Hehasflown a hammerheadrolein a carbonfibrestuntplane.
Piloted a mahoganyracingsailboataroundAlcatrazIsland, exploredinArizonaMeteoritecraterwith a groupofastronauts, built a NativeAmericanlonghouseontheupperfloorofhisTorontohomeandbeeninductedintothecoastalPacificclock.
Walk a walkTribeMalcolmGladwelldiscussedpsychologywithhimwhileresearchinghisbooks.
NormanDeutschis a goodfriendandcollaborator.
ThrillerwriterGregHurwitzemployedseveralofhisquotevaluablethingsas a plotfeatureinhisnumberoneinternationalbestseller, Orphan X, andheworkedwithJimBalsillie, former R.
I M CEO, on a projectforthe U.
N secretarygeneralwithhisstudentsandcolleagues, DrPetersonhaspublishedmorethan 100 scientificpaperstransformingthemodernunderstandingofpersonalityandrevolutionizedthepsychologyofreligionwithhisnowclassicbookMapsofMeaning.
TheArchitectureofBelief.
As a Harvardprofessor, hewasnominatedfortheprestigiousLevinsonTeachingPrizeandisregardedbyhiscurrentUniversityofTorontostudentsasoneofthreetrulylifechangingteachers.
DrPetersonis a coreofmostviewedwriterandvaluesandprinciplesandparentingandeducation.
Um, duringthe q and a sessionwhenyouwerehanded a microphone, Pleasespeakdirectlyintoit.
OurviewersonYouTubewillappreciateit.
Andfinally, I am a moderatorbetweenProfessorPetersonandtheaudience, butalso a biasedparticipantinthisconversation.
Okay, well, it's a reliefthat's allover.
Okay, so, um, I thoughtwewouldstartthingsoffwiththis.
I assumethatmanyintheaudiencearecuriousbutrelativelyunfamiliarwithyou, orhaveheard a lotaboutyouwithouteverreadingorlisteningtoyou.
So I thoughtwemightstartwithyouintroducingyourselftotheaudienceandmaybetellingthemsomeofthemainthingsthatyouthinktheymightbeinterestedinknowingaboutyou.
Well, I guessthemostrelevantdetailisthat I spentabout 15 yearswritingthisand I workedonitaboutthreehours a day, everydayduringthatperiodoftime.
Um, atatthesametime I wasfinishingoffmydoctorand I startedlecturingatHarvard, but I wasdoingthatcontinuallyandthinkingaboutitcontinuallyandreadingthematerialthat I neededtoreadinordertowritethebookcontinuallyaswell.
I didn't realizeuntilmorerecentlythatwhat I wasdoingwasattheheartofthepostmodernconundrum.
I wouldsay I wasverymuchobsessedbytheeventsoftheColdWar.
Forreasons I don't exactlyunderstand.
I had a lotofdreamsaboutnuclearannihilationforyearsonend.
Itwasn't thatuncommontobeobsessedbythatwhen I grewup.
I mean, becauseitwas a preoccupationofeveryonewhowasmyage.
I supposetheretherewerelotsofyears, probablybetween 1962 I wouldsay, probablyin 1985 wherepeoplewereprettyconvincedthattheprobabilityof a nuclearwarwashigh, muchhighernowthanpeopleconsidered.
Now, Um, and I wascuriousaboutthis.
I wascuriousaboutwhyeveryonewasn't obsessedaboutthisallthetime.
I couldn't understandhowanybodycouldconcentrateonanythingotherthanthat, sinceitseemssoutterlyinsane.
Um, and I wascuriouswhatwasgoingonexactlywasthisone, Nick.
Theexplanationwasthatthere's a verylargenumberofwaysthathumanbeingscouldorganizethemselvesinsocietylike a largenumberofgamesthatwecouldhypotheticallyplay.
Andsothat's what I wastryingtofigureoutwaswhatthehellwasgoingonwiththisconflictAndwasitmerely a battlebetweentwohypothetically, equallyvalidinterpretationsoftheworld, drawnfrom a setofextraordinary, largepotentialinterpretations, which I thinkwouldbeessentially a postmodernisttakeonit?
And I think I wentintotheproblemneutrallyinthat I didn't think I knewwhattheanswerWaas.
Butit's not a goodwaytowrite a goodwaytowriteandthinkit's have a problemandthentrytosolveitrighttoactuallysolveit, nottodemonstratethatyou're a prioricommitmentistrue.
Andyouknow, oneofthesigns I wouldsaythatmy a prioricommitmentsweren't thepurposeforthewritingwasthat I walkedawayfromthat 15 yearprojectwith a viewoftheworldthatwascompletelydifferentthantheviewthat I hadgoinginandlearnedallsortsofthings, especiallyabouttheroleofnarrativeandandreligiousthinkinginlife.
That I havenoideawaspossiblewhen I started.
And a lotofthatwas a consequenceofreadingthegreatpeoplewho I readdeeply.
Youknow, I readwell, allthegreatworksofFriedrichNietzscheinthegreatworksofDostoyevskyandTolstoy, andmostofyouguyscollectedworks, everythingthathadbeenpublisheduptothatpoint, and a verylargeswathoftherelevantclinicalliterature, thegreatcliniciansofthe 20thcenturyand a hugestackofneuroscienceandetcetera, etcetera.
Because I wasreadingconstantlyduringthistime.
And, um, I realizedsomethingsthat I thinkaretrue.
TheCommunistswerewrong.
Theyweren't andnotjust a littlebitwrongandnotwronginsomearbitraryway.
Theywereplaying a gamethathumanbeingscannotplaywithoutdescendinginto a murderouscatastrophe.
And I don't knowwhatthatmightmeanmetaphysically, becausewhothehellknowswhatanythingmeans?
Metaphysically, right?
I mean, youryourknowledgerunsoutatsomepoint.
Anyways, I workedalltheseideasout, andthen I taughtfor a longtimecoursesthatwerebasedontheideasandthecourseswereveryimpactful.
I wouldsaytheyhavethesameimpactonthepeoplethat I wasteachingaswalkingthroughthematerialhadonmeandwell, itwasoutofthatthatallofthispoliticalcontroversyarose.
I mean, I wasneverfocusedonpoliticalcontroversy, eventhough I'm interestedinpolitics, and I thoughtitmanypointsinmylifeabout a politicalcareer.
I alwaysputitasidefor a psychologicalandphilosophicalcareer, I wouldsay, andbutButthingsstartedtoshiftbadlyinCanadaoverthelastfiveyears, andourgovernmentdaredtoimplementlegislationthatcompelledspeech.
Andoneofthethingsthat I hadlearnedwhen I wasdoingallthisbackgroundinvestigationwasthatthereisn't a highervaluethanfreespeech.
And I wasjustnotwillingtoputupwithrestrictionsonmyfreelife.
Andso I madesomevideospointingoutthepathologyofthisdoctrineandthefactthatthegovernmenthadradicallyoverreached.
It's it's appropriatelimitsandwell, then, youknow, Well, maybeyoudon't know, but I'vebeenenvelopedincontinualscandalsincefor 18 monthsas a consequence, whichtomeas a clinicianindicatesthat I gotmydamndiagnosis, right?
Right.
It's notaboutpronouns.
It's aboutsomething a lotdeeperthanthat.
And I standbythat.
I believethatit's thecase.
And I don't thinkthatwewouldallbeheretonightifthatwasn't thesituation.
SoSo I wantedmyfirstormynextquestion, um, tobeaboutLafayette.
Andso I thought I wouldread a coupleofFacebookpoststhatcertainstudentswhoarecriticalofyoureadintheleaduptothiseventandjustaskyoutorespondtothem.
Ifyoubelievethismanis a legitimatesourceofknowledgebecausehehas a degreeinclinicalpsychologyfuelfreetoaskourpsychologydepartmentfacultyandcounselingcenterstaffaboutthevalidityofhisclaims.
I'm certaintheywouldnotendorsethisspeaker.
Dobetterinallcaps.
ForthoseofyouunfamiliarJordanPetersonisknownfordenouncingthemetomovement, claimingthatwomenareinnowaymarginalizedintheWest, arguingagainsttheexistenceofgenderneutralpronouns, arguingagainstguncontrolinthe U.
S.
Andclaimingthatidentity, politicsandsocialjusticemovementsarepartof a deviousMarxistagenda.
Andthenanotherstudentresponded.
AndthisisbrieferCollege.
Conservativesknowthatiftheybringin a speakerwhowaswillingtoblatantlyinsult a portionoftheaudienceandthelivesgetangryenoughaboutthisforgoodreason, thentheymaygetanopedwrittenabouttheminTheNewYorkTimes.
As a result, thereare a wholegroupofhackslikeMiloandPeterson, whogetfamousandinvitedpurelyfortheirpromisetomissgendertransstudentsandadvocateprovocativebutultimatelytoothlessargumentsaboutsocialDarwinistracetheory.
What I'm sayingisthatyouhaveeveryrighttobepissedJordanPetersonis, Ah, harmfulmoron, butnothebutknowthatyoubeingpissedisalso 100% atthepointofwhyhewasinvited.
He's not a conservative.
He's just a guywho's mildlyracistenoughtooffendcollegeliberalsandthereforesecurewindsfortheculturalright, comparativelymildstuff.
Youknow, like I'vehadthousandsofconversationswithpeoplebecause I'vespent 20 yearsas a clinicalpsychologist, andoneofthethings I'velearnedaboutpeopleisthatthereareunbelievablyinteresting.
And I learnedthismostlyfromfromAlexanderSolzhenitsyn.
Inhisdetailedanalysisofwhat I wouldcallideologicalpossession I talkedto, hetalkedaboutpeoplehemetinthegulagcampswhowereundertheswayofofrigidcommunistorthodoxyandnotedveryclearlythatitwasliketherewas a crankinsomesenseonthesideoftheirheadandyoucouldjustcrankthecrankandoutwouldcometheideologicaldogma, andit's allentirelypredictable, andpeoplewhoarein a situationlikethatdon't understandthatthey'repossessedbyanidearightsCarlYoungsaid.
Andtocloseonthat, I wouldalsosaytothepeopleonthemoderateleft, Ifyouwantyourdoctrinestohavepurchaseandtocontinuetospeakfortheforthosewhostackupatthebottomofinevitablehierarchies, thenyouoweittoyourselftodisassociateyourselffromthedangerousradicalsbecauseotherwisetheyinvalidateyourideas.
Ontheotherhand, andthisisjust a facttonsofpeopleontheleft, aswe'vejustseenbecauseofyourpowerandalsoyourfrontalattackon a lotoftheirviews, hateyouandviciouslycaricatureyou.
Well, I meanwithheight, forexample, withmorepowertohim.
Asfaras I'm concerned, youknow, hehehas a differenttemperamentthanme.
He's he's moreintroverted.
He's lessvolatile.
I wouldsayhe's probablymoreagreeableormorepoliteanyways.
And I thinkthatwhathe's doingisextremelyeffective, especiallyfromtheperspectiveofverycarefullydocumentingtheempiricalfactsaboutthetheideologicalwhattheideological, theincreasinglyleftleaningideologicaltiltofcampuses, whichissomethingthatneedstobeexploredonempiricalground.
So, umso, like I said, morepowertohimandthere's nothingwrongwithbeingreasonable, I guess.
Whathappenedwhen I mademyinitialvideoswasthat, youknow, I had I hadspoke.
I talkedtopeople a lot.
I'veworkedwithpeople a lotaboutnegotiation.
It's oneofthethingsthat I specializedin.
I wouldsayinmyclinicalandconsultingpracticewasteachingpeoplehowtonegotiate, and I couldtellyousomethingsaboutnegotiatingthatyoumightfindinterestinganduseful.
Thefirstisyoucan't negotiatefrom a positionofweakness, soallofyouwhoaregoingtobedevelopingyourcareer's inthefuture.
Andsoifyouwanttodevelopyourcareerintermsofpromotion, say, andsalaryislike, youhavetobeconfidentandyouhavetobestrategicandtobestrategicwhenyounegotiatefor a newpositionorfor a newsalary, youhavetobeabletosay, Ifyoudon't givemewhat I want, thensomethingyoudon't likewillhappentoyouandwhatthatmeans.
It's not a physicalthreat.
It's it's thatyouhaveanoption, youknow.
SoyouhaveyourCV, yourresumeandorder, right.
You'reeducatedandcompetentanddesirabletopeople.
Outsideofyourimmediatejob, you'rewillingtoinstantlyputyourselfoninthejobmarketandundergothestressoffinding a newpositionandundergoinginterviewsandallofthat.
Youknow, you'relookingat 1/4 of a 1,000,000,000 deathslike, isn't thatenough?
Well, thepeoplethat I readwhowereprofoundVictorFrankelis a goodexampleforbeginnersifyouwanttoreadaboutthissortofthing.
Youwrote a bookcalledMan's SearchforMeaningandFrankel, andalsosoldunitsandin a varietyofothercommentatorsaswell, whoreallylookedintowhathappenedinininbothofNaziGermanyandandintheinthecommuniststates?
Thesortofpeoplethatyouknow, twoguyswhoweretakingnakedpregnantwomenoutintothemiddleoffieldsandshootingtheminthebackoftheheadandthedocumentsonestepat a time.
Andifyou'renotgonnabethatsortofperson, thenyoudon't takethefirststepsbecausethefirststepsleadyoudown a pathwaythat, atleastinprinciple, youdon't wanttogo.
Sowhile I thinkpartofwhatmakesmecombativesay, comparedtosomeonelikeheightisthat I spentyearslookingattheworstthingstherearetolookatand I'velearnedfromthatand I'velearned, certainlylearnedthingsthat I won't doandoneofthemiss I won't letthegovernmentregulatemyspeech.
It's a mistake.
I don't carewhatcompassionateprincipleshypotheticallymotivatethatmove.
So I havereasons, I think, otherthanthosethatmotivatesomeonelikeJonathanHeighttobeparticularlypassionateaboutthisissue.
Soonthesubjectoftotalitarianism, um, I wantedtodosomethingveryquickly.
So I'm guessingthateventhoughmostpeopleintheroomhavenegativeviewsofbothmen, theyhaveamore, intenselynegativeviewofHitlerthanofStalin.
I'm guessingalmosteveryoneintheroomhas a farmorenegative, visceralreactiontotheswastikathantothehammerandsickle.
SomeoftheprotestersatyoureventatMcMasterUniversitystoodbehind a bannerwith a hammerandsickle.
You'vesaidthat a hammerandsickleisnofunnierthan a swastikathatquotethereprehensible, thereprehensibleideologiesthatarebasedinfundamentalMarxismkilledatleast 100 millionpeopleinthe 20thcentury.
Well, I wouldsaythefirstthingisthatit's highlyprobablethatyouweretalkingtointellectuals.
Students.
Well, we'llcallthembuttingin.
It's itis a Itis a mystery.
Youknow, itis a mysterybecauseitisthecasethatthereissomethingabouttheNazidoctrinethatseemstohave a visceralimpactthatthattheCommunistDocdoctordoesn't have.
And I saidwhen I openedmyremarkstonightthatitmightbetheissueofracialsuperiority.
Butnowit's like, Well, thisiswhy I saidwhat I saidatthebeginning.
Fine, no, if I don't knowexactlyhowtomakethemoraldistinction.
Butit's a distinctionthathastobemade.
I thinkthatpeoplewhoapologizewhosaysomethinglike I think I thinkthatthatit's virtually I don't knowifit's asreprehensibletosaythatgivenethnicgroupshouldbeconsignedtothefireandtosaythatwasn't realcommunism, buttheirdamnclose.
Andwhen I hearsomeonesaythatwasn't realcommunism, I knowwhattheymean.
Whattheymeanwas, if I wasthedictatorinStellanShoes, I personallywouldhavebroughtintheutopia.
That's whatthatstatementmeans, andoritmeans a knignoranceofhistorythat's soutterlyappalling.
Thathuh, thatanypoliticalstatementmadeonbehalfofthatpersonwhatsoevershouldimmediatelybefollowedby a paroxysmofextremeembarrassment.
I just I justwanttobeclearthatthesestudentswereconcedingthattheydon't agreethattheyshareyourcritique.
Theydon't shareitenough.
Okay, fairenough.
I justwantedtomakethatclearsotheywouldmoreorlessagreewithwhatyoujustsaid.
I thinkabout, um, it's notokaytosaythoseregimesweren't propercommunismandthepropercommunismshouldbetried.
It's like, youknow, wehave a groupofofwellmeaningsocialistsinCanadawhojustproducedsomethingcalledLeapmanifesto a coupleofyearsago, andit's a prettyradical.
Like I workedfor a Socialistpartyforquite a whilewhen I was a kid.
Youknow, when I sawbothsidesofit, I sawsomevery, veryadmirablepeople.
I wasprivyfor, for a varietyofchancereasons, totheleadershipoftheSocialistPartyinCanada, attheprovincialandannouncedlevel, I metthepeoplewhorantheprovinces, someoftheprovincesandwhorantheparty.
And a lotofthemwerereallyadmirablepeople, likethey'd spenttheirwholelife, I wouldsay, workingonbehalfoftheworkingclass, youknow, Sothey'regenuinelaborleadersandandandAndtherewasalso a lotdoneinCanadaontheleft.
Lookslikeitwasactuallyprettygoodstandardworkweek.
Youknowthattheestablishmentofpensions, theintroductionofourhealthcaresystemwhich I wouldsayprobablyoverallworksbetterthantheAmericansystem, althoughnotattheupperend.
Andthere's a deafeningsilenceontheintellectualsideofthespectrumwithregardstowhathappenedontheegalitarianleft, andthere's noexcuseforit.
So, sosomewhatrelated.
Lee.
I thinkit's fairtosaythateventhoughyouhavecriticizedsegmentsofboththeleftSocialjusticewarriorsandtherightthealtarright, you'recriticalcommentaryoverthelastyearand 1/2 hasfocusedsignificantlyMaurontheleftthanontheright.
A lotofpeople I'vetalkedtohereatLafayetteatLafayettetakeissuewiththat, Theysaythatweresofarfrom a Marxisttakeoverofourcultureandpoliticalinstitutionsthat, tosuggestotherwiseistoengagein a classickindofrightwingexaggerationandhysteriathatwe'veseenbeforeinWesterncountries.
Intheearlytomid 20thcentury, Theyalsosay, andthisisimportanttothem, thatthenationalistauthoritarianrightposesmoreof a threattofreedomoftheindividualthantheleftdoestoday, asithasintheWestsincetheearly 20thcentury.
I suspecttosomedegree, that's a matterofhappenstance.
I mean, that's whatyou'd expectifyoulookedat 20thcenturyhistory, but I emergedoutoftheacademyandtheacademyliketherearen't rightwingpeopleintheacademynottospeakofthat's completelythat's thoroughlydocumented.
Andit's certainlynotthecasein a countrylikeCanada.
Ifyoureallyworkedatit, youknow, So I justdon't seethat, atleastinmyowncountry.
That's just a nonissue.
It's a nonstarter.
I mean, thelasttimetherewasanykindofradicalrightwingersinCanadawasprobablyinQuebecinthe 19 fiftiesandmaybefromthe 19 thirtiestothe 19 fifties.
Butit's neverbeen a politicalissue.
Whataboutthe F D?
OrtheItalian?
I can't rememberthenameoftheItalianparty, um, theNationalFrontinFrance.
Wherewouldyouput?
Wouldyou?
Oh, well, I mean, you'reinEurope.
It's more.
There's morepolarization, I wouldsay.
ButtheEuropeansalsohaveproblemsthatwedon't have, Youknow, they'vebean, they'vebeanstrugglingwiththeconsequencesofnonendingviolenceintheMiddleEastandthewaveofrefugeesthathasemergedas a consequenceofthat.
AndsothesituationinEuropeisdifferent.
And I wouldsaythereisMME.
Ormovementandactivityontheright.
So, butandyouknow, I'm not a admirersofidentitypoliticswhileandthat's forthereasons I broughtuptobeginwith, thinkthatyouhavetodecideconceptually, psychologically, familiarlyandsociallywhatyourvisionof a humanbeingis.
It's like, Well, I thinktheidentitypoliticstypesontheleftpose a biggerthreatinmycountry.
It's notsoobviousinyourcountrybecauseyouguys, yourpoliticallandscapeismorebalanced, I wouldsay, thanours.
Iftheradicalrightposed a threattotheacademy, whichtheymostdecidedlydonot, then I wouldbejustasupsetaboutthat, andso I thinkagainit's It's partandparceloftheradicalleft, failuretotakeortheleftsingeneral, failuretotakeresponsibilityfortheRadicals.
And I'vesaidthatmanytimesandinmylecturesto, andpeopleknowthis.
Ifthey'veactuallywatchedmyuniversitylectures, I spend a tremendousamountoftimeandhavefor 30 yearsconvincingmystudentsthatiftheyhadbeaninNaziGermany, therewas a veryhighprobabilitythatratherthanbeingOskarSchindlerandrescuingtheJews, theywouldhavebeen a Nazipersecutor.
Andso I wouldsuspectthatyou'reintheunbelievablydilutedcampbecausetrulyremarkablepeoplearerare.
And I'vereallyhavereallyseenthisinthelastyearortwobecauseoneofthethings I havenoted, like I knewthatpeopleweretimid, youknow, and I knewwhyit's dangeroustostickyourheadupabovetherest.
I mean, it's predatoravoidancestrategytokeepyourheaddown, and I meanthattechnically, ittrulyis.
Toblendinwiththecrowdis a predatoravoidancestrategy.
When I wenttoQueensUniversity a monthagoandwassubjecttothatchillingdemonstration, I wouldsaywheretheradicalsclimbedupintothestainedglasswindowwindowwellsandpounded, Youknow, unendinglyfor 90 minutes.
Whilewewereallinside, I had a professorrightbethedaybeforeandsay, Look, mywifeand I workattheuniversity, reallysupportwhatwhatyou'redoing, butwecan't evenriskcomingtothetalk, becausewhatifthestudentsseeandcomplaint?