This is CS50 on Twitch.

My name is Colton Ogden.

And I'm joined today by--

DAVID MALAN: I'm David Malan.

Nice to see everyone again, for real this time.

It's not just a pop-in.

I'm here the whole time.

COLTON OGDEN: The whole time, yeah.

This a very special appearance today.

What are we talking about today?

DAVID MALAN: So we thought we'd introduce render50,

which is a command line tool that CS50 uses internally,

and some of our high school teachers use as well, to turn source code into PDFs.

COLTON OGDEN: And what are some of the ways that you use this yourself?

DAVID MALAN: So over the years for CS50, especially

for our undergrads and our extension school students here and off campus,

we have typically given feedback, of course,

on students' code when they submit it for grades

and also for qualitative feedback.

And years ago, back in my day, so this is like late '90s,

the technology we used was paper.

And so literally, part of the process of submitting your homework, your CS50

problem sets, was literally print it out,

in addition to submitting the files, and we would have used big ASCII.

You print out a big sheet of paper and like Malan

would be printed in big M's and big A's and big L's all over the paper

to make clear to your teaching fellow whose it is.

And then he or she would write comments physically on the paper.

COLTON OGDEN: Is this also the era of the paper with holes

on the sides of it?

DAVID MALAN: Yes, dot matrix.

Actually, these were laser printers, but I think

those were still, for sure, around.

So that's obviously behind us now.

And so over the years, we transitioned to other techniques

where we would somehow generate PDFs out of students' code

and then use things like Adobe Acrobat, or Apple Preview, or Bluebeam PDF Revu

was another tool we used for some time.

So you could actually type the comments.

And actually, we went through a phase, thanks to some friends at Microsoft

a few years ago, where they kindly let all of our teaching Fellows

here on campus use tab--

they weren't called tablets yet--

what were they even called?

COLTON OGDEN: The like PalmPilots, like the--

DAVID MALAN: Touchscreens.

Well, they were the first laptops with touchscreens.

But I don't think they were called tablets yet.

I'm totally blanking now on the technology.

COLTON OGDEN: I don't remember either.

DAVID MALAN: So you could draw on the screen.

And this was marginally better, because then you

could circle things and be like good, or better, could be this, and so forth.

And just handwrite it as well.

And then most recently did we just write our own tool for generating the PDFs,

because then we can get them just right.

We can syntax highlight them.

We can do it automatically, programmatically.

And so thus was born render50, a tool that

just makes it super easy to render PDFs out of code.

And then also, unfortunately, to render files side

by side in cases of academic dishonesty.

If we suspect that a student has unduly copied someone else's work,

it's often helpful for folks on campus to go

to see their code in the GitHub repo or something else side by side.

So we use this same tool to do that.

So you can just very easily, especially if you're less technical,

look at the code on a PDF or a printout as opposed

to like a diff or GitHub or something like that.

COLTON OGDEN: Nice.

And another use case that, for example, to illustrate,

we're using it today here--

DAVID MALAN: Ironically, yes.

COLTON OGDEN: --for notes.

DAVID MALAN: This is very meta.

COLTON OGDEN: You probably won't be able to see it too well in the stream.

DAVID MALAN: This is my cheat sheet for today.

COLTON OGDEN: I've used it in prior streams

as well for code bases where I just want to have something

to look at as a reference, or in case I forget

how I wrote some function or something.

And you use it for lecture notes too.

DAVID MALAN: All the time.

Like literally every lecture and any stream where

I need some code to reference, just really as

a cheat sheet to remind myself so I'm not futzing with the computer too much.

I just run code through render50, get a nice pretty printed,

syntax highlighted, colorful PDF.

And then we just send it to a color printer.

And then do it old school like this.

COLTON OGDEN: Is this related at all to the old Annotate 50

that we were working on back in the day?

DAVID MALAN: This is like a simplistic version

of that where you rely on actual human hands for the annotations or existing

PDF tools.

We did have a tool in the past that was more digital,

but we've since deprecated that.

COLTON OGDEN: OK, cool.

Let's make sure that we're keeping up with the chat.

We have a lot of new names today that I saw.

DAVID MALAN: Sure, let's say hello.

[INTERPOSING VOICES]

COLTON OGDEN: So BELLA [INAUDIBLE] is a regular.

Hello, Bella, good to have you.

DROP4, VDHUG, again.

HASSAN-- the Twitch font on this sometimes is absurdly difficult to read

against the--

DAVID MALAN: It's very bright green.

COLTON OGDEN: I have it on light mode for some reason, but HASSAN [INAUDIBLE]

says hello.

DAVID MALAN: Hello.

COLTON OGDEN: Good to have you, Hassan.

I think that's the first time I've seen your name in the chat.

So Brenda, shout out to Brenda.

DAVID MALAN: Brenda, nice to see you.

Brenda tuning in, of course, from New Zealand,

one of our furthest away team members.

COLTON OGDEN: Good to have you, Brenda.

SHAMXR says good evening.

MATTHEWTHEGOODMAN.

DAVID MALAN: Montreal, nice.

COLTON OGDEN: In from Montreal.

So very good global representation.

DAVID MALAN: And Pakistan, the other direction.

Wow.

COLTON OGDEN: Yeah.

DAVID MALAN: Good night, nice to see you.

Thanks for tuning in before bed.

COLTON OGDEN: Yeah, awesome.

Some of the folks here are watching us like 4 or 5 o'clock in the morning.

DAVID MALAN: Yeah, well, it must be.

COLTON OGDEN: Which is awesome.

DAVID MALAN: Well, I'm up at that hour, too,

so we might as well just do the streams then too.

COLTON OGDEN: VDHUG acre in the middle of the Amazon forest, interesting.

DAVID MALAN: Wow, all right.

VDHUG, you're going to have to elaborate on that one and how that's working.

COLTON OGDEN: TWINTOWERPOWER, generic third quarter of the day

greeting from a country on one of the continents of earth.

Nice.

DAVID MALAN: OK, this is a puzzle, isn't it?

COLTON OGDEN: That's almost like a very political statement, like a very--

DAVID MALAN: Very generic, yes.

Hello, earthling.

COLTON OGDEN: Waves at folks from around the globe, says Brenda.

[INAUDIBLE] hello, everybody.

Hello, [INAUDIBLE], good to have you.

GARETHBUTLER2, hello.

That's a new name as well.

So many new names today.

POULTON1987, hello.

Hello, hello.

DAVID MALAN: Hello, everyone.

Yeah, the green really doesn't work very well.

COLTON OGDEN: Yeah, it's a little bit--

DAVID MALAN: [INAUDIBLE],, we've been chatting online too, often.

Nice to see you.

COLTON OGDEN: Yeah, yeah.

OK.

And VERONI, VERONI was here in yesterday's chat.

Hello, VERONI.

DAVID MALAN: Nice.

COLTON OGDEN: LITTLEJR, hello from Brazil.

[INAUDIBLE], hello.

Unspecified location from TJ.

And--

DAVID MALAN: This is great.

Siberia, Russia.

That's terrific.

Also far away, and pretty cold though.

Frankly, it's been pretty darn cold here lately.

COLTON OGDEN: Thankfully, today and yesterday not as bad.

We had that blizzard last weekend.

That was terrible.

That was horrible.

DAVID MALAN: Though I don't know if we'd compare it to Siberia.

COLTON OGDEN: Yeah, Siberia's pretty rough.

That's like a summer.

Or to them, that's like a summer.

But you know.

And then MADKINGVALLA says hoy.

DAVID MALAN: Nice.

Nice haircut.

Nice haircut comment.

COLTON OGDEN: I haven't gotten it yet.

Their joking.

I told them I was going to get my hair cut.

I think today I told them I was going to get my hair cut, but [INAUDIBLE]..

DAVID MALAN: All right, so I guess it's being sarcastic.

So not actually very nice.

COLTON OGDEN: No, it's not.

But it's OK.

It's very soon, I promise.

Actual promise.

OK, I think we're all caught up on the comments, so why don't we--

I'm going to transition to your laptop so you can start taking [INAUDIBLE]..

DAVID MALAN: OK, here we go.

COLTON OGDEN: Hopefully-- oh, is it the right size?

Everything good?

DAVID MALAN: Yeah, we can zoom in a little.

Folks want to see a little better.

COLTON OGDEN: Trying make sure that the actual editor--

this wasn't cutting off your screen.

DAVID MALAN: Nice.

I hope everyone enjoyed.

Does anyone have any questions about how the technology works,

any of the code that we've looked at, or where you can go from here?

COLTON OGDEN: This will be amazing when I re-splice it.

Sorry about that.

Facebook booted us.

It booted our server.

So we're cross-streaming right now to Twitch.

Were cross-streaming to Facebook and to YouTube.

Right now we're just to YouTube and to Twitch,

but it looks like Facebook kicked us for some reason.

So if you're watching, or were watching on Facebook, sorry about that.

DAVID MALAN: All right.

But hopefully, we're now back and we can dive in.

COLTON OGDEN: Yeah, let me just make sure that we--

people, if they had any questions before we started.

DAVID MALAN: Sure, yeah.

We were.

COLTON OGDEN: Looks like, no.

I guess we'll do one question from HASSAN.

Which language do you prefer between C and C++, before we begin?

DAVID MALAN: I'd say C. C++ certainly gets useful when you want to do

something object oriented, obviously, by definition.

I find it a little messy, though it's one of the earlier OO languages,

at least, that really was popularized for software development.

But it's also just a little messy syntactically.

It's kind of a pain, I think.

So nah, I never really loved it.

COLTON OGDEN: OK.

Cool, cool.

And then everybody in the stream, definitely

let us know whether or not you can still hear us,

whether or not everything looks good.

I'm going to refresh.

Looks like everything's live on our end, but let us know if you can hear us,

just as a sanity check for us too.

DAVID MALAN: All right, wonderful.

COLTON OGDEN: 100% now, so I think we're OK.

DAVID MALAN: All right, so if you'd like to play along in any way,

let me suggest you go to any of a couple of URLs.

We can paste them in here.

If you want to go to cs50.readthedocs.io/render50,