Name: 變性運動員是否擁有不公平的優勢？ (Do Trans Athletes Have An Unfair Advantage?)
Uploaded: 2025-02-02T14:18:47.000Z
Duration: 15 min 9 s

情態副詞

A woman is having a vagina, oh well, actually, no, is whatever you want to think of the woman.

女人就是有陰道，哦，好吧，其實不是，是你想怎麼想就怎麼想的女人。

There's trans men who are now capable of giving birth.

質疑是否會讓你產生變性恐懼症？

Like, why are you asking these questions right now type thing?

比如，你現在為什麼要問這些問題？

所以今天我問到了變性運動員。

Challenge each person with questions the other side may ask.

用對方可能提出的問題來挑戰每個人。

Should trans athletes compete against biological women?

變性運動員是否應該與親生女性競爭？

People think that they're going to beat them, then they're probably not the best for that competition.

如果人們認為自己能打敗他們，那麼他們可能就不是這場比賽的最佳人選。

That's like saying there's like 10 bears that are all fighting each other and then it's like, wait, let's bring in this one T-Rex and then let's add that in and let's see how that kind of goes.

這就好比說，有 10 頭熊在互相廝殺，然後，等等，讓我們把這頭霸王龍帶進來，再把它加進來，看看會發生什麼。

And what happens is the T-Rex just destroys them.

Women's sports is pretty self-descriptive.

No matter how many surgeries a woman's body is a woman's body, you can't really change that.

無論做了多少手術，女人的身體就是女人的身體，你無法真正改變這一點。

You get on hormone therapy, it does change the hormones within your body.

接受激素治療後，體內的激素會發生變化。

Is it classified as females they should be able to compete against females?

它們是否被歸類為女性，應該能夠與女性競爭？

Women should compete against women and transgenders should compete against transgenders.

婦女應該與婦女競爭，變性人應該與變性人競爭。

Was it fair for a male to do the female PT test?

由男性進行女性 PT 測試是否公平？

婦女的 PT，就像一個較低的標準？

Significantly lower because a female can only do so much.

大大降低，因為女性只能做這麼多。

I do play men's volleyball though, collegiately.

不過，我在大學裡打的是男子排球。

But before we continue, I hope Dan Weil is not the only one confused.

但在我們繼續之前，我希望丹-威爾不是唯一一個感到困惑的人。

I hope you don't mind me asking, but were you born a biological male?

我希望你不介意我這麼問，但你生來就是男性嗎？

I'm non-binary, so I can be female as a gender and my sex can be male.

我是非二元性別，所以我的性別可以是女性，也可以是男性。

Monday and Friday, definitely see her at my job.

週一和週五，肯定會在我工作的地方見到她。

On this channel, we explore the unfamiliar.

在這個頻道中，我們探索陌生的事物。

It gives us only through genuine conversations that we can change our perspective.

只有通過真誠的對話，我們才能改變自己的觀點。

But will people be too afraid to speak their truth?

但是，人們會害怕說出自己的真實想法嗎？

And with all the controversy, will I be demonetized or even worse, canceled like Chappelle?

面對如此多的爭議，我是否會像查普爾一樣被 "妖魔化"，甚至被取消資格？

Ain't no one canceling you with no subscriber had asked.

沒人會在沒有用戶要求的情況下取消你的服務。

Just somebody who feels comfortable within femininity.

只是一個在女性氣質中感到自在的人。

I don't even want to say femininity because he goes beyond that.

我甚至不想說女性氣質，因為他超越了女性氣質。

Kind of actually take that weird Jordan Peterson type stuff.

有點像喬丹-彼得森那種奇怪的人。

And actually affect that towards like gender.

實際上，這也會影響到性別等方面。

Maybe let's take like a recent controversial issue like abortion.

也許我們可以拿最近一個有爭議的問題，比如墮胎。

Heard women say, hey, no one should be making laws about us.

聽到婦女們說，嘿，沒有人應該為我們制定法律。

In that instance, it seems like a woman is someone who is able to have a baby.

在這種情況下，女人似乎就是能生孩子的人。

Does that constitute a woman or would you still stick with your definition?

這算不算女人，還是你仍然堅持你的定義？

I feel like there's so many other parts that are so much more important than just that.

我覺得還有很多比這更重要的部分。

But if you have like the long hair, if you have the nails.

但是，如果你有一頭長髮，如果你有指甲。

So I think those are pretty big differences, right?

是以，我認為這些差異很大，對嗎？

But if I identified as a woman, would that make me a woman?

但如果我認定自己是女人，那我就成了女人嗎？

Is there any scientific definitions or is it just the words become true?

是否有科學的定義，或者只是 "言之成理"？

So no one just wakes up and is like, oh, I feel like being a woman.

所以，沒有人會一覺醒來就覺得，哦，我覺得自己是個女人了。

There are tons of thoughts, decisions, and even social repercussions.

有數不清的想法、決定，甚至社會反響。

Like this entire line of questioning that come with coming out as a woman.

就像女性出櫃後的一系列問題一樣。

But wouldn't that be kind of ignoring some sort of biological, I don't know, realities?

但是，這樣做是不是有點忽視了某種生物，我不知道，現實？

I think that everybody has their own biological reality.

我認為，每個人都有自己的生理現實。

And that's how the world has always worked.

But this world is changing every fucking day.

但這個世界每天都在發生變化。

And you just got to keep up with the new time.

You identify as straight and you identify as a male?

你認為自己是異性戀者，你認為自己是男性？

So not everybody's going to follow what your path is.

所以，不是每個人都會走你的路。

And sometimes we just weren't born with that knowledge because we didn't get taught that as children.

有時，我們生來就不具備這種知識，因為我們在孩提時代沒有接受過這方面的教育。

Why has it changed over the last few years?

Whatever makes someone feel better at night and doesn't hurt somebody else,

只要能讓人晚上好受些，又不傷害別人，就可以了、

我認為這對任何人都無關緊要。

In your mind, do you think there are more than two genders?

在你心目中，是否認為性別不止兩種？

I couldn't identify them all for you, but...

So if I'm growing up, I don't know if I'm a man or a woman.

所以，如果我長大了，我不知道自己是男人還是女人。

Again, I think I decided that I'm an alien.

我想我又一次認定自己是外星人了。

If you don't accept that I'm an alien, then you're wrong.

如果你不承認我是外星人，那你就錯了。

And that just doesn't make logical sense.

字幕列表影片播放

變性運動員是否擁有不公平的優勢？ (Do Trans Athletes Have An Unfair Advantage?)

stuff

weird

sort

approach