Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • - What am I going as for Halloween?

  • A nerd!

  • Don't ask surprised.

  • Pocahontas, if you've paid even a little attention

  • to the political world lately,

  • you know that's President Donald Trump's

  • preferred nickname for Elizabeth Warren,

  • the democratic senator from Massachusetts.

  • It's an admittedly crude reference

  • to her claim that she is of Native American descent

  • and Trump's somewhat fact-free response

  • that Warren claimed her status as a minority

  • to get ahead in the world of academia.

  • So why does any of this matter you ask.

  • Well, because Warren is running.

  • Mmm, should I say, considering running

  • for president in 2020 against,

  • you guessed it, Donald John Trump.

  • Which brings us to what Warren did recently,

  • out of the blue, she released a five plus minute video

  • in which she travels back to her hometown,

  • that's Norman Oklahoma,

  • to extensively trace her family tree.

  • The video is slickly produced and has all the hallmarks

  • of a video someone running for president,

  • or considering running for president.

  • (bell dings) Would make.

  • There's the folksy conversation

  • with Warren's extended family

  • about their hearth's gravel roots.

  • The shots of Warren doing normal people stuff,

  • you know, like walking and pointing at things

  • and repeated mentions of how Warren's mother

  • always told her family that she was

  • of Native American heritage.

  • And then comes the big reveal.

  • Warren, on the phone with renowned Stanford geneticist,

  • Carlos Bustamante, he's an advisor to 23andMe,

  • we've all heard of that, asked whether Trump is right,

  • or her mother is right and if she does in fact

  • have Native American ancestry.

  • Bustamante responds that.

  • - The facts suggest that you absoulutely

  • have a Native American ancestor in your pedigree.

  • - Which, if you ask me is not exactly definitive.

  • Think of it this way, if I go to the doctor for a physical

  • and at the end, when I ask them if I'm healthy,

  • he says, quote, the facts suggest

  • that you absolutely are healthy,

  • I'm feeling good, but I'm not feeling great, right?

  • I'd rather have heard, you are absolutely healthy!

  • You are going to live until you are 120 years old.

  • The word, suggest, from Bustamante throws a decent slice

  • of doubt into the proceedings.

  • The conclusion from Warren's DNA test.

  • A test Trump himself has routinely called on her to take

  • doesn't help her case all that much either.

  • She is, according to the best estimate

  • somewhere between 1/64 an 1/1,024 Native American.

  • 1/1,024!

  • That's 0.0097%, which is not a lot.

  • Now sidebar on the timing of all of this.

  • Warren's people say the results were released

  • soon after she got them, which, fine.

  • But of course, DNA tests measure one thing,

  • and we know ethnic identity is complex.

  • That's something that the Secretary of State

  • for the Cherokee Nation brought up

  • in his response to the whole thing, saying quote,

  • "Using a DNA test to lay claim to any connection

  • "to the Cherokee Nation or any tribal nation,

  • even vaguely, is inappropriate and wrong."

  • That's Chuck Hoskin Jr., he added,

  • "Senator Warren is undermining tribal interests

  • "with her continued claims of tribal heritage."

  • Ugh.

  • All of which leaves me wondering why did Warren

  • do this DNA thing at all?

  • Yes, of course, I get what she was trying to do.

  • She knew that Trump's Pocahontas attack

  • was doing her some damage among skiddish democrats

  • who don't wanna nominate someone in 2020

  • who has a gaping weakness that Trump,

  • the biggest bully on the block,

  • would and could exploit.

  • Warren wanted to show that she couldn't

  • and wouldn't be swift-boated.

  • What do I mean by that term?

  • Democrats are still bitter about the 2004 campaign

  • in which a number of men who had served

  • with Massachusetts Senator, John Kerry,

  • on swift-boats in Vietnam claimed

  • that he had badly exaggerated his acts of bravery

  • during the war.

  • Kerry was caught flat-footed by an attack

  • on what most people believe was his greatest strength,

  • his military service in Vietnam and really never recovered,

  • losing to George W. Bush.

  • So Warren wanted to tell democrats that she was ready

  • for Trump's attacks and had the facts 100% on her side.

  • That he would come at her, but she would punch back hard

  • and effectively.

  • She wanted to reassure them that there was no danger

  • that in nominating her, they could be risking their chances

  • of beating Trump, their last chance

  • at beating Trump in 2020.

  • Sidebar, democrats are also still haunted

  • by Hilary Clinton's loss to Trump in 2016.

  • A defeat they lay, at least in part,

  • at the feet of the fact that she simply had

  • too much baggage from past political fights

  • that he could and did exploit effectively.

  • All the while amazingly side-stepping the baggage

  • he had of his own.

  • The problem here is that Warren's video and DNA test

  • didn't tie things up in a nice bow for her or democrats.

  • Even the most favorable reading

  • of what Warren's DNA test showed

  • is that there's a high probability

  • that she has a tiny bit of Native American blood in her.

  • Now, that fact doesn't change this fact.

  • That when the story first broke, way back in 2012,

  • Warren initially said she had no idea

  • that she was not only listed,

  • but touted as a minority by Harvard Law School.

  • She then had to acknowledge that she had listed

  • her minority status on some federal forms.

  • Another sidebar, Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania

  • continue to say that her ancestry

  • was not a factor in her hiring.

  • Now the DNA test doesn't offer any sort

  • of conclusive, beyond a shadow of a doubt, evidence

  • of Warren's Native American heritage,

  • and therefore it remains today what it's been

  • for the past six years.

  • It's an effective attack line for her political opponents,

  • democrats and republicans.

  • Enter Trump.

  • He tweeted, quote, "Pocahontas, the bad version,

  • "sometimes referred to as Elizabeth Warren

  • "is getting slammed.

  • "She took a bogus DNA test and it showed

  • "that she may be 1/1,024,

  • "far less than the average American.

  • "Now Cherokee Nation denies her.

  • "DNA test is useless.

  • "Even they don't want her.

  • "Phony!"

  • Then he tweeted again.

  • "Elizabeth Warren is being hammered, even by the left.

  • "Her false claim of Indian heritage

  • is only selling to very low IQ individuals."

  • This is of course what Trump does.

  • He boasts, he brags, he bullies.

  • But Warren's DNA test reveal was aimed

  • at taking potent arrow out of Donald Trump's quiver.

  • Instead, she gave him lots more ammunition.

  • And that is ThePo!nt.

  • We do this every week, twice.

  • Check back every Tuesday and Thursday

  • for brand new episodes.

  • (jazz music)

- What am I going as for Halloween?

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B2 中高級

伊麗莎白-沃倫的DNA測試為何會適得其反? (Why Elizabeth Warren’s DNA test totally backfired | With Chris Cillizza)

  • 5 0
    林宜悉 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日
影片單字