Placeholder Image

字幕列表 影片播放

  • ISRAEL VERSUS PALESTINE.

  • AND I KNOW THAT EVEN SAYING THAT

  • SENTENCE MEANS I'M LOSING

  • FOLLOWERS ON SOCIAL MEDIA.

  • THAT'S HOW CONTENTIOUS THIS

  • TOPIC IS.

  • BEFORE YOU EVEN FINISH THE

  • SENTENCE, PEOPLE ARE LIKE, "YOU

  • IDIOT!

  • HOW DARE YOU!

  • SHUT THE HELL UP!"

  • BUT, GUYS, WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT

  • IT, BECAUSE THIS IS ONE OF THE

  • MOST DIFFICULT STORIES THAT HAS

  • EXISTED IN OUR LIFETIME.

  • I MEAN, THERE ARE LOTS OF FIGHTS

  • THAT SEEM LIKE THEY WILL NEVER

  • COME TO AN END: INDIA VERSUS

  • PAKISTAN, CHINA VERSUS TIBET,

  • WHITE PEOPLE VERSUS RHYTHM.

  • BUT ISRAEL VERSUS PALESTINE IS A

  • 73-YEAR-OLD BEEF THAT HAS

  • STUMPED EVERBODY.

  • I MEAN, WHEN IT STUMPED JARED, YOU KNEW THAT THIS THING WAS

  • YOU KNEW THAT THIS THING WAS

  • DIFFICULT.

  • BUT THE PARODOX, THE PARODOX IS

  • THAT BECAUSE ISRAEL AND

  • PALESTINE HAS BEEN ONGOING FOR

  • SO LONG, PEOPLE FORGET THAT IT

  • IS ONGOING, UNTIL THERE ARE

  • FLARE-UPS THAT THE WORLD CANNOT

  • IGNORE, WHICH IS WHAT HAPPENED

  • AGAIN THIS WEEK.

  • >> OVERNIGHT, A DEADLY BARRAGE

  • FROM ISRAELI FORCES LIGHTING UP

  • THE SKIES OVER GAZA.

  • ( SIRENS )

  • AND IN THE WEST BANK, WARNING

  • SIRENS ECHOING THROUGH

  • BETHLEHEM.

  • EARLIER, PALESTINIAN MILITANT

  • GROUPS FIRING MORE THAN 200

  • ROCKETS INTO ISRAEL, MOST OF THE

  • HAMAS ROCKETS STOPPED BY

  • ISRAEL'S MISSILE DEFENSE SYSTEM,

  • OR THEY FELL SHORT.

  • ISRAELI STRIKES REPORTEDLY

  • KILLING AT LEAST 23 PEOPLE,

  • INCLUDING NINE CHILDREN, ISRAEL

  • SAYING THE DEAD WERE MILITANTS.

  • AT LEAST SIX ISRAELIS WERE

  • REPORTED INJURED.

  • TENSIONS HAD BEEN ESCALATING

  • OVER ISRAELI MOVES TO EVICT

  • PALESTINIAN FAMILIES FROM THEIR

  • HOMES IN EAST JERUSALEM.

  • THEY BOILED OVER AS MORE THAN

  • 100 WORSHIPPERS AND PROTESTERS

  • WERE INJURED AS ISRAELI POLICE

  • STORMED THE AL AQSA MOSQUE USING

  • TEAR GAS AND RUBBER BULLETS.

  • >> Trevor: YES, THIS WEEK, THE

  • CONFLICT ESCALATED AGAIN, AND

  • NOW DOZENS OF PEOPLE ARE DEAD.

  • INCLUDING CHILDREN.

  • AND, LOOK, MAN, WHAT MAKES

  • ISRAEL-PALESTINE SUCH A

  • DIFFICULT TOPIC TO EVEN BROCH

  • IS ALL THE LAYERS PACKED UNDER

  • IT.

  • NO MATTER HOW MUCH YOU TRY TO

  • BREAK IT DOWN, PEOPLE WILL SAY

  • YOU'RE LEAVING OUT SOME CRUCIAL

  • PIECE OF CONTEXT, AND THEY'RE

  • PROBABLY RIGHT.

  • I MEAN, THERE'S THE HISTORY OF

  • HOW ISRAEL BECAME A STATE AFTER

  • NAZI GERMANY TRIED TO DESTROY

  • THE JEWISH PEOPLE.

  • BUT THERE'S ALSO THE HISTORY OF

  • THE BRITISH TAKING THE LAND FROM

  • THE PALESTINIANS, NOT TO MENTION

  • THAT EVERY OTHER COUNTRY IN THE REGION HAS ITS OWN ISSUES AND

  • REGION HAS ITS OWN ISSUES AND

  • ITS OWN AGENDAS.

  • AND ON TOP OF ALL OF THAT,

  • THERE'S RELIGION INVOLVED.

  • AND RELIGION HAS NEVER CALMED

  • ANY SITUATION WHERE THERE'S A

  • CLASH.

  • WHAT MAKES IT EVEN HARDER IS THE

  • FACT THAT WHO'S RIGHT AND WHO'S

  • WRONG ALWAYS SEEMS TO CHANGE,

  • DEPENDING ON WHEN YOU START

  • MEASURING FROM.

  • THIS WEEK WAS THE PERFECT,

  • PERFECT EXAMPLE OF IT.

  • IF YOU START FROM "ISRAEL FIRED

  • ROCKETS INTO GAZA," THEN ISRAEL

  • IS THE BAD GUY, BECAUSE THEY'RE

  • BOMBING GAZA.

  • BUT THEN YOU TAKE A STEP BACK IN

  • TIME, YOU GO, "WELL, BUT HAMAS

  • FIRED ROCKETS AT ISRAEL."

  • THEN HAMAS IS THE BAD GUY.

  • BUT THEN YOU TAKE A STEP BACK,

  • AND YOU GO, "BUT THE ISRAELI

  • POLICE WENT IN AND STARTED

  • BEATING PEOPLE UP IN A MOSQUE

  • DURING RAMADAN, THE MOST HOLY

  • TIME IN THE MUSLIM CALENDAR."

  • WELL THEN, ISRAEL IS THE BAD

  • GUY.

  • BUT THEN YOU GO, "WELL THE

  • PALESTINIANS WERE THROWING

  • ROCKS..."

  • "WELL, THE ISRAELIS WERE KICKING

  • PEOPLE OUT OF THEIR HOMES..."

  • "WELL, THE INTIFADA..."

  • "WELL, ISRAEL KEEPS TAKING MORE

  • AND MORE LAND..."

  • "WELL, THE ARAB INVASION..."

  • AND BACK AND BACK AND BACK, AMD

  • WHO KNOWS HOW FAR.

  • THE FIRST CAVEMEN WHO HIT EACH

  • OTHER WITH CLUBS WERE PROBABLY

  • ISRAELI AND PALESTINIAN.

  • I DON'T KNOW.

  • AND, LOOK, I DON'T WANT TO HAVE

  • THAT ARGUMENT.

  • I DON'T WANT TO HAVE THE

  • ARGUMENT AND THE NOISE THAT

  • GOES BACK AND FORTH IN THIS

  • THING, BECAUSE, HONESTLY, I

  • DON'T THINK ANY TV SHOW IN 10

  • MINUTES IS GOING TO SOLVE

  • ISRAEL-PALESTINE.

  • TEN MINUTES ISN'T EVEN ENOUGH

  • TIME TO EXPLAIN THE MORTAL

  • KOMBAT" CONFLICT.

  • SO I'M NOT EVEN TRYING TO COME

  • IN AND DO THAT.

  • THE PART WHERE WE SAY WHO'S GOOD

  • AND WHO'S BAD, OR WHO STARTED

  • IT-- LET'S STEP AWAY FROM THAT.

  • INSTEAD LET'S ASK A DIFFERENT

  • QUESTION.

  • INSTEAD, LET'S LOOK AT WHO'S

  • DEAD AND WHO'S ALIVE THIS WEEK.

  • IN GAZA, ISRAELI AIR STRIKES

  • HAVE REPORTEDLY KILLED 28

  • PEOPLE, INCLUDING 10 CHILDREN.

  • OVER 150 PEOPOLE HAVE BEEN

  • WOUNDED.

  • IN ISRAEL, HAMAS ROCKETS HAVE

  • KILLED TWO PEOPLE.

  • AND THIS EXCHANGE OF FIRE COMES

  • AFTER THE ISRAELI ASSAULT IN AND

  • AROUND THE AL AQSA MOSQUE THAT

  • LEFT MORE THAN 600 PALESTINIAN

  • PROTESTERS, WORSHIPERS, AND

  • CIVILIANS WOUNDED, AND A FEW

  • DOZEN ISRAELI POLICE.

  • NOW, PERSONALLY-- I'M NOT SAYING

  • FOR YOU-- JUST PERSONALLY,

  • I CANNOT WATCH THAT FOOTAGE AND

  • HEAR THOSE NUMBERS, AND SEE A

  • FAIR FIGHT.

  • SET ASIDE MOTIVES AND

  • INTENTIONS, AND JUST LOOK AT

  • TECHNOLOGY, TECHNOLOGY ALONE.

  • ISRAEL HAS ONE OF THE MOST

  • POWERFUL MILITARIES IN THE

  • WORLD.

  • THEY CAN CRUSH GAZA LIKE TA.

  • NOT TO MENTION ONE OF THE MOST

  • ADVANCED DEFENSE SYSTEMS.

  • YOU SHOOT A ROCKET AT THEM, IT'S

  • PROBABLY NOT GOING TO DO

  • ANYTHING TO THEM BECAUSE OF THAT

  • DEFENSE SYSTEM.

  • RIGHT, THEY'VE GOT A GIANT

  • MOTUMBO IN THE SKY, JUST

  • KNOCKING THEM DOWN.

  • AND I KNOW, I KNOW THIS IS

  • CONTENTIOUS, AND I KNOW PEOPLE

  • ARE GOING TO HATE ME FOR THIS.

  • BUT I JUST WANT TO ASK AN HONEST

  • QUESTION HERE: IF YOU ARE IN A

  • FIGHT WHERE THE OTHER PERSON

  • CANNOT KNET YOU, HOW MUCH SHOULD

  • YOU RETALIATE WHEN THEY TRY TO

  • HURT YOU?

  • IT'S AN HONEST QUESTION.

  • I ASK THIS QUESTION BECAUSE I

  • THINK OF IT LIKE THIS: WHEN I

  • WAS A TEENAGER, I WOULD ALWAYS

  • GET INTO FIGHTS WITH MY LITTLE

  • BROTHERS.

  • AND LITTLE KIDS CAN BE VICIOUS.

  • THEY'RE TRYING TO PUNCH YOU IN

  • THE LEGS.

  • THEY'RE TRYING TO PUNCH YOU IN

  • THE NUTS.

  • THEY DO THAT.

  • BUT MY MOM WOULD SAY TO ME,

  • "TREVOR, DON'T HIT THE KID BACK,

  • BECAUSE THEY CAN'T HURT YOU.ñu3i

  • IS FOUR."

  • AND I WAS LIKE, "YEAH, BUT THE

  • KID IS HITTING ME!

  • HE COULD HURT ME!"

  • BUT MY MOM SAID, "YES, BUT

  • YOU'RE ALSO SO MUCH BIGGER THAN

  • THE KID.

  • YOU CAN CRUSH HIM IN AN

  • INSTANT."

  • AND PLEASE DON'T GET ME WRONG,

  • BECAUSE I KNOW SOMEONE WILL

  • WATCH THIS AND SAY YOU'RE

  • COMPARING PALESTINIANS TO

  • CHILDREN.

  • I'M NOT DOING THAT.

  • I'M TELLING A STORY ABOUT

  • MYSELF, HONESTLY, I AM.

  • WHAT MY MOM MADE ME UNDERSTAND

  • IS, AS THE PERSON WHO HAS

  • IMMENSELY MORE POWER, I

  • HAD TO ASK MYSELF WHETHER MY

  • RESPONSE TO THIS CHILD WAS JUST

  • OR NECESSARY.

  • COULD I FIND A DIFFERENT WAY TO

  • DEAL WITH THIS?

  • WHETHER I FELT AGGRIEVED OR NOT,

  • OR WHETHER THEY WERE FIGHTING

  • FAIR WAS ALMOST IRRELEVANT.

  • WAS I EVEN ABLE TO ASK MYSELF

  • THE QUESTION ABOUT WHY THEY WERE

  • DOING WHAT THEY WERE DOING?

  • WAS I WILLING TO ADMIT GUILT.

  • THIS IS ALL PART OF THE QUESTION

  • I HAD TO ASK MYSELF.

  • BUT THE MAIN QUESTION I ASK IN

  • THIS SITUATION IS ABOUT POWER.

  • AGAIN, I KNOW, IT'S NOT A GREAT

  • ANALOGY BECAUSE I'M NOT SAYING

  • PALESTINIANS ARE CHILDREN.

  • I'M NOT SAYING THEY'RE ALL

  • CHILDREN.

  • I'M NOT SAYING THEY'RE HARMLESS

  • OR IRRATIONAL OR ACTING OUT.

  • I'M NOT SAYING ANY OF THAT.

  • I'M NOT.

  • I'M TALKING ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE

  • IN POWER, WHICH IS SOMETHING WE

  • DO ALL THE TIME.

  • THINK ABOUT POLICING.

  • IF A MAN HAS A KNIFE, SHOULD THE

  • COPS SHOOT HIM?

  • IN MANY PARTS AROUND THE WORLD,

  • LIKE IN THE U.K., THEY SAY,

  • "WE'RE GOING TO DO EVERYTHING TO

  • TRY AND NOT SHOOT THE PERSON,

  • EVEN AT RISK TO OURSELVES,"

  • BECAUSE AT THE END OF THE DAY,

  • THEY BROUGHT A KNIFE TO A GUN

  • FIGHT.

  • SO WHAT'S THE RIGHT RESPONSE?

  • EVERYONE HAS DIFFERENT ANSWERS

  • TO THE QUESTION, AND I'M NOT

  • TRYING TO ANSWER THE QUESTION

  • NOR DO I THINK I'M SMART ENOUGH

  • TO SOLVE IT.

  • ALL I'M ASK IS WHEN YOU HAVE

  • THIS MUCH POWER, WHAT IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY?

ISRAEL VERSUS PALESTINE.

字幕與單字

單字即點即查 點擊單字可以查詢單字解釋

B1 中級 美國腔

以色列和巴勒斯坦衝突,為什麼不該簡化誰對誰錯?(Let’s Talk About the Israel-Palestine Conflict | The Daily Show)

  • 40 1
    Jay 發佈於 2023 年 11 月 15 日
影片單字