字幕列表 影片播放 列印英文字幕 THERE IS NOW A COUP IN TURKEY. THIS USED TO HAPPEN ONCE A DECADE, BUT IT HASN'T HAPPENED IN QUITE SOME TIME. THIS COUP IS UNUSUAL IN TWO WAYS, FIRST COUPS IN TURKEY ARE NOT TO END DEMOCRACY, THEY ARE NORMALLY DONE TO PROTECT SECULAR DEMOCRACY. BUT THAT IS NOT THE HISTORY IN TURKEY. IN TURKEY USUALLY IF THE GOVERNMENT HAS SUCCEEDED ITS MANDATE, THE MILITARY IS A PROTECTOR OF SECULAR DEMOCRACY, THEY WILL STEP IN AND GET RID OF THAT GOVERNMENT AND THEN HAVE ORDERLY ELECTIONS AFTERWARD. NOW ERDOGAN IS A RIGHT-WINGER, THE PRESIDENT OF TURKEY. HE CLAIMS THAT HE HAS WON ALL THESE ELECTIONS. HE SAYS HE IS ON THE SIDE OF DEMOCRACY. SO SOME OF THESE ELECTIONS HAD STRETCHED THE BOUNDS OF REASON. THERE IS NOW A PEACE COUNCIL WHICH IS WHAT THE COUP IS CALLING HAS CLAIMED OVER THE COUNTRY. BUT THAT IS THE SECOND INCREDIBLY UNUSUAL PART OF THIS. NORMALLY A COUP HAPPENS FAIRLY QUICKLY. USUALLY THERE IS A DECISIVE BLOW, THEY TAKE OVER THINGS LIKE THE MEDIA OUTLETS, AND IN THIS DAY AND AGE WE CAN TAKE OVER THE MEDIA OUTLETS. THE PRESIDENT OF TURKEY WENT ON FACETIME TO GET HIS MESSAGE OUT. YOU TAKE OVER THE MEDIA, YOU TAKE OVER IMPORTANT POLICE INSTALLATIONS, THE AIRPORT, ETC. AND YOU FINALLY GET THE PERSON YOU ARE TRYING TO DO A COUP ON. RIGHT NOW IT APPEARS THEY DO NOT HAVE THE PRESIDENT. FURTHERMORE, THE MILITARY IS DIVIDED. NORMALLY IT IS A UNITED MILITARY THAT DOES A COUP, IN THIS CASE IT IS NOT. IT IS NOT REMOTELY OVER. THERE IS NO RESOLUTION TO THIS COUP AS WE SPEAK. WE ARE DOING THIS LIVE. THIS CAN STRETCH ON FOR QUITE SOME TIME. I HAVE SOURCES FROM INSIDE TURKEY THAT ARE SAYING THAT PEOPLE ARE OUT ON THE STREETS. THE FACT THAT HE CALLED THE PEOPLE OUT SHOWS YOU GOOD NEWS AND BAD NEWS FOR HIM. HE DOES HAVE A LOT OF SUPPORTERS IN THE COUNTRY. HE IS CALLING OUT THE FUNDAMENTALIST PEOPLE. SO THERE HAS BEEN SHOOTING BACK AND FORTH. JOHN WILL GIVE YOU DETAILS ABOUT THAT. THE POLICE ARE GENERALLY ON THE SIDE OF THE GOVERNMENT. THAT MEANS THE POLICE AND THE MILITARY ARE OFTEN IN CONFLICT AND THERE ARE REPORTS OF SHOOTOUTS THERE AS WELL. >> THE TELEGRAPH IS REPORTING THAT 17 POLICE OFFICERS THAT WERE KILLED. IF THAT IS TRUE THEY WERE KILLED BY MILITARY. >> ONE OF MY SOURCES SAYS THAT THE MILITARY WAS TRYING TO LAND ON THE MOST IMPORTANT POLICE HEADQUARTERS IN ISTANBUL [VIDEO BUFFERING] THEY CLAIM THAT IS WHAT STARTED THE HOSTILITIES ñ BUT IN BETWEEN THE POLICE AND THE MILITARY. NOW THERE ARE REPORTS THAT THERE ARE TANKS FIRING AT THE PARLIAMENT BUILDING. IN THE VERY BEGINNING OF THIS COUP, TURKISH TELEVISION WAS RECORDING AS NOT A COUP, BUT A LIGHT MILITARY ACTION. THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A LIGHT COUP, YOU EITHER WIN OR YOU ALL GET EXECUTED. SO NOW SOME PORTION OF THE TURKISH MILITARY IS EITHER GOING TO WIN OR BE EXECUTED, AND THE PRESIDENT IS EITHER GOING TO WIN OR WALK OUT PRESUMABLY IN HANDCUFFS. THIS IS WINNER TAKE ALL. PEOPLE ARE IN THE STREETS, TANKS ARE IN THE STREETS. THIS IS A MESS. >> AS YOU SAY, IT IS AN INTERESTING COUP, A VERY MODERATE COUP. THEY TRIED TO TAKE OVER THE MEDIA, THE TOOK OVER STATE TELEVISION, FACEBOOK, TWITTER, YOUTUBE WERE SHUT DOWN ALMOST INSTANTLY. BUT BECAUSE OF VPNS THERE WAS STILL A LOT OF INFORMATION THAT WAS COMING OUT OF THE COUNTRY. BUT WE ALSO HAVE MANY JOURNALISTS BEING EJECTED FROM THE COUNTRY, NOT BY THE MILITARY, BUT PRIOR BY THE GOVERNMENT. IT IS A VERY COMPLICATED SITUATION. SOME OF WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT CONTROLLING KEY AREAS, THOSE ARE OUR INITIAL CLUES THAT SOMETHING WAS GOING ON. SEVERAL BRIDGES HAVE BEEN BLOCKED OFF BY TANKS. EVENTUALLY ONE AIRPORT WAS SHUT DOWN, NOW ALL AIRPORTS ARE SHUT DOWN. AS YOU SAID THIS IS NOT A UNIFIED MILITARY EFFORT, IT IS ACTUALLY FAR MORE DANGEROUS. YOU HAVE NOT ONLY THE INSTANCE WHERE THE RENEGADE HELICOPTERS FIRED UPON THE POLICE STATION KILLING 17 PEOPLE. WE THEN HAD A JET AFFILIATED WITH THE MILITARY FORCES LOYAL TO THE PRESIDENT SHOOTING DOWN ONE OF THOSE HELICOPTERS. WE NOW HAVE THE POTENTIAL FOR TANK BATTLES, AND ARMED FORCES ON BOTH SIDES FIGHTING. >> WHEN YOU GET THE MILITARY FIRING ON POLICE IN THE CAPITAL, THAT IS A CIVIL WAR. THOSE ARE THE THINGS THAT BEGIN A CIVIL WAR. >> IF YOU ARE A BELIEVER IN SECULAR DEMOCRACY, THERE IS A REASON TO ROOT FOR THIS COUP. I KNOW THERE ARE A LOT OF TRICKS INSIDE THE COUNTRY THAT ARE HOPING THAT THIS GETS DONE, IF IT DOES NOT THEN THE PRESIDENT REGAINS POWER AND HE WILL BE AN IMMOVABLE OBJECT. HE WILL BE GUARDED, HE WILL PASS EVERY DRACONIAN LAW AND THE FUNDAMENTALISTS WILL HAVE A MUCH TIGHTER REIN ON POWER. IF YOU ARE IN THAT SECULAR GROUP AND WANT THE COUP TO SUCCEED, IT WAS GOOD NEWS IN THE BEGINNING AND NOT GOOD NEWS NOW. YOU WANTED IT TO HAPPEN QUICKLY AND BE OVER, BUT IT IS NOT OVER. ONE OF THE LEADING GENERALS SAID THAT I AM NOT PART OF THIS AND HE DID NOT TAKE SIDES. THE NAVY SAID WE ARE NOT PART OF THIS. THAT DOESN'T MEAN THE NAVY ATTACKED THE COUP. YOU CAN SEE HOW THIS CAN GET INTO AN UNBELIEVABLE MESS. COPS VERSUS MILITARY, PARTS OF THE MILITARY VERSUS OTHER PARTS OF THE MILITARY. >> THE US WAS VERY SLOW TO TALK ABOUT THIS. BUT NOW ñ WE HAVE A BASE IN TURKEY THAT HOUSES NUCLEAR WEAPONS. IT'LL BE INTERESTING TO SEE IF WE REALLY DO CHOOSE SIDES. >> THE PRESIDENT AND JOHN KERRY ñ THE SECRETARY UNDERSCORED THAT THE STATE DEPARTMENT WILL CONTINUE TO FOCUS ON THE SAFETY AND SECURITY OF US CITIZENS IN TURKEY. THERE IS SOME QUESTION AS A NATO MEMBER, WHAT ARE YOU SUPPOSED TO DO WHEN THERE IS A COUP ATTEMPT? IT IS A COMPLICATED SITUATION AND I'M PRETTY SURE THE US WANTS TO SIDE WITH THE WINNER. >>THE US ROLE IN THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT AND VERY UNCLEAR. NORMAL OPERATING PROCEDURE IS IF AN ALLY LIKE TURKEY IS GOING TO PULL OFF A COUP AGAINST THE GOVERNMENT, THEY WOULD CERTAINLY CONSULT WITH THE UNITED STATES. >> IT APPEARS THEY DIDN'T. THIS IS TOO EARLY. >> WHAT IS NOT EVIDENT IS SECRETARY KERRY OR PRES. OBAMA'S WORDS. THEY WOULD SAY THEY ARE BACKING THE GOVERNMENT NO MATTER WHAT THEY DO. >> THIS IS FROM REUTERS, A SENIOR EU SOURCE MONITORING THE SITUATION SAID, "IT LOOKS LIKE A WELL ORCHESTRATED COUP BY A SIGNIFICANT BODY IN THE MILITARY NOT JUST A FEW COLONELS. THEY HAVE CONTROL OF THE AIRPORTS AND ARE EXPECTING CONTROL OVER THE TV STATIONS. THEY CONTROL SEVERAL STRATEGIC POINTS IN ISTANBUL. GIVEN THE SCALE IT IS DIFFICULT TO IMAGINE THAT THEY WILL STOP SHORT OF PREVAILING THOUGHT IS NOT JUST A FEW COLONELS. THIS IS CLEARLY NOT SOME LITTLE COUP, THE TURKISH AMBASSADOR WAS CLEARLY SHOCKED AND IS TAKING VERY SERIOUSLY. HOWEVER IT LOOKS IN THE MORNING THEY WILL HAVE MASSIVE IMPLICATIONS FOR TURKEY. THIS HAS NOT COME OUT OF NOWHERE." MEANING IT WAS PLANNED. WE STILL DON'T KNOW. THE SUGGESTION ñ IT DOESN'T SUGGEST THAT THE US DIDN'T KNOW, BUT IT SUGGESTS THAT IT SURPRISED THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO MIGHT HAVE KNOWLEDGE OF IT. >> I WOULD CONSIDER IT SHOCKING IF THE US DIDN'T KNOW. ONE OF THE TOP GENERALS HAS BEEN TAKEN BY THE LEADERS OF THE COUP, SO THERE IS DEFINITELY A RIFT WITHIN THE TURKISH MILITARY. >> IT'S SHOCKING AND SURPRISING BECAUSE TURKEY HASN'T HAD A MILITARY COUP SINCE 1980, BUT IF YOU REALLY THINK ABOUT IT IT IS NOT THAT SHOCKING WHEN YOU CONSIDER THAT TURKEY AMONG ALL PREDOMINANTLY MUSLIM COUNTRIES HAS BEEN VERY VOCAL ABOUT REMAINING SECULAR. EVEN THOUGH THE COUNTRY IS DIVIDED AMONGST THOSE WHO SUPPORT THE PRESIDENT, OR MIGHT AGREE WITH THE MILITARY COUP, THERE IS THIS NEED AND WANT TO BE SECULAR. ONE THING THAT STOOD OUT TO ME WAS HOW THE FIRST THING THE PRESIDENT WANTED TO DO WAS ASKED HIS SUPPORTERS TO GO OUT IN THE STREETS. HE HAS BEEN SO HORRIFIC TOWARD JOURNALISTS AND PROTESTERS. AS SOON AS HE NEEDS PROTESTERS FOR HIS OWN AGENDA AND PURPOSES, HE TELLS THEM TO GO OUT ON THE STREETS AND RISK THEIR OWN LIVES. >> IT'S INCREDIBLY DANGEROUS FOR THEM TO GO OUT THERE. TO WHAT YOU ARE SAYING ABOUT WHETHER THE U.S. MIGHT KNOW OR NOT, THE STATEMENT THAT WAS PUT OUT BY THE COUP FORCES I THINK IS INTERESTING. IT EXPLAINS THEIR REASSURANCE TO THE US. " TURKISH ARMED FORCES OF ñ HUMAN RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS, THE RULE OF LAW ON THE GENERAL SECURITY THAT HAS DAMAGED ALL INTERNATIONAL AGREEMENTS ARE STILL VALID. WE HOPE ALL OUR GOOD RELATIONSHIPS WITH ALL COUNTRIES WILL CONTINUE." >> THERE IS NO QUESTION WHAT THEY WANT, THEY WANT TO BE IN CHARGE OF TURKEY AND GET RID OF THE PRESIDENT AND CONTINUE THE ROLE THAT TURKEY HAD PRIOR TO THE PRESIDENT. TO CENK'S POINT WE ARE NOT GOING TO KNOW IN THE COMING DAYS, BECAUSE IF WE KNEW IT WASN'T BECAUSE THESE GUYS CALLED JOHN KERRY. THERE IS NO QUESTION WHAT SIDE WE HAVE TO BE ON, AND WE HAVE NO BIGGER ALLY IN THE FIGHT AGAINST ISIS THAN TURKEY. INCREDIBLY VALUABLE. THE NOTION THAT WE WOULD OFFICIALLY RISK ñ THAT IS THE WORST POSSIBLE OUTCOME IS A STRENGTHENED AND AN EMPOWERED PRESIDENT. THE FLIPSIDE IS TO CENK'S POINT, THE NOTION THAT THE CIA DIDN'T KNOW OF THIS ñ IT WOULD BE A FASCINATING INTRIGUING STORY WHEN REVEALED. >> LET ME CLARIFY THE PRESIDENT REFERENCED THE CIA BUT IN A VEILED WAY. YOU KNOW HE IS NOT IN CHARGE, HE CLAIMS HE IS. IF YOU REMEMBER ONE OF THE TACTICS THAT THE PRESIDENT WILL USE AGAINST PROTESTERS IS FIREWATER. THEY WOULD PUT PEPPER SPRAY IN THE WATER HOSES AND SPRAY THAT ON EVERYONE SO THEY WOULD GET PEPPER SPRAY ALL OVER THEM, SO HE NORMALLY HATES PROTESTERS IN THE STREETS. NOW HE IS BEGGING FOR PROTESTERS IN THE STREETS WHICH MEANS HE IS NOT IN CHARGE. HE HAS LOST THE MEDIA ENTIRELY AND HE HAD GREAT CONTROL OVER THE MEDIA. YOU CAN TELL HE IS NOT IN CHARGE OF THE MEDIA BECAUSE HE HAD TO USE A CELL PHONE AND FACE TIME TO MESSAGE THE TURKISH PEOPLE. NO WAY THE PRESIDENT IS FACE TIMING IF HE WAS ACTUALLY IN CHARGE. IF YOU ARE IN FAVOR OF PEACEFUL RESOLUTION, YOU WANT THIS TO END EITHER WAY IMMEDIATELY. THE WORST-CASE SCENARIO IS NEITHER SIDE WINS AND THEN WE'VE GOT TANKS ALL OVER THE STREETS, ONE REPORT HAS AN F-16, TURKISH MILITARY, SHOOTING DOWN A TURKISH MILITARY HELICOPTER. TURKEY IS HEAVILY ARMED. IT IS THE SECOND LARGEST ARMED NATION IN NATO. LET ME GIVE YOU WHAT I KNOW ABOUT THE AMERICAN INVOLVEMENT. THERE IS ANOTHER MUSLIM FUNDAMENTALIST WHO LIVES INSIDE AMERICA. HE WAS DEEP ALLIES WITH ERDOGAN, THE PRESIDENT, HAS BEEN IN POWER SINCE 2003. THEY ARE BOTH FUNDAMENTALIST MUSLIMS. THAT IS NOT FUNDAMENTALIST MUSLIMS AS YOU WOULD HAVE IN OTHER PLACES OF THE MIDDLE EAST. AS WE HAVE THE CHRISTIAN RIGHT HERE IN AMERICA, THEY ARE BASICALLY THE MUSLIM RIGHT. THEY ARE REPUBLICANS, RIGHT WING IN THAT SENSE. >>HE IS THE MIKE PENCE OF TURKEY. >>YES, HE IS NOT A RELIGIOUS LEADER. ERDOGAN IS NOT A RELIGIOUS LEADER, BUT HE IS MORE OF A MUSLIM FUNDAMENTALIST WITHIN THE DEMOCRACY OF TURKEY. PEOPLE ARE UNSURE IF HE TAINTED THAT DEMOCRACY IN THOSE ELECTIONS. THE GUY IN PENNSYLVANIA IS A RELIGIOUS LEADER AND USED TO WORK WITH THE PRESIDENT. AND THEY THINK HE HAS AN ALLIANCE WITH THE CIA. HE HAS A COMPOUND IN PENNSYLVANIA, CHARTER SCHOOLS ALL OVER AMERICA. WE DON'T OFTEN GIVE FUNDAMENTALIST MUSLIMS CHARTER SCHOOLS TO TEACH OUR KIDS IN AMERICA UNLESS YOU'VE GOT SOME SORT OF OKAY FROM THE US GOVERNMENT. WHEN THOSE TWO GUYS THEN BROKE APART AND BEGAN AN INTERNAL STRUGGLE FOR POWER IN TURKEY, A LOT OF THE POLICE USED TO BE ON ONE SIDE, THEN THE PRESIDENT CAME IN WITH A POWER PLAY. IT IS AN AMAZING POWER PLAY GOING ON. AT THAT BREAK, IT APPEARS THAT THE AMERICAN GOVERNMENT THOUGHT THE PRESIDENT IS OFF THE RESERVATION. THERE ARE THINGS THAT HAPPEN BEHIND THE SCENES. IT APPEARED THAT BEHIND THE SCENES THE U.S. WAS ON THE GUY IN PENNSYLVANIA'S SIDE. SO NOW HE PUT OUT A STATEMENT SAYING IT WASN'T ME. IT WOULD BE ENORMOUSLY SURPRISING IF A MILITARY, OBVIOUSLY VERY WELL ORGANIZED, OBVIOUSLY NOT AS WELL-ORGANIZED AS THEY WANT TO BE. THAT KIND OF MILITARY COUP DIDN'T ASK THE CIA, OR THE GUY IN PENNSYLVANIA, OR THE AMERICAN GOVERNMENT. BEN IS RIGHT, THE AMERICAN GOVERNMENT WOULD NEVER SAY IN PUBLIC. THIS HAS IMPLICATIONS FOR TURKEY, FOR THE MIDDLE EAST, AND FOR THE WHOLE WORLD. IF I HAD TO GUESS, AND I AM GUESSING BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW. I AM TELLING YOU WHAT WOULD NORMALLY HAPPEN, IF I HAD TO GUESS I WOULD SAY THAT WE WERE ON THE SIDE OF THE COUP, THE U.S. IS. BUT IF IT DOES NOT WORK, IT IS CERTAINLY THE PRESIDENT WILL THINK THAT WE ARE ON THE SIDE OF THE COUP AND WE WILL HAVE A LOT OF TROUBLE. >> WHAT WE ARE HEARING IS THAT OBAMA HAD A MEETING WITH HIS NATIONAL SECURITY STAFF. THEN THEY CAME OUT WITH THAT STATEMENT. MEANING WHAT THEY HEARD. >>ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE AT THIS POINT, AND IT IS A COUP. THERE ARE THREE DIFFERENT WAYS THAT THIS CAN GO. THE COUP CONTINUES, THEY MANAGED TO WRANGLE ENOUGH OF THE REST OF THE MILITARY AND THE POLICE AND KEEP THE PEOPLE IN THE STREETS AT BAY, AND THEY SEIZE POWER. IT HAPPENS RELATIVELY QUICKLY. BY THE MORNING, BY THE NEXT DAY IT IS OVER. A SECOND POSSIBILITY IS THE COUP DETERIORATES AND NOW THERE ARE SOME REPORTS THAT IT IS. AND THE OTHER PARTS OF THE MILITARY STEP IN ALONG WITH THE POLICE AND CRUSH THEM. THE THIRD POSSIBILITY IS NEITHER SIDE WINS. THAT IS PROBABLY THE WORST CASE SCENARIO. LOOK, I AM DEEPLY SECULAR SO MY PROCLIVITIES ARE OBVIOUS. BUT IF THE TURKISH MILITARY AND POLICE START FIGHTING ONE ANOTHER, AND IT DOES NOT END, IF YOU THOUGHT THE MIDDLE EAST AND THAT REGION WAS UNSTABLE BEFORE, YOU AIN'T SEEN NOTHING YET.
B1 中級 美國腔 新聞:土耳其軍方企圖發動政變推翻政府。 (BREAKING: Turkish Military Attempted Coup To Overthrow Government) 127 12 a0972861294 發佈於 2021 年 01 月 14 日 更多分享 分享 收藏 回報 影片單字