字幕列表 影片播放 由 AI 自動生成 列印所有字幕 列印翻譯字幕 列印英文字幕 We're surrounded by statistical claims, 我們被統計學上的主張所包圍。 whether it's a striking graph going viral on social media, 無論是在社交媒體上瘋傳的引人注目的圖表。 a politician claiming that life has gotten 62% better 一位政治家聲稱生活已經好了62%。 while they've been in office, 當他們在任時。 or just something everyday, like a piece of economic data, 或者只是一些日常的東西,比如一個經濟數據。 the numbers are everywhere. 這些數字無處不在。 So what should we think about them? 那麼,我們應該如何看待他們呢? Here's one approach - 這裡有一個方法-- don't trust any of them. 不相信他們中的任何一個。 Mutter something about 喃喃自語,說什麼 lies, damned lies and statistics. 謊言、該死的謊言和統計數據。 Or joke that 98% of statistics are made up on the spot. 或者開玩笑說,98%的統計數據是當場編造的。 That seems smart. 這似乎很聰明。 After all, nobody likes to be taken for a fool. 畢竟,沒有人喜歡被當做傻瓜。 But we can't just reject all statistics equally. 但我們不能一視同仁地拒絕所有的統計數據。 Statistics can show us things about the world 統計數據可以向我們展示關於世界的東西 that we can't perceive in any other way. 我們無法以任何其他方式感知的。 Instead, we have to exert a bit of brain power 相反,我們必鬚髮揮一點腦力的作用 to figure out what is true and what is not. 以弄清什麼是真的,什麼是假的。 That sounds hard, but perhaps it's not as hard as you might think. 這聽起來很難,但也許並不像你想象的那麼難。 So here are three easy rules 是以,這裡有三個簡單的規則 to make statistics add up - 以使統計數字相加 - the three Cs of data wisdom. 數據智慧的三個C。 First, be calm. 首先,要冷靜。 Most statistics come packaged up with emotional baggage. 大多數統計數據都被包裝成了情感包袱。 They're supposed to make us angry or joyful or afraid. 它們應該讓我們憤怒、喜悅或恐懼。 Staggering deficits, shocking rates of crime, 驚人的赤字,令人震驚的犯罪率。 inspiring sums raised for good causes. 為公益事業籌集的資金令人鼓舞。 These emotions are why numbers go viral on social media, 這些情緒是數字在社交媒體上走紅的原因。 the reason they end up in the headlines. 他們最終出現在頭條新聞中的原因。 There's nothing wrong with feeling emotions, 感受情緒並沒有錯。 but they don't help us think clearly. 但它們並不能幫助我們思考清楚。 So before you share a claim that has you hot under the collar, 是以,在你分享一個讓你熱血沸騰的主張之前。 take a moment to notice your instinctive reaction - 花點時間注意你的本能反應------。 from rage, to denial, to vindication. 從憤怒,到否認,到平反。 Once you've noticed it, look at the statistic again. 一旦你注意到這一點,再看看這個統計數字。 It may seem different now. 現在看來可能有所不同。 Second, get context. 第二,瞭解背景。 For example, when the UK Health Secretary said in 2020 例如,當英國衛生部長在2020年表示 that the NHS would save £100 million over five years 國家醫療服務系統將在五年內節省1億英鎊。 if everyone who was overweight lost a few pounds. 如果每個超重的人都減掉幾磅。 What should we make of that claim? 我們應該如何看待這種說法? What does he mean by overweight, for example? 例如,他所說的超重是什麼意思? And what evidence does he have to support this claim? 他又有什麼證據來支持這一說法? But the most important piece of context 但最重要的一塊背景是 is simply to understand whether £100 million is a big number. 是簡單地瞭解1億英鎊是否是一個大數字。 It sounds big. 這聽起來很大。 But there are 67 million people in the UK, 但英國有6700萬人口。 so £100 million is just £1.50 each. 是以,1億英鎊只是每個人1.5英鎊。 You can figure that out on your phone. 你可以在你的手機上計算出來。 Now remember that £1.50 each 現在記住,每個人1.5英鎊 was spread across five years. 分佈在五年內。 So that's 30 pence 所以那是30便士 per person, per year. 每人每年。 The Health Secretary then said 衛生部長接著說 that if every overweight person lost some weight, 如果每個超重的人都減輕一些體重。 the NHS would save the equivalent of 30 pence per UK resident per year. NHS將為每個英國居民每年節省相當於30便士的費用。 Not a lot. 不是很多。 Statistics can be a very complex subject, 統計學可能是一個非常複雜的學科。 but you can get a long way with simple questions about context. 但你可以通過有關背景的簡單問題走很遠的路。 What's being measured here? 這裡測量的是什麼? Is it going up or going down? 它是上升還是下降? Is it big or small? 它是大還是小? What's the source of the claim? 該說法的來源是什麼? You don't need a lot of fancy maths, just a search engine, 你不需要很多花哨的數學知識,只需要一個搜索引擎。 the back of an envelope, and a curious mind. 一個信封的背面,以及一顆好奇的心。 Which brings me to the third important principle - be curious. 這使我想到第三個重要原則--要有好奇心。 When we use a number as a weapon in an argument, 當我們在爭論中使用一個數字作為武器時。 or a prop for our preconceptions, 或者說是我們先入為主的一個道具。 we learn nothing. 我們什麼也沒學到。 Instead we should think about statistics 相反,我們應該思考統計學問題 as a tool to understand the world, 作為了解世界的一個工具。 like a telescope for an astronomer. 就像天文學家的望遠鏡。 Ask yourself what a statistical claim 捫心自問,統計學上的主張是什麼? is really telling you about the world 是真正告訴你這個世界 and what questions it inspires. 以及它激發了什麼問題。 Of course we don't have time to do all this for every claim we see, 當然,我們沒有時間為我們看到的每一項索賠做這一切。 so a final habit is to ask yourself whether the source 是以,最後的習慣是問自己:來源是什麼? of a statistical claim is respecting the three Cs. 統計學上的主張是尊重三個C的。 A good journalist will help you be calm, will give you context, 一個好的記者會幫助你冷靜,會給你提供背景。 and will feed your curiosity. 並將滿足你的好奇心。 A viral 'gotcha' circulating on Twitter or WhatsApp 在Twitter或WhatsApp上流傳的病毒性 "騙局"。 will often do the opposite. 往往會起到相反的作用。 We shouldn't just accept statistics unthinkingly, 我們不應該只是不假思索地接受統計數據。 but neither should we dismiss them without thinking either. 但我們也不應該不假思索地否定它們。 Three simple habits - be calm, get context, and be curious - 三個簡單的習慣--冷靜、瞭解背景和好奇心 can help the world add up. 可以幫助世界加起來。
B1 中級 中文 統計 數據 超重 數字 主張 背景 什麼時候可以相信統計數據?| BBC思想 (When can you trust statistics? | BBC Ideas) 38 0 Summer 發佈於 2021 年 06 月 17 日 更多分享 分享 收藏 回報 影片單字