Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • This is where the FIFA World Cup final will soon be held...

  • the Lusail Stadium in Qatar.

  • In just four years, it went from this...

  • to this.

  • It has 80,000 seats...

  • and cost more than $700 million to build.

  • It's the biggest stadium in the Middle East.

  • But it's more than that.

  • Over a decade ago, Qatar had hoped

  • that hosting a mega sporting event in stadiums like these

  • would put it on the map.

  • But today, stadiums like Lusail are a symbol

  • of how a country can build grand infrastructure

  • to further its own interests

  • and how those ambitions can trap thousands.

  • "...migrant workers lost their lives in the construction of the stadiums..."

  • "...forced to labor under extremely poor conditions..."

  • "Migrants working on infrastructure projects have died or suffered abuse."

  • "The logical source of oil for Europe is the Middle East..."

  • Since the 1940s, when Qatar discovered huge reserves of oil and then gas

  • it's been one of the richest countries on Earth.

  • 70% of the government's revenue comes from oil and gas exports.

  • Thanks to all that wealth

  • Qatar has gone through a remarkable transformation.

  • The capital, Doha, for instance, went from fishing town...

  • to world class city in just a couple of decades

  • complete with extraordinary museums and fancy hotels.

  • But in recent years, the world has been turning to renewable energy

  • making the oil and gas market Qatar relies on

  • even less dependable.

  • And in the Gulf, the country has seen regional tensions surge

  • most notably in 2017, when neighboring countries

  • issued a blockade against Qatar...

  • cutting off trade and travel.

  • It cost the country hundreds of millions of dollars.

  • So to diversify and protect its economy...

  • Qatar has started leaning into another area

  • that helped establish its status as a wealthy nation...

  • sports.

  • That repositioning is based on soft power.

  • Qatar is trying to secure friends when in need.

  • Particularly powerful friends from the West

  • like the United States and the UK.

  • And so the best way to do that

  • is through these soft sectors like sports.

  • In the last 18 years, Qatar has held more than 20 major sporting events.

  • But nothing compares to the 2022 World Cup.

  • "The winner is... Qatar."

  • Qatar won the rights to host the World Cup in 2010.

  • "Today we celebrate, but tomorrow...

  • the work begins."

  • It had made an unbeatable promise to FIFA.

  • It would spend more money

  • than any host had ever done before.

  • $200 billion.

  • And it delivered.

  • Since then, Qatar has built up 8 stadiums.

  • It's built dozens of hotels and laid down miles of roads

  • and metro lines to connect all that infrastructure.

  • They've even completed a whole new city

  • with golf courses, marinas, and a theme park.

  • It can brag that it is the first Middle Eastern country

  • that's ever hosted a mega sporting event.

  • To be able to do that

  • you have a lot of partners, including FIFA itself

  • and all the celebrity ambassadors who are vouching for Qatar

  • having these incredible world class stadiums, these glowing, glistening hotels.

  • You can come to Doha and feel secure

  • that you're experiencing a world that's business savvy

  • that's modern and advanced.

  • While the spotlight was supposed to show Qatar

  • as a shining example of development...

  • it also exposed one of its darkest secrets.

  • To power decades of development

  • Qatar has relied on a constant supply of temporary, low paid workers

  • mainly from South Asia and East Africa.

  • Since the early 2000s, so many foreigners have come to work in Qatar

  • they now make up 80% of the total population.

  • They build, clean, serve, and staff pretty much every industry.

  • When we think about how migrant workers recruitment journey commences

  • we think about workers who are

  • in extremely low wage situations.

  • So they are looking for a place where they can emigrate...

  • to allow them some upward socioeconomic mobility.

  • And Qatar promises them that mobility.

  • Typically, Qatari companies hire international recruitment agencies

  • that find workers to send over.

  • They promise these workers well-paying jobs

  • in exchange for illegal recruitment fees upfront.

  • They also have the workers pay for medical tests

  • passports, flights, the visa...

  • all to get the job contract.

  • The workers often take out loans in their home countries

  • to pay the agencies incurring significant debt.

  • It's a huge transnational...

  • cross-border operation...

  • which completely screws workers at the start of their journey.

  • Workers often use their family's savings to pay for a job

  • in one of the richest countries per capita in the world.

  • They arrive in Qatar often to find

  • they're not getting the job and salary promised

  • and can't do anything about it...

  • because they've now entered the country's kafala system.

  • It's a uniquely restrictive immigration system

  • that can take different forms in different industries.

  • But they all have one crucial thing in common.

  • Kafala legally ties the immigrant's immigration status

  • to their employer.

  • Meaning an individual employer

  • has to sponsor their worker

  • which gives them an inordinate amount of power over them.

  • They can control when their employees job ends

  • or if they can change jobs.

  • They can control if and when migrants leave the country.

  • Often by confiscating their passports.

  • And they can also control the worker's ability

  • to renew their residency and work permit.

  • But beyond the restrictions on a migrant's freedom of movement

  • the system also traps them in a cycle of abuse.

  • And that became evident when Qatar started preparing for the World Cup.

  • To deliver on the infrastructure Qatar promised

  • it tapped into its migrant pipeline

  • and recruited hundreds of thousands of new workers.

  • When Qatar was awarded the World Cup in 2010...

  • all of the people involved in decision making

  • knew that the World Cup would be built

  • based on the kafala system.

  • Thousands of migrants turned into construction workers

  • to build stadiums like Lusail

  • which became the site for human rights abuses

  • that ranged from verbal abuse to death.

  • Several investigations into Qatar's stadiums

  • revealed that employers usually house workers

  • in private camps far from city centers...

  • where they are forced to live in overcrowded rooms

  • and unsanitary conditions.

  • And at work, their lives are put at risk.

  • Migrant workers are often given the most dangerous jobs on the site

  • and can be forced to work up to 14 hour days

  • in Qatar's extreme heat.

  • The day this photo of the Lusail stadium was taken

  • the high in Doha reached 109 degrees Fahrenheit.

  • They have spent so many hours in the blistering sun...

  • and after that they only permitted

  • a five minute break to eat

  • and they eat standing and then go back.

  • Whenever you're also up on a scaffolding, coming down for a bathroom break

  • might get you in trouble with your boss.

  • And so you end up drinking less water

  • despite the need to have it

  • to avoid heat exhaustion.

  • The number of work-related migrant deaths

  • surrounding stadiums remains unclear

  • due to Qatar's lack of transparency.

  • In fact, that's the case for the entire kafala system.

  • But there have been some clues along the way.

  • The death certificates Nepal has received

  • with the bodies sent back from Qatar

  • show that nearly 120 Nepalese migrants

  • have died on the job since 2008.

  • The real number, though, is likely much higher.

  • In 2019, a study examined the link between Nepalese worker deaths

  • and heat exposure and concluded heatstroke

  • was a likely cause of cardiovascular deaths.

  • That alone could raise the number of just Nepali migrant worker deaths

  • to about 600.

  • In addition to living and working in abusive conditions

  • many are also not getting paid for their work.

  • Workers have repeatedly faced wage theft.

  • So then the debt keeps racking up

  • because the debt still exists and in many cases

  • workers have still not been able to survive on a daily basis.

  • This is one of the richest countries in the world

  • and yet they haven't been able to accelerate

  • its reforms and ensuring people have been paid on time.

  • Some workers try to file complaints, only to find

  • there are few effective mechanisms in place.

  • And speaking out comes with risk of retaliation...

  • which has kept migrants isolated in the kafala system

  • with increasing debt and unable to access justice.

  • After years of mounting pressure

  • from human rights organizations and a formal complaint

  • that reached the UN's International Labor Organization...

  • in 2017, Qatar signed an agreement

  • promising to align its laws and labor practices

  • to international standards.

  • In 2020, 10 years after construction for the World Cup began

  • Qatar implemented a minimum wage for workers

  • and now allows them to terminate

  • their employment contract.

  • But...

  • The challenge with the minimum wage laws is enforcement.

  • Employers started pushing back against the government.

  • And so even though we haven't seen amendments to the legislation.

  • Indeed, we're seeing a watering down of reforms.

  • And for the migrants who have already been abused to the kafala system.

  • This is all too late.

  • Civil rights groups and football associations

  • are now calling for a remedy fund

  • to compensate the migrant workers financially.

  • And some teams have taken a stand in the field...

  • and on social media.

  • "We have learned that the decision

  • to host the World Cup in Qatar

  • which resulted in the suffering

  • and harm of countless of our fellow workers..."

  • Making this year's World Cup

  • a particularly difficult one to watch.

  • Millions of football fans

  • will still tune in and cheer for their favorite teams.

  • But after that final match is over...

  • and the trophy is awarded...

  • stadiums like Lusail will continue to be a grim reminder

  • that it all came at a human cost.

This is where the FIFA World Cup final will soon be held...

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級

How Qatar built stadiums with forced labor

  • 3 0
    林宜悉 發佈於 2022 年 11 月 24 日
影片單字