字幕列表 影片播放 列印英文字幕 >>> THIS HISTORIC IMPEACHMENT OF >>> THIS HISTORIC IMPEACHMENT OF DONALD TRUMP COMES AMID MUCH DONALD TRUMP COMES AMID MUCH TALK ABOUT HOW AMERICANS ARE TALK ABOUT HOW AMERICANS ARE DIVIDED. DIVIDED. BUT THERE IS STRIKING AGREEMENT BUT THERE IS STRIKING AGREEMENT AMONG THE WRITERS AND EDITORS AMONG THE WRITERS AND EDITORS WHO REPORT ON GOVERNMENT FOR A WHO REPORT ON GOVERNMENT FOR A LIVING. LIVING. WELL, THEY'RE INDEPENDENT WELL, THEY'RE INDEPENDENT ARRIVING AT THE SAME ONE. ARRIVING AT THE SAME ONE. LOOK AT "THE NEW YORK TIMES" AND LOOK AT "THE NEW YORK TIMES" AND HOW THEY PUT IT. HOW THEY PUT IT. OR TAKE THE NEWSPAPER THAT OR TAKE THE NEWSPAPER THAT LAUNCHED THE MODERN TRADITION OF LAUNCHED THE MODERN TRADITION OF INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM IN INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM IN WATERGATE, "THE WASHINGTON POST" WATERGATE, "THE WASHINGTON POST" NOW ENDORSING THE IMPEACHMENT OF NOW ENDORSING THE IMPEACHMENT OF PRESIDENT TRUMP IN THIS HISTORIC PRESIDENT TRUMP IN THIS HISTORIC FULL PAGE EDITORIAL, NOTING HIS FULL PAGE EDITORIAL, NOTING HIS OBSTRUCTION THREATENS U.S. OBSTRUCTION THREATENS U.S. DEMOCRACY. DEMOCRACY. IT IS A DEPARTURE FROM THE LAST IT IS A DEPARTURE FROM THE LAST IMPEACHMENT IN OUR HISTORY WHERE IMPEACHMENT IN OUR HISTORY WHERE NEWSPAPERS OFTEN CONDEMNED NEWSPAPERS OFTEN CONDEMNED CLINTON'S PERSONAL CONDUCT BUT CLINTON'S PERSONAL CONDUCT BUT LARGELY OPPOSED THE REPUBLICAN LARGELY OPPOSED THE REPUBLICAN PUSH FOR IMPEACHMENT AS LEGALLY PUSH FOR IMPEACHMENT AS LEGALLY UNWARRANTED. UNWARRANTED. TODAY SEVERAL NEWSPAPERS SAY TODAY SEVERAL NEWSPAPERS SAY THEY SHIFTED AGAINST TRUMP WITH THEY SHIFTED AGAINST TRUMP WITH RELUCTANCE AND ONLY RECENTLY AS RELUCTANCE AND ONLY RECENTLY AS UKRAINE TIPPED THE SCALE. UKRAINE TIPPED THE SCALE. QUOTE, VIRTUALLY NOTHING DOES. QUOTE, VIRTUALLY NOTHING DOES. NOW, THERE ARE EXCEPTIONS. NOW, THERE ARE EXCEPTIONS. "THE WALL STREET JOURNAL," A "THE WALL STREET JOURNAL," A CONSERVATIVE EDITORIAL PAGE, CONSERVATIVE EDITORIAL PAGE, OPPOSES THE IMPEACHMENT CASE AS, OPPOSES THE IMPEACHMENT CASE AS, QUOTE, WEAK. QUOTE, WEAK. BUT THE DAILY NEWS SAYS INSTEAD BUT THE DAILY NEWS SAYS INSTEAD OF ONE SMOKING GUN, THERE IS OF ONE SMOKING GUN, THERE IS ACRID BLACK STUFF RISING FROM ACRID BLACK STUFF RISING FROM THE WHITE HOUSE. THE WHITE HOUSE. THE PHILADELPHIA INQUIRY THE PHILADELPHIA INQUIRY LABELING TRUMP A THREAT TO THE LABELING TRUMP A THREAT TO THE NATIONAL SECURITY. NATIONAL SECURITY. OR THE "ORLANDO SENTINAL" SAYING OR THE "ORLANDO SENTINAL" SAYING BASICALLY ONLY THE MOST CYNICAL BASICALLY ONLY THE MOST CYNICAL PARTISAN COULD MINIMIZE THE PARTISAN COULD MINIMIZE THE PUBLIC EVIDENCE AGAINST TRUMP. PUBLIC EVIDENCE AGAINST TRUMP. SHOULD AMERICANS CARE ABOUT THIS SHOULD AMERICANS CARE ABOUT THIS ON IMPEACHMENT EVE? ON IMPEACHMENT EVE? WE TURN TO THOMAS FRIEDMAN WE TURN TO THOMAS FRIEDMAN MAKING HIS DEBUT ON THE BEAT. MAKING HIS DEBUT ON THE BEAT. THANKS FOR BEING HERE. THANKS FOR BEING HERE. >> ARI, GREAT TO BE HERE WITH >> ARI, GREAT TO BE HERE WITH YOU. YOU. >> WHAT DOES IT SAY TO >> WHAT DOES IT SAY TO AMERICANS, AND SHOULD IT MATTER AMERICANS, AND SHOULD IT MATTER THAT SO MANY EDITORS AND LEADERS THAT SO MANY EDITORS AND LEADERS IN JOURNALISM ARE TAKING THIS IN JOURNALISM ARE TAKING THIS POSITION? POSITION? >> I THINK IT REALLY COMES DOWN >> I THINK IT REALLY COMES DOWN TO THE FACT THAT THERE ARE TWO TO THE FACT THAT THERE ARE TWO SIMPLE ISSUES HERE. SIMPLE ISSUES HERE. ONE IS THAT IF WE LET A ONE IS THAT IF WE LET A PRESIDENT USE CONGRESSIONALLY PRESIDENT USE CONGRESSIONALLY APPROPRIATED DEFENSE FUNDS FOR APPROPRIATED DEFENSE FUNDS FOR UKRAINE IN ORDER TO INTIMIDATE UKRAINE IN ORDER TO INTIMIDATE THE PRESIDENT OF THAT COUNTRY TO THE PRESIDENT OF THAT COUNTRY TO TAKE HIS RIVAL IN THE NEXT TAKE HIS RIVAL IN THE NEXT ELECTION, WE ARE BASICALLY ELECTION, WE ARE BASICALLY SAYING IT IS OKAY FOR ALL FUTURE SAYING IT IS OKAY FOR ALL FUTURE PRESIDENTS TO ENLIST FOREIGN PRESIDENTS TO ENLIST FOREIGN POWERS. POWERS. CAN YOU IMAGINE HOW MUCH MONEY CAN YOU IMAGINE HOW MUCH MONEY SOMEONE COULD RAISE FROM ENLIST SOMEONE COULD RAISE FROM ENLIST OR FROM IRAN? OR FROM IRAN? WE WOULD NEVER AGAIN HAVE A WE WOULD NEVER AGAIN HAVE A LEGITIMATE PRESIDENT. LEGITIMATE PRESIDENT. SOMEONE WHO YOU SAID WELL, I SOMEONE WHO YOU SAID WELL, I LIKE OR DON'T LIKE HIM OR HER LIKE OR DON'T LIKE HIM OR HER BUT THEY'RE LEGITIMATE. BUT THEY'RE LEGITIMATE. WE WOULD NEVER AGAIN HAVE A WE WOULD NEVER AGAIN HAVE A LEGITIMATE PRESIDENT. LEGITIMATE PRESIDENT. AND THAT WOULD BE A PRESCRIPTION AND THAT WOULD BE A PRESCRIPTION FOR POLITICAL CHAOS. FOR POLITICAL CHAOS. SECONDLY, IF WE'D LET A SECONDLY, IF WE'D LET A PRESIDENT IN THE FACE OF THESE PRESIDENT IN THE FACE OF THESE CHARGES NOT ALLOW THE KEY CHARGES NOT ALLOW THE KEY WITNESSES TO TESTIFY, THOSE WITNESSES TO TESTIFY, THOSE CLOSEST TO THE PROCESS, CLOSEST TO THE PROCESS, GIULIANI, POMPEO, MICK MULVANEY, GIULIANI, POMPEO, MICK MULVANEY, IF WE DON'T LET -- IF WE LET HIM IF WE DON'T LET -- IF WE LET HIM GET AWAY WITH NOT LETTING THEM GET AWAY WITH NOT LETTING THEM TESTIFY AND NOT TURNING OVER ANY TESTIFY AND NOT TURNING OVER ANY DOCUMENTS, WE ARE BASICALLY DOCUMENTS, WE ARE BASICALLY SAYING WE NO LONGER HAVE A SAYING WE NO LONGER HAVE A SERPTHS OF SERPTHS OF SEPARATION OF POWERS, WE SEPARATION OF POWERS, WE ACTUALLY HAVE A MONARCHY. ACTUALLY HAVE A MONARCHY. AND IF WE LET BOTH OF THOSE AND IF WE LET BOTH OF THOSE THINGS HAPPEN, THE AMERICA THAT THINGS HAPPEN, THE AMERICA THAT YOU AND I KNEW, GREW UP AND YOU AND I KNEW, GREW UP AND LOVED, THE AMERICA THAT IS SO LOVED, THE AMERICA THAT IS SO WIDELY RESPECTED AROUND THE WIDELY RESPECTED AROUND THE GLOBE WILL BE NO MORE, AND WE GLOBE WILL BE NO MORE, AND WE WILL MISS IT WHEN IT'S GONE. WILL MISS IT WHEN IT'S GONE. >> IT'S STRIKING WHEN YOU LAY IT >> IT'S STRIKING WHEN YOU LAY IT OUT LIKE THAT. OUT LIKE THAT. YOU'VE COVERED MANY PRESIDENTS. YOU'VE COVERED MANY PRESIDENTS. YOU'VE BEEN AROUND THE WORLD. YOU'VE BEEN AROUND THE WORLD. YOU'RE A HIGH-LEVEL GUY, TOM, IF YOU'RE A HIGH-LEVEL GUY, TOM, IF YOU DON'T MIND ME SAYING. YOU DON'T MIND ME SAYING. AND YOU MADE THE OBSERVATION AND YOU MADE THE OBSERVATION THAT IN A WEIRD WAY DONALD THAT IN A WEIRD WAY DONALD TRUMP, WHO STYLES HIMSELF A TRUMP, WHO STYLES HIMSELF A COMMUNICATIONS GURU, HAS COMMUNICATIONS GURU, HAS DISARMED FROM THE BULLY PULPIT DISARMED FROM THE BULLY PULPIT OF THE WHITE HOUSE PRESS ROOM. OF THE WHITE HOUSE PRESS ROOM. WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT? WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT? >> IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE I >> IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE I COVERED THE SECRETARY OF STATE COVERED THE SECRETARY OF STATE AND I COVERED THE FIRST YEAR OF AND I COVERED THE FIRST YEAR OF BILL CLINTON. BILL CLINTON. SO I'VE BEEN IN KIND OF BOTH SO I'VE BEEN IN KIND OF BOTH THOSE PRESS ROOMS. THOSE PRESS ROOMS. AND I ALWAYS NOTICED HOW MUCH AND I ALWAYS NOTICED HOW MUCH THE BEST SPOKESPEOPLE FOR THE BEST SPOKESPEOPLE FOR THOSE -- FOR THOSE OFFICIALS THOSE -- FOR THOSE OFFICIALS WOULD USE THE QUESTIONS THEY GOT WOULD USE THE QUESTIONS THEY GOT FROM THE PRESS AS REAL EARLY FROM THE PRESS AS REAL EARLY WARNING SIGNS, WHAT'S OUT THERE, WARNING SIGNS, WHAT'S OUT THERE, WHAT ARE THE ISSUES WE NEED TO WHAT ARE THE ISSUES WE NEED TO BE AWARE OF AND WHERE IS THIS BE AWARE OF AND WHERE IS THIS STORY GOING. STORY GOING. THE FACT THAT TRUMP HAS NOT THE FACT THAT TRUMP HAS NOT ALLOWED A WHITE HOUSE BRIEFING ALLOWED A WHITE HOUSE BRIEFING SINCE I DON'T KNOW, NINE MONTHS, SINCE I DON'T KNOW, NINE MONTHS, TWELVE MONTHS, I DON'T EVEN KNOW TWELVE MONTHS, I DON'T EVEN KNOW HOW LONG IT'S BEEN ANYMORE, THE HOW LONG IT'S BEEN ANYMORE, THE FACT THAT HIS SPOKESMAN ONLY FACT THAT HIS SPOKESMAN ONLY GOES ON FOX NEWS, THE FACT THAT GOES ON FOX NEWS, THE FACT THAT HE ONLY GOES ON FOX NEWS, HE ONLY GOES ON FOX NEWS, THEY'VE BEEN IN SUCH A BUBBLE THEY'VE BEEN IN SUCH A BUBBLE THAT I THINK, A, THEY DON'T THAT I THINK, A, THEY DON'T REALIZE THE DANGER THAT THEY ARE REALIZE THE DANGER THAT THEY ARE IN. IN. THEY DON'T REALIZE HOW SERIOUS THEY DON'T REALIZE HOW SERIOUS THIS IS VIEWED BY THE COUNTRY. THIS IS VIEWED BY THE COUNTRY. THEY DON'T REALIZE HOW TRUMP THEY DON'T REALIZE HOW TRUMP EARLY ON SAID, HEY, I MADE A EARLY ON SAID, HEY, I MADE A MISTAKE, I REALLY WENT A LITTLE MISTAKE, I REALLY WENT A LITTLE BIT TOO FAR. BIT TOO FAR. HAD HE ACCEPTED CENSURE, AND HAD HE ACCEPTED CENSURE, AND THAT WAS WHAT THE DEMOCRATS THAT WAS WHAT THE DEMOCRATS WOULD HAVE MUCH PREFERRED I WOULD HAVE MUCH PREFERRED I THINK, HE COULD HAVE GOTTEN AWAY THINK, HE COULD HAVE GOTTEN AWAY WITH CENSURE AND NOT WITH CENSURE AND NOT IMPEACHMENT. IMPEACHMENT. IN THE HISTORY BOOKS NO ONE IN THE HISTORY BOOKS NO ONE REALLY REMEMBERS A PRESIDENT WHO REALLY REMEMBERS A PRESIDENT WHO WAS CENSURED. WAS CENSURED. NO ONE WILL EVER FORGET A NO ONE WILL EVER FORGET A PRESIDENT WHO'S BEEN IMPEACHED. PRESIDENT WHO'S BEEN IMPEACHED. >> GIVEN YOUR VIEW ON THE ENTIRE >> GIVEN YOUR VIEW ON THE ENTIRE WORLD, YOU'VE MENTIONED THAT WORLD, YOU'VE MENTIONED THAT THERE ARE OTHER COUNTRIES THAT THERE ARE OTHER COUNTRIES THAT ARE INCREASINGLY ROOTING FOR ARE INCREASINGLY ROOTING FOR TRUMP. TRUMP. WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT? WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT? >> I THINK BOTH RUSSIA AND CHINA >> I THINK BOTH RUSSIA AND CHINA WILL BE VOTING TRUMP IN 2020. WILL BE VOTING TRUMP IN 2020. I'M NOT SAYING THEY'LL I'M NOT SAYING THEY'LL NECESSARILY INT SCREEN.ERVENE. NECESSARILY INT SCREEN.ERVENE. I'M SURE THE RUSSIANS WILL. I'M SURE THE RUSSIANS WILL. I CAN'T SPEAK FOR THE CHINESE. I CAN'T SPEAK FOR THE CHINESE. IT'S FOR TWO REASONS. IT'S FOR TWO REASONS. ONE IS BECAUSE THEY KNOW THAT AS ONE IS BECAUSE THEY KNOW THAT AS LONG AS TRUMP IS PRESIDENT OF LONG AS TRUMP IS PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES AMERICA'S IN THE UNITED STATES AMERICA'S IN TURMOIL. TURMOIL. THE OTHER THING THEY KNOW IS THE OTHER THING THEY KNOW IS THAT AS LONG AS TRUMP IS THAT AS LONG AS TRUMP IS PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES HE CAN NEVER GALVANIZE A GLOBAL HE CAN NEVER GALVANIZE A GLOBAL COALITION AGAINST THEM. COALITION AGAINST THEM. HE CAN NEVER GALVANIZE THE HE CAN NEVER GALVANIZE THE EUROPEANS IN A COALITION AGAINST EUROPEANS IN A COALITION AGAINST RUSSIA AND HE CAN NEVER GAVEL RUSSIA AND HE CAN NEVER GAVEL GALVANIZE THE ASIANS AGAINST GALVANIZE THE ASIANS AGAINST CHINA. CHINA. AND FOR BOTH THOSE COUNTRIES AND FOR BOTH THOSE COUNTRIES THAT IS CRITICAL. THAT IS CRITICAL. THEY KNOW AS LONG AS TRUMP IS THEY KNOW AS LONG AS TRUMP IS THERE THEY WILL NEVER FACE A THERE THEY WILL NEVER FACE A GLOBAL COALITION AGAINST THEM. GLOBAL COALITION AGAINST THEM. >> THE OTHER THING I WANT TO ASK >> THE OTHER THING I WANT TO ASK YOU ABOUT SOMETHING WE'VE BEEN YOU ABOUT SOMETHING WE'VE BEEN FOLLOWING CLOSELY HERE WITH OUR FOLLOWING CLOSELY HERE WITH OUR EXPERTS, AND THAT IS THE DECLINE EXPERTS, AND THAT IS THE DECLINE OF COMMON FACTS, WHICH IS NOT TO OF COMMON FACTS, WHICH IS NOT TO SAY THERE HASN'T ALWAYS BEEN SAY THERE HASN'T ALWAYS BEEN RICH AND HUGE DEBATES IN THIS RICH AND HUGE DEBATES IN THIS COUNTRY. COUNTRY. THERE HAS BEEN PARTISAN PRESS IN THERE HAS BEEN PARTISAN PRESS IN THE FOUNDING ERA. THE FOUNDING ERA. THERE'S BEEN A LOT. THERE'S BEEN A LOT. SO IT'S NOT TO OVERSIMPLIFY. SO IT'S NOT TO OVERSIMPLIFY. BUT I WANT TO SHOW YOU SOMETHING BUT I WANT TO SHOW YOU SOMETHING YOU KNOW ABOUT AND OUR VIEWERS YOU KNOW ABOUT AND OUR VIEWERS KNOW ABOUT, WHICH IS LOOK AT THE KNOW ABOUT, WHICH IS LOOK AT THE DECLINE OF NIXON'S APPROVAL DECLINE OF NIXON'S APPROVAL ACROSS PARTIES. ACROSS PARTIES. IF YOU SEE ON THE RIGHT HERE. IF YOU SEE ON THE RIGHT HERE. AS WATERGATE EVIDENCE CAME OUT, AS WATERGATE EVIDENCE CAME OUT, IT WAS A NET DROP THAT WAS VERY IT WAS A NET DROP THAT WAS VERY SIMILAR AMONG DEMS, INDIES, AND SIMILAR AMONG DEMS, INDIES, AND Rs. Rs. ALL AROUND 40 OR 40-PLUS ALL AROUND 40 OR 40-PLUS PERCENT. PERCENT. IT MADE ALL THE DIFFERENCE. IT MADE ALL THE DIFFERENCE. DO YOU THINK THAT WAS BECAUSE OF DO YOU THINK THAT WAS BECAUSE OF THE WAY THAT PEOPLE CONSUMED THE WAY THAT PEOPLE CONSUMED INFORMATION THEN, AND DO YOU INFORMATION THEN, AND DO YOU EVER GET BACK TO THAT WORLD EVER GET BACK TO THAT WORLD WHERE THERE ARE SOME COMMON WHERE THERE ARE SOME COMMON FACTS IN AMERICA? FACTS IN AMERICA? >> YEAH, WE HAVE -- DAVE ROBERTS >> YEAH, WE HAVE -- DAVE ROBERTS WROTE ABOUT THIS VERY WELL IN WROTE ABOUT THIS VERY WELL IN VOX RECENTLY. VOX RECENTLY. WE BASICALLY HAVE TODAY THE WE BASICALLY HAVE TODAY THE ABILITY TO CREATE AN ALTERNATIVE ABILITY TO CREATE AN ALTERNATIVE ENTIRE EPISODEERRE EPISTEMOLOGIC ENTIRE EPISODEERRE EPISTEMOLOGIC WHERE YOU COMPLETELY LIVE IN A WHERE YOU COMPLETELY LIVE IN A DIFFERENT SET OF FACTS BECAUSE DIFFERENT SET OF FACTS BECAUSE IF YOU GET MOST OF YOUR IF YOU GET MOST OF YOUR INFORMATION ONLINE FROM FACEBOOK INFORMATION ONLINE FROM FACEBOOK AND THAT'S TARGETED TO REINFORCE AND THAT'S TARGETED TO REINFORCE YOUR BIASES. YOUR BIASES. AND IF YOU WATCH ONLY ONE AND IF YOU WATCH ONLY ONE PARTICULAR NETWORK AND YOU PUT PARTICULAR NETWORK AND YOU PUT ALL THOSE TOGETHER. ALL THOSE TOGETHER. THERE'S NO WALTER CRONKITE OUT THERE'S NO WALTER CRONKITE OUT THERE WHO EVERYONE IS SHARKING THERE WHO EVERYONE IS SHARKING THE SAME INFORMATION FROM. THE SAME INFORMATION FROM. AND I THINK IT'S ONE OF THE MOST AND I THINK IT'S ONE OF THE MOST FRIGHTENING THINGS BECAUSE OUR FRIGHTENING THINGS BECAUSE OUR DEMOCRACY, ARI, IS BASED ON TWO DEMOCRACY, ARI, IS BASED ON TWO PILLARS -- TRUTH AND TRUST. PILLARS -- TRUTH AND TRUST. OKAY? OKAY? IF WE DON'T SHARE TRUTH, WE IF WE DON'T SHARE TRUTH, WE CAN'T POSSIBLY GET THE BIG -- WE CAN'T POSSIBLY GET THE BIG -- WE CAN'T POSSIBLY FACE THE BIG CAN'T POSSIBLY FACE THE BIG CHALLENGES, CLIMATE CHANGE, CHALLENGES, CLIMATE CHANGE, CYBER WAR, EDUCATION. CYBER WAR, EDUCATION. WE CAN'T POSSIBLY AGREE TO DO WE CAN'T POSSIBLY AGREE TO DO ANYTHING AT SCALE IF WE DON'T ANYTHING AT SCALE IF WE DON'T SHARE THE SAME TRUTH AND IF WE SHARE THE SAME TRUTH AND IF WE DON'T TRUST EACH OTHER WE CAN'T DON'T TRUST EACH OTHER WE CAN'T POSSIBLY DO ANYTHING BIG AND POSSIBLY DO ANYTHING BIG AND HARD TOGETHER. HARD TOGETHER. IF YOU DON'T HAVE TRUTH AND IF YOU DON'T HAVE TRUTH AND TRUST, YOU CANNOT DO ANYTHING TRUST, YOU CANNOT DO ANYTHING BIG AND HARD. BIG AND HARD. AND ALL THE CHALLENGES WE HAVE AND ALL THE CHALLENGES WE HAVE COMING AT US RIGHT NOW ARE BIG COMING AT US RIGHT NOW ARE BIG AND HARD. AND HARD. >> ON A HISTORIC TIME AS WE TAKE >> ON A HISTORIC TIME AS WE TAKE ALL THIS IN IT'S REALLY GREAT TO ALL THIS IN IT'S REALLY GREAT TO GET YOUR INSIGHTS. GET YOUR INSIGHTS. TOM, I HOPE YOU COME BACK AND
B1 中級 "暴徒"、"威脅"。特朗普的 "威脅":支持彈劾,頂級報紙對特朗普大加撻伐|MSNBC ('Thug,' 'Threat': Endorsing Impeachment, Top Newspapers Unload On Trump | MSNBC) 15 1 林宜悉 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日 更多分享 分享 收藏 回報 影片單字