章給我，我現在讀完覺得很好笑，文章是這樣寫的。

Sienna Rose has achieved a level of breakout stardom envied by musicians everywhere.

Sienna Rose 已經達到了讓所有音樂人都羨慕的突破性巨星等級。

Over the last four months, she's developed a fan base of more than 4 million monthly Spotify listeners.

在過去四個月裡，她已經累積了超過 400 萬的 Spotify 月活躍聽眾。

Her her star has risen in tandem with that of Olivia Dean, a fellow neo soul vocalist who took home this year's Grammy for Best New Artist.

她的聲勢和 Olivia Dean 一樣高漲，Olivia Dean 也是一位新靈魂樂歌手，今年抱走了葛萊美獎 Best New Artist。

Rose's Spotify biography extol sir is not just a performer, but

Rose 的 Spotify 自傳中讚揚她不只是一位表演者，

a storyteller at heart, singing every word with a sense of truth and beauty.

更是一位天生的說書人，用真誠和美麗的歌聲唱出每個字。

But Rose didn't attend the Grammys earlier this month because she's neither a neo soul artist nor the possessor of he's so funny with the expression on his face.

但 Rose 這個月稍早沒有出席葛萊美獎，因為她既不是新靈魂樂歌手，也不是擁有那種表情超好笑的人。

He's like he's holding back so much right now.

The soul to begin with, she is AI top to bottom, an algorithmic interpretation of real artists in a genre it was built to exploit and ultimately replace.

從一開始的靈魂樂，她就是 AI top to bottom，是演算法詮釋真實藝術家的一種方式，而這個曲風的建立就是為了剝削並最終取代他們。

It goes on to say AI generated songs now make up nearly 40% of music uploaded to streaming services daily.

文章還提到，AI generated 歌曲現在佔了每天上傳到串流平臺的音樂將近 40%。

These songs are becoming more impressive by the day too.

這些歌曲也一天比一天更厲害。

In one study, only 3% of respondents could reliably distinguish between AI generated and human generated music, and

在一項研究中，只有 3% 的受訪者能可靠地區分 AI generated 和人類創作的音樂，

I'm pretty sure that information came from Deezer.

So Deezer released the information that roughly 39% of all music delivered to its platform daily is AI music.

所以 Deezer 公佈的資訊是，每天送到他們平臺的音樂，大約有 39% 是 AI music。

And that's roughly 60,000 AI tracks every day.

而這大約是每天有 60,000 首 AI 歌曲。

As of late January, six of Spotify's top 50 trending songs in the US were fully AI generated.

截至一月底，Spotify 美國熱門歌曲前 50 名中，有 6 首是完全 AI generated 的。

So anytime I hear that something is possibly AI, I click on their Instagram to see what's going on there.

所以每次我聽到有東西可能是 AI 的，我就會點進他們的 Instagram 看看是怎麼回事。

So I click on the link provided here in Spotify and it brings me to this page.

所以我點了 Spotify 這裡提供的連結，它就帶我到這個頁面。

Sienna Rose, who has 35 posts and 6,971 followers.

Sienna Rose，有 35 則貼文和 6,971 位追蹤者。

That's not very many followers for someone with about 4 million monthly listeners.

對於一個有大約 400 萬月聽眾的人來說，這追蹤者數量不算多。

I'm looking at her account right now because I was just curious because right now there's about 100,000 views on Rick's video.

我現在正在看她的帳號，因為我只是好奇，因為 Rick 的影片現在大約有 10 萬次觀看。

Because of the free publicity that this account is now getting, she has gained 20 new followers.

因為這個帳號現在獲得的免費宣傳，她已經增加了 20 位新追蹤者。

As a point of comparison, let's look at another artist that's in the same style, like a kind of Neo soul.

作為比較，我們來看另一位風格相似的藝人，像是 Neo soul。

Unlike Sienna Rose, this song has 192 million plays.

和 Sienna Rose 不同的是，這首歌有 1.92 億次播放。

She also has a song called monopoly that's got 202 million plays.

她還有一首歌叫 monopoly，有 2.02 億次播放。

That's the amount of plays you would expect for someone that has 4 million monthly listeners.

這才是擁有 400 萬月聽眾的藝人該有的播放次數。

And if you go to her Instagram, she has 2.1 million followers there, which is what you would expect with a real human being.

如果你看她的 Instagram，她有 210 萬追蹤者，這才是一個真實人類該有的數字。

If we go back to Sienna Rose's Instagram and you click these three buttons to see about her account, it says, date joined, 2022 account based in Norway.

如果我們回到 Sienna Rose 的 Instagram，點擊這三個按鈕查看她的帳號資訊，上面寫著加入日期是 2022 年，帳號設在挪威。

Well, if you hear her talk, I'm not saying anything, but if you watch this video.

嗯，如果你聽她說話，我什麼都不說，但如果你看這支影片。

So I keep seeing these comments everywhere.

Well, I feel real and I.3 million people listening feel the same.

嗯，我感覺自己是真人，而且我這 300 萬的聽眾也這麼覺得。

All right, so we actually did a deep dive on Sienna Rose a few weeks ago because at that time, the Spotify streams were still under like, a million.

好的，其實我們幾週前有深入研究過 Sienna Rose，因為那時候她的 Spotify 播放量還不到一百萬。

But it was very noteworthy because again, there didn't seem to be a real world footprint of like, is this a real person?

但這點非常值得注意，因為同樣地，似乎沒有一個真實世界的足跡能證明「這是一個真人嗎？」

But I did go and inspect and with AI videos and trying to mimic human skin and stuff like that, it's getting pretty good.

不過我確實去檢查了，而且用 AI 影片來試圖模仿人類皮膚等等，它已經做得相當不錯了。

在某些情況下，甚至好得有點嚇人。

像是，Spotify 為什麼要推這種爛東西？

I mean, is it possible that she's a real artist?

我是說，她有可能是一位真正的藝人嗎？

I guess it's possible that she only has 11 million plays of her biggest song on here and that she has 4 million monthly listeners.

我猜啦，她這首最紅的歌在這裡有 1100 萬次播放，而且她有 400 萬的月聽眾，這是有可能的。

And these other people that have 4 million monthly listeners have songs with hundreds of millions of plays.

而那些同樣有 400 萬月聽眾的其他人，他們的歌曲都有數億次的播放。

It's possible that she has 6,900 Instagram followers.

她有 6900 個 Instagram 追蹤者，這也是有可能的。

When someone that has the same amount of monthly listeners on Spotify has 2 million, it's possible that her videos are real and that she's a real person that lives in Norway.

當一個人在 Spotify 上有相同月聽眾數量的人，卻有 200 萬的追蹤者時，那她可能是個住在挪威的真人，她的影片是真的。

It's possible that Norway has magical disappearing door frames.

挪威有可能有神奇的消失門框。

And it's possible that Deezer accidentally labeled it as AI, but it's real.

而且 Deezer 有可能不小心標記它是 AI，但實際上是真的。

So Deezer is a standout platform that actually discloses if something is made with AI and Deezer has developed patent pending technology to identify AI music.

所以 Deezer 是個很突出的平臺，它會實際揭露內容是否為 AI 生成，而且 Deezer 開發了專利申請中的技術來辨識 AI music。

And they want everyone to know it's if something is AI and in fact they even carve it out so that the royalties that are paid, that if something is AI music, it does not receive royalties.

他們希望讓大家知道，如果內容是 AI 生成的，事實上他們甚至會區分開來，讓支付的權利金，如果內容是 AI music，就不會收到權利金。

So they've taken a stand since the beginning to try to protect human made music and more specifically to protect the earnings received on music platforms that they be paid to the human creators.

所以他們從一開始就採取立場，試圖保護真人創作的音樂，更具體來說是保護在音樂平臺上支付給真人創作者的收入。

Why is Spotify pushing stuff that appears to be AI and not labeling it?

Spotify 為什麼要推廣看起來是 AI 卻沒有標記的內容？

People that I know, if they know that it's AI, they don't want to waste their time listening to it.

我認識的人，如果知道是 AI 做的，他們就不想浪費時間去聽。

Okay, when we looked at Sienna Rose a few weeks ago, our issue was that on the videos being like, I'm a real person, you don't think I'm real?

好的，幾週前我們看 Sienna Rose 的時候，我們的問題是，影片裡說「我是真人，你不覺得我是真人嗎？」

Right, she sings, carries a sense of truth and beauty, making Sienna Rose not just a performer, but

對，她唱的每一個音符都帶著真誠和美麗，讓 Sienna Rose 不僅僅是一位表演者，而是

Okay, so there's this little thing called consumer fraud.

好的，所以有個小小的東西叫做消費者詐欺。

And it's a big deal when you lie to the public at large saying you are somebody that you are not or you are something that you are not.

當你對大眾撒謊說你是某個人，但你不是，或者你是某樣東西，但你不是，這可是件大事。

Okay, fine, it may be a great song, but I want to know what I'm listening to.

好的，好吧，也許這是一首很棒的歌，但我想要知道我正在聽的是什麼。

There is a reason they put the ingredients on things because you don't want to be eating a bunch of crap.

東西上面之所以會標示成分，是因為你不想吃到一堆爛東西。

It least on Twizzlers it says artificially flavor.

至少 Twizzlers 上面有寫是人工香料。

All right, we're going to start a war in the comments section right now.

好啦，我們現在就要在留言區開戰了。

Not sponsored by Twizzlers as a bunch of fake things in the ingredients.

這不是 Twizzlers 的業配，說成分裡有一堆假的東西。

And I know I'm eating dyes and sugar and just a bunch of crap that's not real.

我知道我吃的是色素、糖，還有很多不是真的東西。

I want to know that I'm listening to something that's not real, that wasn't created by a human, but

我想知道我聽到的東西不是真的，不是人類創作的，而是

it was created from a bunch of actual real artists, real work.

是由一群真正的藝術家、真實的作品創作出來的。

It's just a bunch of fragments stolen and recombined together to mimic something that is real, but

它只是一堆片段被偷來、重組在一起，模仿真實的東西，但

Somehow Spotify is letting this thing go and letting it gather what I assume is fake listeners.

不知道為什麼 Spotify 竟然讓這種東西存在，還讓它累積我猜是假的聽眾。

They may not be fake listeners, but I assume they're fake.

也許不是假的聽眾，但我猜是假的。

Listeners just because it doesn't seem to obey the laws of gravity at all or any of the laws of physics compared to other real artists.

聽眾，因為跟其他真正的藝術家比起來，它似乎完全不遵守地心引力或任何物理定律。

And in fact one of the current CO CEOs of Spotify had this to say, quote, a growing catalog has always been very good for us in reference to the rise of AI generated music.

事實上，Spotify 現任的幾位執行長之一曾說過，引述：「不斷增長的曲庫對我們來說一直都很好」，這是指 AI generated music 的崛起。

Quote, it attracts new users, drives engagement and builds fandom.

引述：「它吸引新用戶，增加互動，並建立粉絲群。」

While the music may be generated on various AI platforms, the point is that regardless of where the music is made, the cultural moment always happens on Spotify.

雖然音樂可能是在各種 AI 平臺生成的，但重點是，無論音樂在哪裡製作，文化熱潮總是在 Spotify 上發生。

AKA bigger catalogs, more users, more engagement, more subscriptions and more advertising dollars for Spotify.

也就是說，更大的曲庫、更多用戶、更多互動、更多訂閱，以及為 Spotify 帶來更多廣告收入。

So really going back to Deezer and I'm setting up a meeting with them so we can discuss their tech and how I would potentially like to integrate them into our class action lawsuits.

所以，回到 Deezer，我正在安排和他們開會，以便討論他們的新技術，以及我可能會想將他們納入我們集體訴訟的計畫。